Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Matty’s Bar & Grille prides itself on our core values of Community and Incomparable Hospitality. Our property has something for everyone from our WI Sports Pub featuring a dynamic display of fine WI Sports art to our cream city brick window walled all seasons dining and party area. Not to mention a premier outdoor patio area featuring seating for 100, firepit, rain awnings and radiant heaters available. Beyond that is our Rustic Bar and Tented Terrace Space which can handle live music events, reunions, weddings, backyard BBQ’s, corporate events and much more….comfortable for 50 to 750.
Classic sports bar serving burgers & pub food in a lively TV-filled space & out on a covered patio.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 14460 College Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151
Phone: (414) 427-3838
Website: http://www.mattysbar.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Matty’s Bar & Grille
Your WI Sports Team Authority featuring a chef inspired menu in a friendly, casual sports bar atmosphere. Lunch and dinner are served seven days a week and …
Matty’s Bar & Grille, New Berlin, WI – OpenTable
Guests can grab a Smokehouse Burger at the traditional front bar, enjoy a gourmet pizza or family dinner in the warm and inviting Four Seasons Room.
Matty’s Bar & Grille (@mattysbarandgrille) – Instagram
Buffalo Trace’s newest release has officially landed at Matty’s, and we’re one of the first locations in Wisconsin to receive it. We’ve secured just 60 bottles …
Reviews
Anup M (Ace Eyes)
First visit to Matty’s Bar & Grille — and I get why everyone loves this place! Great food, lively atmosphere, and genuine hospitality all around. Huge shout-out to Christine for her incredible service — she kept everything smooth and welcoming start to finish.
Tried their Larceny Bourbon — must-try if you enjoy a good pour! Plenty of parking, multiple event spaces, and a team that clearly takes pride in what they do. I’ll definitely be back! ✨
… moreTried their Larceny Bourbon — must-try if you enjoy a good pour! Plenty of parking, multiple event spaces, and a team that clearly takes pride in what they do. I’ll definitely be back! ✨
Lil B
Always a 10/10. Love the fish street tacos and breakfast tacos. The Bloody Mary drinks are always super delicious. Only downside is when you sit at the bar it feels like they’re rushing you out. After 20 mins of getting food and drinks they’re asking if you want the box and check. Overall very good place.
… moreAlex Graber
As a fish fry connoisseur, Matty’s holds strong in my top 3! The batter is crispy and light. Three huge battered fillets. The potato pancakes are crispy on the outside yet soft in the center with great flavor. The coleslaw is tasty, and you can’t go wrong with marble rye bread. It was very filling! I walked by someone who got the baked cod and it was a huge fillet with paprika. It looked great.
A couple criticisms include that this particular time, our appetizers were brought out about one minute before the meal, which doesn’t even make me want them anymore. Major pet peeve of mine. The entrées were fired way too early. A couple of other people in my party ordered another round of drinks and mentioned how they tasted completely different than the first time. The server graciously had them remade, but they were still off. My Matty’s old fashioned (bourbon, on tap) was great, and that dirty cherry is everything! I could eat those by the jar.
Nonetheless, a well-deserved five stars in terms of the fish fry. Just some of the other components bring down the overall rating. I would just recommend taking your time ordering entrées if you order appetizers and sticking to their cocktail list.
… moreA couple criticisms include that this particular time, our appetizers were brought out about one minute before the meal, which doesn’t even make me want them anymore. Major pet peeve of mine. The entrées were fired way too early. A couple of other people in my party ordered another round of drinks and mentioned how they tasted completely different than the first time. The server graciously had them remade, but they were still off. My Matty’s old fashioned (bourbon, on tap) was great, and that dirty cherry is everything! I could eat those by the jar.
Nonetheless, a well-deserved five stars in terms of the fish fry. Just some of the other components bring down the overall rating. I would just recommend taking your time ordering entrées if you order appetizers and sticking to their cocktail list.
Arthur Scheller
I ordered the pork schnitzel with mushroom gravy which comes with mashed potatoes and sauteed asparagus. The dinner was excellent! The schnitzel was breaded and fried and very big. It was fairly thick but still moist and crunchy, just how a German likes it!
This entree was on their special Oktoberfest menu for the month of October. I think they should offer this entree year around! The service was prompt, very efficient, humorous, and neighborly! Matty’s has a lot of tv’s to watch sports and ample parking in the back.
… moreThis entree was on their special Oktoberfest menu for the month of October. I think they should offer this entree year around! The service was prompt, very efficient, humorous, and neighborly! Matty’s has a lot of tv’s to watch sports and ample parking in the back.
Mary Deischel
Fun atmosphere, good food, cold beer and drinks. We came for the Friday fish fry and it was delicious. It was a little busy, but there was no wait for seating, and there was plenty of parking. We saw folks with kids in high chairs, and what looked like a first date. 100 percent recommend.
… moreNora Barton
We spend every Thanksgiving here. The food is wonderful and plentiful. Servers have a nearly impossible job, yet they stay on top of everything like a well-oiled machine. I highly recommend!
… moreAl Wichman
Stopped on whim and glad we did. Service was A+, drinks were perfect, not too strong, but not all watered down. I ordered soup and my friend ordered the Jack Daniels chili, both were really good. Our dinners came out fast and were really good. I had the patty melt and she had the braised short ribs with shrimp. Got the check and thought it was a mistake, two people with drinks, appetizers, and mains for under 75. For the quality of food, drinks, and service I was expecting a lot more. But Matty’s does it right, fair prices, quality people working there, and quality food. Will definitely visit again.
… moreJustine Filapek
As a Lift driver I have picked up and dropped off many people at Matty’s. I finally took the opportunity to go myself. For a Sunday brunch – BEFORE Easter.
The dining area we were in was open and bright. We were seated close to the back door which is accessible in cold weather even though it opens directly into the dining room from outside. So we were kind of cold as the wind hit us every time that door opened. The tables were very small and the chairs did not feel sturdy at all.
The service was wonderful. Our server was prompt and friendly. Absolutely love the running of cards right at the table. She was always keeping an eye on us, but was never intrusive.
The food was okay. Nothing special, but certainly not bad. I got the Brisket Skillet. There was an overall lack of flavor. Like not even seasoned with salt and pepper before cooking the eggs or potatoes. The menu description included that it had cheese sauce on it. Nope. No cheese at all. The brisket itself was quite delicious though. After taking the leftovers home, I was able to bring it to life with some cheese and seasoning on the reheat. maybe they’re just not a “brunch place.” Or maybe they had an off day.
The vibe was fun enough though to warrant going back and trying dinner.
… moreThe dining area we were in was open and bright. We were seated close to the back door which is accessible in cold weather even though it opens directly into the dining room from outside. So we were kind of cold as the wind hit us every time that door opened. The tables were very small and the chairs did not feel sturdy at all.
The service was wonderful. Our server was prompt and friendly. Absolutely love the running of cards right at the table. She was always keeping an eye on us, but was never intrusive.
The food was okay. Nothing special, but certainly not bad. I got the Brisket Skillet. There was an overall lack of flavor. Like not even seasoned with salt and pepper before cooking the eggs or potatoes. The menu description included that it had cheese sauce on it. Nope. No cheese at all. The brisket itself was quite delicious though. After taking the leftovers home, I was able to bring it to life with some cheese and seasoning on the reheat. maybe they’re just not a “brunch place.” Or maybe they had an off day.
The vibe was fun enough though to warrant going back and trying dinner.
Joe Frank
Came here for lunch on a warm November day wanted to sit outside.
We didn’t realize that the menu at the outside seating area was different than the menu inside the bar.
It really wasn’t that big of a deal. We went inside and ordered our food.
I’m really glad we did! I got the Muskego Pizza burger, which was perfect Italian sausage with onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese and spaghetti sauce served on a toasted bun. My wife got the brisket burger, which she couldn’t stop going on about! The french fries were like little scoops And very unique!
It was a great atmosphere with lots of sports on TV and very busy inside as well as outside on a Saturday afternoon.
There were four of us at the table, and although the place was very busy, service was incredibly fast and very attentive. I will return on a colder day to try their French onion soup that I saw someone else order.
… moreWe didn’t realize that the menu at the outside seating area was different than the menu inside the bar.
It really wasn’t that big of a deal. We went inside and ordered our food.
I’m really glad we did! I got the Muskego Pizza burger, which was perfect Italian sausage with onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese and spaghetti sauce served on a toasted bun. My wife got the brisket burger, which she couldn’t stop going on about! The french fries were like little scoops And very unique!
It was a great atmosphere with lots of sports on TV and very busy inside as well as outside on a Saturday afternoon.
There were four of us at the table, and although the place was very busy, service was incredibly fast and very attentive. I will return on a colder day to try their French onion soup that I saw someone else order.
Scott W
I like Matty’s. The venue is spacious and comfortable. It has really expanded (and continues) over the years. The service and food is usually good, but not always consistent.
Stopped in last night with another couple. Had a couple of excellent burgers and fries. The waitress did a great job. Very attentive and super friendly (thanks Jenny).
… moreStopped in last night with another couple. Had a couple of excellent burgers and fries. The waitress did a great job. Very attentive and super friendly (thanks Jenny).