Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 106 W Pearl St, Trafalgar, IN 46181
Phone: (317) 878-9988
Website: http://smalltownpizzasubco.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Small Town Pizza & Sub Co.
We at Small Town Pizza & Sub Co. strive to produce great-tasting, quality food, and great guest service in a friendly, clean atmosphere.
Small Town Pizza & Sub Co. | Trafalgar IN – Facebook
Come join us for great music and great food where friends gather small town pizza and sub co trafalgar.
Small Town Pizza Sub Co.: Delight in Farm-Fresh Flavors in Trafalgar
Small Town Pizza & Sub Co., located in the heart of Trafalgar, IN, offers a delightful menu that celebrates comfort food with a personal touch.
Reviews
Joey McIntosh
⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (4/5)
This was our second visit to Small Town Pizza and Sub and once again we had a great experience. My wife and I stopped in for pickup. I ordered their “pizza roll” (basically a calzone) with Italian sausage, mushrooms, green bell peppers, and onions. It was huge and absolutely delicious — I could only eat half!
We also shared the stuffed pizza sticks with regular sausage. They’re very different from what you might expect, but in a good way. We liked that they had their own unique style. We got both cheese dip and marinara on the side, which paired great with them.
My wife ordered a pizza bowl with mushrooms, onions, sausage, and tomatoes. It was loaded with cheese and had plenty of sauce.
We’re giving four stars because the pizza sauce is a little on the sweet side, and we personally prefer a more savory sauce. That said, the service was excellent and the food quality was top-notch. No real complaints at all.
They have a big variety — wings, subs, pizzas, and more. Definitely worth checking out. We’ll be back!
… moreThis was our second visit to Small Town Pizza and Sub and once again we had a great experience. My wife and I stopped in for pickup. I ordered their “pizza roll” (basically a calzone) with Italian sausage, mushrooms, green bell peppers, and onions. It was huge and absolutely delicious — I could only eat half!
We also shared the stuffed pizza sticks with regular sausage. They’re very different from what you might expect, but in a good way. We liked that they had their own unique style. We got both cheese dip and marinara on the side, which paired great with them.
My wife ordered a pizza bowl with mushrooms, onions, sausage, and tomatoes. It was loaded with cheese and had plenty of sauce.
We’re giving four stars because the pizza sauce is a little on the sweet side, and we personally prefer a more savory sauce. That said, the service was excellent and the food quality was top-notch. No real complaints at all.
They have a big variety — wings, subs, pizzas, and more. Definitely worth checking out. We’ll be back!
claudi
Great pizza, one of the best I’ve had. My dad really liked the cheesy bread, it’s delicious, and we took some to go. The man serving us was nice as well, thank you!
… moreH
Loves the food! Best Pizza ive had in a long time! Raspberry tea is great. And they even gave me some sald dressing to take home since I liked it so much, great prices, great service wouldn’t change a thing!
… moreJennifer Buras
This pizza place is a hidden gem. We found it one night after a football game. It was late and we were hungry and most places were closed. We went to Small Town because according to Google it looked like they would still be open. We got out of the car & walked toward the building but it looked like they would be closing soon so we were hesitant to go in but the server came outside & told us they were open. So we went in, I felt a little guilty about going in cuz it was so close to closing time but the server rolled out the red carpet for us and treated us like royalty! On top of that my boys were requesting a customized pizza and the server was all into helping them with their order. One would think the server would be rolling his eyes thinking “please, just put your order in!”, but no, the server, whose name is Kegan, was all in to helping us just before closing time, it was amazing! Every time we have gone back, Kegan has been our server and has given us the same royal treatment, on top of that, the pizza is amazing and they have all kinds of other good stuff like fried pickles & onion rings.
I will tell you something else. I wanted to have a graduation party for my son who attended Indian Creek. The conundrum was that we live in Greenwood so I was trying to figure out a good place to have the party that was fairly close to where my child’s friends were. So I was talking about this with a friend of mine and my other son said “have it at Small Town Pizza”. Me and my friend looked at each other & said “that’s a great idea!”. So that night I called Small Town and asked them if they did parties at their place and sure enough they have a whole enclosed outdoor grassy area with a patio and tables that’s perfect for parties! So that is where we had my son’s graduation party and it was perfect! On top of that, I requested my favorite server Kegan to be there. The owner said it was his day off so I didn’t expect him to be there but he actually came in on his day off to help me with my son’s grad party! I couldn’t believe he came in on his day off! That was the icing in the cake! I totally recommend this place! They have great food, they are warm and friendly and treat you like royalty! Go there for dinner and have your next party/event there! You will be happy you did!
… moreI will tell you something else. I wanted to have a graduation party for my son who attended Indian Creek. The conundrum was that we live in Greenwood so I was trying to figure out a good place to have the party that was fairly close to where my child’s friends were. So I was talking about this with a friend of mine and my other son said “have it at Small Town Pizza”. Me and my friend looked at each other & said “that’s a great idea!”. So that night I called Small Town and asked them if they did parties at their place and sure enough they have a whole enclosed outdoor grassy area with a patio and tables that’s perfect for parties! So that is where we had my son’s graduation party and it was perfect! On top of that, I requested my favorite server Kegan to be there. The owner said it was his day off so I didn’t expect him to be there but he actually came in on his day off to help me with my son’s grad party! I couldn’t believe he came in on his day off! That was the icing in the cake! I totally recommend this place! They have great food, they are warm and friendly and treat you like royalty! Go there for dinner and have your next party/event there! You will be happy you did!
Jaci Shields
We stopped in on a Friday night and even had live music. Prices are Very good and you get what you pay for. Quality and flavor of the food is Amazing. We will Deffinately go back regulary.
… moreSeth Cummings
Some of the best local pizza I have had in a good while. The pizza is great and the breadsticks are next level, to say the least. In addition, they deliver. As in 12 miles away. The only food delivery I have had in the 11 years I have lived at this address. Everything was still hot and fresh when it arrived, about an hour after ordering. Head and shoulders above any chains in the area.
… moreJuanita Graham
I love going there it’s like being with my own family. Everyone is very nice and the food is great I had a Blt stromboli. It was cooked just the way I like it. I also had a salad and it was fresh lettuce no old stuff. The prices was good for the smile on my face. If you like great pizzas and strombolis or a wonderful salad you should look in to this place.
… moreJuanita Graham
We love that place and we have lots of fun. The food is delicious and lots to choose from. They are on one floor that has a handy capped door and bathroom. They open at 4pm
… moreJustin Smith
This is a good spot for pizza. Had it on Christmas Eve and really liked it. Was typical midwest style, like Jack’s. Guys were great that worked there.
… moreKris. Serna
Pizza was great. The wings were amazing. My friend ate the tenderloin she thought it was the best.
… more