Social Profile: ![]()
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 9 AM–2 PM |
| Tuesday | 9 AM–5 PM |
| Wednesday | 9 AM–5 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM–5 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM–5 PM |
| Saturday | 9 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2552 W 45th St, Highland, IN 46322
Phone: (219) 924-6464
Website: http://www.butterfingersbakerynwi.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Butterfingers Bakery NWI
Our display cases are always full of delicious cupcakes, flavored bars, cookies and more to keep your sweet tooth happy. Call our Highland store for information …
Butterfingers, a Dessert Shop & Delicatessen | Highland IN – Facebook
Stop by Highland Butterfingers to purchase your cupcake kit! Call 219-924-6464 to see what flavors are available for the day.
Butterfingers – “A dessert and delicatessen shop”
… We have been serving the Highland and Munster area for over 30 years and are dedicated to quality and ensuring our patrons enjoy every dish & dessert…
Reviews
Alex S
The highest cheesecake price online is $45. I just paid $55 (cash) for mine. If I had more time before the birthday party, I would have gotten something different somewhere else. While they may have just forgotten to update their prices in an honest fashion, a 22% unexpected up charge isn’t something customers feel good about…especially in a pinch.
… moreKath UEP
50/50…their cakes & cupcakes are phenomenal. This time I bought 6 different pastries..
1 was good (apple pastry/bar)
1 ok. (Cherry slice)
The rest were very disappointing.
Lemon bar….consistency indicated dream whip or a gelatin mixed in for texture. It was not what a lemon bar s/b.
Cannoli: the filling was…idk what but not ricotta or marscapone. Soggy…tasted like frosting filling.
I still…am a fan of everything else here but so crushed at these items.
… more1 was good (apple pastry/bar)
1 ok. (Cherry slice)
The rest were very disappointing.
Lemon bar….consistency indicated dream whip or a gelatin mixed in for texture. It was not what a lemon bar s/b.
Cannoli: the filling was…idk what but not ricotta or marscapone. Soggy…tasted like frosting filling.
I still…am a fan of everything else here but so crushed at these items.
Jenny Griffin
I purchased the apple crumb bar, cranberry bar and chicken salad. Everything was tasty.
… moreDJ SWQUO
Delicious! The chicken salad sandwich crossaint is sooooo good! Make sure that you add banana peppers!
… moreDerm Light
Best cakes ever! Great salad selection esp turkey cheese grape salad & chicken salad
… moreChas Applegate
The food is good. A little pricey. Can get crowded standing in line for carryout. They are not very nice to their employees at all.
… moreOfelia Tovar
We loved our velvet Birthday cake, it was delicious, we thank you on how much love you put into these cakes! Thank you. 🙂
… moreC Sanders
The sandwiches are excellent and always fresh. The salad are great, especially the seafood pasta salad. The desserts are additive especially banana cake, coconut, and the butterscotch oatmeal cookies are to die for whenever they are in stock.
… moreV Stark
Delicious food, great prices and super nice staff. First time here and I will return here again.
… moreNina
Love Butterfingers but customer service has gone downhill. I ordered a cake for a birthday to be ready for pick up at 2pm. Arrived at 2:30 and the cake was not ready. The girl actually took a cake from the case and went to write happy birthday on the cake.
… more