Convenience store-based pizza chain doling out create-your-own pies along with wings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1632 Pleasant Valley Blvd, Altoona, PA 16602
Phone: (814) 942-1900
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Brother’s Pizza New York Style Delivery Menu – Altoona – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Brother’s Pizza New York Style in Altoona! View Brother’s Pizza New York Style’s February 2026 deals and menus.
Brother’s Pizza Altoona New York Style (1632 Pleasant Valley Blvd)
From any restaurant in Altoona • From tacos to Titos, textbooks to MacBooks, Postmates is the app that delivers – anything from anywhere, in minutes.
Brother’s pizza altoona new york style – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Brother’s pizza altoona new york style at 1632 Pleasant Valley Blvd in Altoona. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
Andrew Dolan
A small, local pizza shop well worth the trip. Close to a major avenue so easy to get to and there should be plenty of parking in the lot. This may also be because the dining area is tiny, most people likely get takeout or delivery.
They serve great New York Style pizzas, as well as stromboli, sandwiches and typical pizza shop appetizers. The crust is spot-on being foldable in the middle while standing up to plenty of toppings and thick and crispy on the outside. Extra toppings are good quality and generous. The pizza prices are quite reasonable though extra toppings are a bit pricey.
This location is worth checking out if you want to explore local authentic pizza shops!
… moreThey serve great New York Style pizzas, as well as stromboli, sandwiches and typical pizza shop appetizers. The crust is spot-on being foldable in the middle while standing up to plenty of toppings and thick and crispy on the outside. Extra toppings are good quality and generous. The pizza prices are quite reasonable though extra toppings are a bit pricey.
This location is worth checking out if you want to explore local authentic pizza shops!
Crystal Garnett
First time we have been here under new management. People were nice but…. food doesn’t taste the same. This place was always a go to spot everytime I came into town. Pizza was OK, sauce is definitely not the same, Mushrooms are not seasoned. Really disappointed.
… moreBrandon Murphy
The pizza I ordered last night two cheese pizzas tasted horrible me and my girlfriend couldn’t believe how nasty it was and I’m from Waynesboro Pa and there pizza down there taste way better then Altoona pa does wow we both have stomach problems today cause of it and wow I’m so sad about it cause there one of my favorites
… moreBrad
Pizza was some of the best I have had. New York style. Ate here 2 times and would recommend to anyone. Pizza was so good.
… moreRidge Bowers
I haven’t been to the Pleasant Valley Blvd Brother’s, but figured that since it is a franchise, it would be similar to Bellwood’s Brothers. Nope.
I ordered a family size stromboli, there was a single slice of ham, one after another, so maybe 4 or 5 pieces of ham in total and observed up to 10 pepperoni slices. This definitely was not worth $22.50 in my opinion.
The only reason I gave 2 stars, is because it had a fair amount of cheese.
I don’t know if I’m being too picky, but definitely didn’t meet expectations.
… moreI ordered a family size stromboli, there was a single slice of ham, one after another, so maybe 4 or 5 pieces of ham in total and observed up to 10 pepperoni slices. This definitely was not worth $22.50 in my opinion.
The only reason I gave 2 stars, is because it had a fair amount of cheese.
I don’t know if I’m being too picky, but definitely didn’t meet expectations.
Betty White
We haven’t had brothers in years bc it just went down hill. We seen there was new owners and gave it a try. We got a large meat stromboli, a calzone, and a large salad. The boli and calzone was cooked perfectly and I liked the new style. Our poor delivery driver was soaked from the rain.We will def be back.
… moreColin Symons
Continues to be the best pizza in Altoona. New owners seem to have kept the best parts. Service was very polite and on time.
… moreRobin Walz
I just ordered some food from this place via doordash and TBH I was nervous because normally when I try a new place it’s not good..Needless to say I was pleasantly surprised..Everything was delicious…10 out of 10 .I would definitely recommend..❤️
… moreBarry Ch
New owners as of 7/15/2025. I’m a new customer here and will stay thst way. Came in on opening day and got a couple of strombolis. The strombolis were good but the marinara dipping sauce was soooooo good. New owner was friendly and had a family vibe to the place. Will be back the next time I’m craving a Stromboli
… moreMartin Haigh
Did they fire the other cook Stromboli not the same? That person has no clue how a Stromboli is made very disappointed!!! Guess ill find another place bought from brothers since hills and riverside was at the station mall.
… more