Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2621 W Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075
Phone: (580) 247-2344
Website: http://caffeitaliapizzeriaok.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Caffe Italia Pizzeria – Pauls Valley, OK – 2621 Grant Ave – Hours …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-9:00 PM; Shop address is 2621 Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 730752621 Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075; (580) 247-2344.
Caffe Italia Pizzaria OK | Pauls Valley OK – Facebook
Caffe Italia Pizzaria OK, Pauls Valley. 225 likes · 24 talking about this · 28 were here. A taste of Italy with small town charm!
Caffe Italia Pizzeria – 2621 Grant Ave, Pauls Valley, OK 73075 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Pauls Valley, OK! Caffe Italia Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Reviews
Inna Turcanu
We’re truckers, and my husband and I had such a wonderful experience at this restaurant! The lady who helped us was incredibly sweet and attentive, making us feel so welcome. The chef and owner went above and beyond—not only is he super friendly, but the food and desserts he made were absolutely delicious. Everything felt personal and warm, and we left completely satisfied. We can’t wait to come back!
There’s also alot of room for truck parking behind.
… moreThere’s also alot of room for truck parking behind.
Noel Thrasher
Truck stop lunch? Why yes, I will! This place has the ambiance and quality of any classic Italian restaurant available in the metro. Better if you ask me. Ive been to them all. The scratch kitchen delivered on each dish including the decadent tiramsu dessert. Our waitress, Chesney, was a delight and gave excellent recommendations. Longest & best review I’ve ever left and hard to believe its about an Italian spot at a Pro Mart Travel Plaza!
… moreHonor Martial Arts
Good service and attitude. Fresh rolls were fantastic. Food servicing size was crazy big. We highly recommend this restaurant! All 5 of us loved it.
… moreRachel Willock-Kennedy
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Culinary art in Paul’s Valley – passion on every plate ⭐️
From the very first bite, this dining experience was unforgettable.
I had the Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken — hands down, the best I’ve ever tasted! The Alfredo sauce was elegant, creamy, silky, and full of rich flavor. The chicken was tender, perfectly seasoned, and complemented the noodles — which were cooked flawlessly My husband had the Spaghetti “The Works”, and he was thoroughly impressed. Every bite was full of depth, comfort, and care. And he couldn’t stop talking about it. Every bite was layered with flavor — pure culinary craftsmanship. And the cheesecake… one taste and you’re right back in Grandma’s kitchen — homemade, heartwarming, and simply unforgettable. One taste brought back memories of home‑baked comfort — warm, nostalgic, and full of heart. This is authentic, soulful cooking. Nothing feels commercial here — it’s genuine, handcrafted food made with passion and pride. Paul’s Valley, you truly have a gem of a chef! His professionalism and artistry shine in every dish. The hospitality? Exceptional! Our servers made us feel right at home — relaxed, welcomed, never rushed. The chef even came out to chat with us afterward — what a treat! Such warmth and sincerity made the evening unforgettable. We left feeling like we’d just come home after being away too long. ❤️We left feeling like family — full, happy, and already planning our next visit. ❤️
If you haven’t been here yet, go. And if you have, go again (and again!). You’ll leave with a full heart and an even fuller smile. An unforgettable culinary experience — where passion, precision, and genuine hospitality meet in every bite. Paul’s Valley, OK
#LocalGem #FoodieFind #OklahomaEats #CulinaryArt #HiddenGem #SupportLocal #FoodLovers #ChefPassion #AuthenticFlavors #WorthTheTrip
… moreFrom the very first bite, this dining experience was unforgettable.
I had the Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken — hands down, the best I’ve ever tasted! The Alfredo sauce was elegant, creamy, silky, and full of rich flavor. The chicken was tender, perfectly seasoned, and complemented the noodles — which were cooked flawlessly My husband had the Spaghetti “The Works”, and he was thoroughly impressed. Every bite was full of depth, comfort, and care. And he couldn’t stop talking about it. Every bite was layered with flavor — pure culinary craftsmanship. And the cheesecake… one taste and you’re right back in Grandma’s kitchen — homemade, heartwarming, and simply unforgettable. One taste brought back memories of home‑baked comfort — warm, nostalgic, and full of heart. This is authentic, soulful cooking. Nothing feels commercial here — it’s genuine, handcrafted food made with passion and pride. Paul’s Valley, you truly have a gem of a chef! His professionalism and artistry shine in every dish. The hospitality? Exceptional! Our servers made us feel right at home — relaxed, welcomed, never rushed. The chef even came out to chat with us afterward — what a treat! Such warmth and sincerity made the evening unforgettable. We left feeling like we’d just come home after being away too long. ❤️We left feeling like family — full, happy, and already planning our next visit. ❤️
If you haven’t been here yet, go. And if you have, go again (and again!). You’ll leave with a full heart and an even fuller smile. An unforgettable culinary experience — where passion, precision, and genuine hospitality meet in every bite. Paul’s Valley, OK
#LocalGem #FoodieFind #OklahomaEats #CulinaryArt #HiddenGem #SupportLocal #FoodLovers #ChefPassion #AuthenticFlavors #WorthTheTrip
Shawn S
Best Italian food I’ve had. This is our second time here and it didn’t disappoint. My wife had the baked ziti (second time and just as good) and I tried the Pollo Rollantine ‘Valdostana” (chicken, veggies in a creamy garlic sauce). My dish had all the tastes going on so I was happy! The first time here I tried the vodka gnocchi, and loved it!
The service was great and food was very good! Just know that it’s made from scratch so it won’t be a quick in and out, but that’s the trade off for quality.
… moreThe service was great and food was very good! Just know that it’s made from scratch so it won’t be a quick in and out, but that’s the trade off for quality.
Heather Hodges
Don’t let the exterior fool you! This restaurant has to be one of the best highlights of this quaint little town. The food was amazing. We went on a Tuesday and had to come back on Wednesday. The ingredients were fresh. The flavors and portions were perfect. I wish I lived closer to it. Hannah our server was amazing. She was very cordial and efficient. CAFFE ITALIA A+++
… moreJoan A
We enjoyed a delicious pasta dinner accompanied by warm rolls. I chose lemon garlic shrimp which included mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, and artichoke hearts in a creamy lemon garlic sauce. Scrumptious! My husband picked the garlic shrimp on fettuccine. The shrimp were huge and cooked perfectly. What a wonderful find in the small town of Paul’s Valley. The outside of the restaurant looks like nothing, but the food was excellent. We also enjoyed the cheesecake for dessert. Homemade and so yummy!
… morewillie coats (Karath Ben Judah)
I’ve been eating here since it opened, I’ve always been treated kindly by the main chefs and his staff, the food is excellent and try something different every time, you can’t beat the price.. 5 stars forsure
… morebuitabo96
Guy Fieri would call this place a hidden gem!! Homemade authentic food at affordable prices in middle of Oklahoma? Amy is a fantastic server with just the right amount of attention for the customer and Chef Blair clearly cares about his clientele – asked about food preferences and allergies before he made everything. The Campo salad was fresh, crisp and filling. Hearty baked ziti, and freshly made tiramisu along with italian roast! Kudos to all…will come back.
… moreMan Rex
Nice place and the service is ok,
the deserts are also great but..pasta? Is a different story,I asked for a pasta carbonara or spaghetti carbonara and is not good at all not even taste good lack of many condiments,there are greats videos on YouTube about spaghetti carbonara the “chef “ can learn real good there.
… morethe deserts are also great but..pasta? Is a different story,I asked for a pasta carbonara or spaghetti carbonara and is not good at all not even taste good lack of many condiments,there are greats videos on YouTube about spaghetti carbonara the “chef “ can learn real good there.