Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Top Shelf Pizza- Honeoye, NY – Facebook
Top Shelf Pizza Est in 2005–Dine-in, Take-out and Delivery on all menu items. Pizza, Wings, Calzones
Top Shelf Pizza: A Premier Destination for Delicious Pizza in …
A delightful gem located at 4905 E Lake Rd, Honeoye, NY. This restaurant has quickly gained a reputation for serving up some of the best pizza in the area.
Top Shelf Pizza – CLOSED, 4905 E Lake Rd, Honeoye, NY 14471, US
Top Shelf Pizza is a cozy pizzeria nestled in the heart of Honeoye, NY, serving up a variety of delicious pizzas and Italian dishes.
Reviews
John Law
Solid. Value. Consistent. I like grabbing a sub or wings from once or twice a month. The food is always consistent and lots of it. I’m never disappointed. I usually order it to pick up and it’s about 25-40 minutes. Food is hot. The girls check you out quick. The taste is way above average. I attached a recent menu because they don’t have a huge online presence. Probably because they stay busy even without it. $11 for a large steak bomber.
… moreVince Sampson
Ordered based on the menu and prices posted. When I was over charged and questioned it I was told oh a customer must have posted it. Are you kidding me??? It’s the menu phamlet from Top Shelf Pizza. Bad enough they would not honor the advertised prices, but the food was disgusting, definitely not worth the cost. The chicken wings are so dried out the skin is cracking. There is zero sauce on them or in the container. The fried mushrooms are all breading, the actual mushrooms are the size of my thumb nail. And the Jalapeno poppers were all breading and cheese, very little actual pepper. Disgusting. Definitely will go elsewhere next time. I don’t like false advertising and disgusting food. Not to mention poor customer service.
… moreAmy VanOrden
I called in my order of pizza logs and asked it they could be lightly fried and they said yes. I got home and they weren’t what I asked for.
… moreNick Kalynycz
Looking for a home town pizza shop with banging pizza? We’ll kids, here it is. Great pizza, hands down
… moreKevin B. Leigh
Great vacation food.
We ordered the usual chicken wings and pizza, and are always a little nervous when we try a new place.
But to our surprise the food was delicious and the service was fast and my teenage boys are happy. What more can you ask for
… moreWe ordered the usual chicken wings and pizza, and are always a little nervous when we try a new place.
But to our surprise the food was delicious and the service was fast and my teenage boys are happy. What more can you ask for
E D
Definitely best pizza for the area. With me I grew up with the original marks pizza.
… moreMark Williams
I ordered last night and there was a mix up on one of the items, the owner or manager made it right and got it out to us quickly. The food was great and their customer service was excellent. Thank you all at Top Shelf for being the best in town.
… morePatricia Gilbert
I hate to complain and I understand it was New Year’s Eve and very, very busy, but, when you’re using the fryers with that kind of intensity, I think you should be having the employees change the oil more often. My wings had a very greasy nasty flavor to them, which has never happened to me before at Top Shelf.
… morebarbara franklin
It looks like a hole in the wall. The staff is great as is the pizza!!! Huge slices and very cheap!!! Fresh and delicious!!
… more