

Cozy, rustic Italian restaurant with two bars and a private outdoor table, offering seafood and vegetarian dishes, plus cocktails.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 453 6th Ave, New York, NY 10011
Phone: (212) 777-0057
Website: http://www.osteria57.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Osteria57 |Fish & Vegetarian New York – Osteria57
OSTERIA 57 (@osteria57) · New York, NY – Instagram
Osteria 57: New York City Restaurant, Greenwich Village
Reviews
The gnocchi funghi e tartufo
What can I say? There are no words. Only dreams and flash backs and hopes of returning to experience this delightful meal one more time.
The restaurant vibe is awesome, service was great. Even though it was super super busy, the waiters were still available and friendly. The cocktails are really good.
We started with the scallops and the ricotta truffle toast, both of which were excellent. The scallops were beautifully prepared and the truffle toast was rich and flavorful without being overwhelming.
For the main course we had the pescatarian del giorno. The branzino was perfectly cooked with a lovely char from the grill. We paired it with grilled mushrooms and roasted fingerling potatoes with a confit garlic purée, which were both outstanding and complemented the fish perfectly.
What really stood out was the hospitality. We arrived around 9:30pm, knowing the kitchen was closing around 10, so we were already grateful they were willing to seat us. The team kept apologizing for the timing and pace of service, but honestly there was nothing to apologize for. They were welcoming, attentive, and made us feel completely taken care of.
The atmosphere is warm and homey, and the bar is one of the most beautiful in the city.
A wonderful meal from start to finish. Huge thanks to Behrouz and the team for making it such a lovely evening. We’ll absolutely be back.
Food was nice as well, I’d recommend sea food lovers to go cause I remember them saying that they are a pescatarian restaurant.
The only dishes that made more of an impression were the appetizers— the truffle ricotta toast and cod croquettes were very light and fresh.
The entrée tasted pretty average and the portions were slightly smaller than expected.
I jumped over to their espresso bar right next-door and enjoyed a delicious pastry as well as a double espresso. The bartender was also very kind and attentive. Definitely will be returning. I appreciate their fresh gluten-free pasta and vegetable selection.
However, the food left something to be desired. Despite the pasta being homemade, it tasted quite plain and didn’t stand out. The one dish that did impress me was the truffle ricotta, which was a delicious appetizer worth trying.
In terms of pricing, it’s in line with the area—cocktails around $20 and main dishes about $30. Overall, it’s a great spot for drinks and a cozy atmosphere, but the food may not leave a lasting impression.
The interior was beautiful and charming. Highly recommended!