Joshua
Excellent service. My server was great and small talked football with my son and I. Fun personality. Atmosphere was perfect, very lively.
We got our salad and bread sticks and they were spot on as always. Delicious Alfredo Dipping Sauce won the spot light .
My son ordered Crispy Chicken fettuccine with Broccoli and I ordered from “lighter portions” menue, fettuccine. Dish was beautiful, his chicken beautifully breaded and cooked too. Our only complain was the lack of sauce. Both dishes were a tad dry and lacked the desired sauce.
Overall, great experience
… moreAmie MJ (PrinCesS Amie)
Kiddos food, the pizza particularly isnt very good. The chicken tenders are hit and miss but were perfection this go round! Love the adult entrée/s but had to have the Stuffed Chicken Marsala remade after the chicken was too cooked and tough on one side, however, the manager asked if id like it remade or something different, then left me to finish my sides while waiting. Once the new one was made, not only was it perfection, but they served it with the side and extra side of broccoli I had already eaten. This was HUGE because so often, when waiting to get your replacement, you eat your sides which taste better paired with the main dish. Its a flavor thing which Olive Garden showed they totally get without my having to mention it! Super pleased with this. Then to top it off, the meal was removed from the ticket.
The best experience I have had while having had my meal need fixed eating out. It was a complete non issue and our server was kind and attentive.
… moreTom Ryan
Excellent. We ate here two nights in a row. I had the Herb-Grilled Salmon both nights. Delicious! I told the waiter to tell Herb he did a great job! The Italian donuts with raspberry sauce were fantastic. Highly recommended!!!
… moreJim Greenway
First time at the new Olive Garden in Utica Square. Ethan was our server and he was wonderful. Great service and food.
… moreAsal
I tried their chicken stuffed marsala but didn’t like it that much. The breading they used for the chicken was falling apart. The sauce on the food itself was too flavorful to the point that you couldn’t really taste what the chicken itself. My friend got the chicken alfredo and that was good just too much sauce on that as well.
… moreJohn Noveskey
Moms time out. Took my son out for unlimited soup, salad and breadsticks. The reason I only gave 4 stars for food and atmosphere is for me that is standard for a chain restaurant that I do not consider fine dining. Having said that, I did eat one serving of each of the four bowls of soup they offer on the menu. The salad was very well prepared and our waitress Scarlett was very professional and attentive and we never lacked for service. It’s a good place to with plenty of options on the menu and reasonably priced and generous Oklahoma portions. It’s also located in a safe area of Tulsa known as Utica Square shopping center.
… moreAngie Dobson
For the price, the quality of the food could be a bit better. To me it tasted like the food was frozen then heated up. The bread sticks and salad used to be restocked at the table automatically, but now I guess you have to ask for more after the 1st round. Olive Garden used to be a more fine dining experience, but now it seems more casual though the prices are still more of a fine dining feel.
… moreJ. Parker O’Roark
Nicest Olive Garden I’ve ever been to. Packed busy with a wait on a weeknight?! We took the first available half booth. That was the only part of the dining experience that wasn’t great. It has admittedly been a while since I’ve visited an Olive Garden but wow! I did the classic “tour of Italy” and all three dishes were fantastic! Seriously! No notes. Perfect. The soup and salad beforehand was good and of course the breadsticks! While not as amazing as I remember, way more filling than they seemed to be when I was younger?! lol! No, everything was great and the service was attentive and friendly.
… moreSteven Briggs
UPDATE 2025:
I’ve been back a few times since my original review. They moved to a new building in the same area and it is much nicer inside. The food remains pretty good, I’ve had occasional issues but they’ve been resolved, the service is sort of hit/miss—particularly when it gets busy. This is still my goto location in Tulsa.
2022 Review:
The food was good and the service we got from our server was accurate and efficient. What turned me off was how we were rushed out of there by the hostess as soon as we seemed to be winding down. Our plates were taken away as fast as we finished and the bill was delivered. She kept coming by and asking if we needed anything else and talking into her headset so I would assume they were trying to get someone else into our table. I understand they wanted to turn the table over but making us feel like we’d overstayed our welcome isn’t the way to keep folks coming back.
… morepresley crow
LANE IS SO GREAT!!! We had him tonight as our server and LOVED him. Everyone there was so sweet. Best service I have ever received and probably ever will. Give that man a raiseeee!!! Employee of the month 100%
… more