Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Counter-service place offering hot & cold subs on house-baked bread, plus pizza, calzones & salads.
Hours
| Monday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 379 S Idaho St, Wendell, ID 83355
Phone: (208) 536-2505
Website: https://papakelseyssubs.toast.site/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Kelsey’s Pizza
Papa Kelsey’s Pizza. … Wendell, ID 83355 (208) 536-2505. MON-THURS: 11am-8pm. FRI & SAT: 11am-9pm. SUN …
Menu – Papa Kelsey’s
Menu. 379 South Idaho Street, Wendell, ID. Change location. Baked Subs. Pizzas … Papa Kelsey’s Lunch Menu (Wendell). Baked Subs. Italian Combo Sub. Ham …
Papa Kelsey’s
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Twin Falls, ID, Twin Falls, ID, Buhl, ID.
Reviews
Bird Fleck
The food is SO GOOD! You need to go here! I’ve had the subs before and they blow my mind.
I had a breakfast burrito and it was perfection! My friend got the breakfast pizza and it looked really good too! She said it was. It was super cold there but the food warmed us up.
… moreI had a breakfast burrito and it was perfection! My friend got the breakfast pizza and it looked really good too! She said it was. It was super cold there but the food warmed us up.
Whitney Hankel
Overcharged, food was terrible, 2 pizzas were made completely wrong! I get server bad migraines eating anything tomato based. Specifically requested 2 of them to be made with ranch base instead of pizza sauce. Drove in a bad snow storm to get them and came back home to 2 being made wrong and the 1 pizza for the kids tasted like it had rotten cheese!! All I asked for was a refund of all my money!! Especially being over charged!! Deal was 2 medium 2 topping pizzas for $20.99! I got charged $61.24 for 4 medium pizzas!! If it were The Gines or the Sears that still owned the restaurant they would have done me right!! NEVER AGAIN WILL I EVER RECOMMEND THIS PLACE NOR WILL I EVER EAT HERE AGAIN!!!
… moreRachael Douglas
My husband called and placed an order around 6 pm, he asked for a hawaiian pizza sub & a light onion french dip (he had to ask for light onions 4 times!).. we brought it home. My husband has a regular pizza sub no pineapple whatsoever. My French dip is covered & I mean covered in onions. My husband’s fry sauce is broken and spilled in his fries.. oh and half were burnt. For not a single person eating in there at the time of order… cmon.
… morej watson
really really good pizza, i definitely recommend if ur in the area, I observed , most just get to go, but there’s are plenty of tables
… moreDeez Nuttz
Every time I travel along I-84, I am greeted with a warm welcome from Sam and his son, which makes my journey all the more enjoyable. They have gone above and beyond by waiting for me even after closing hours just to ensure that I could savor my favorite Turkey Special. I can’t help but spread the word to every trucker I encounter, encouraging them to make a stop at this wonderful place! The only difficulty I face is indulging in that incredible cinnamon roll—it’s truly a delightful challenge! This establishment brings so much joy to my travels, and I want to express my heartfelt gratitude to everyone for their outstanding hospitality and kindness. I love you guys
Bee Jaye
… moreBee Jaye
Angie Bohan
I like the food and have eaten there several times. It can be a bit pricey. I have had the ice cream in the past and it was really good. Went for ice cream tonight and was told they don’t have ice cream. The sign says otherwise! WTH?
… moreKytyn Matney
Pretty good pizza. Friendly counter person and very clean restaurant. Pizza has a medium crust with a nice crunchy bottom. The usual kind of sauce and cheese, pepperoni and mushrooms not liberally placed – could have used more to be an average portion of toppings.
… moreChad Olson
Horrible pizza. Great people. Don’t do it. Huge waste of money and experience!
… moreJordan Allen
It’s my all time favorite sandwich. And it has been my favorite sandwich for over 30 years. I just wish there was as much focus on creating a great atmosphere as there is creating an excellent sandwich. (A portable radio for music?) But I’ll be back. And my kids will be back. It’s the best!
… moreJessica Avalanche
By war one of the best pizzas in the region. It was worth friving off the freeway for this pizza. Our new must stop by place whenever we’re driving by
… more