Gustavo Gonzalez
First time at the establishment after being in Nazareth for 12 years. Honestly didn’t try because reviews back then were not favorable. Decided to go on in the other night to give it a try. Inside is a lot smaller than I expected. L shaped area of seating. Very warm inside being so close to the stove. Asked to sit outside since it was a beautiful evening. Very helpful and nice waitress. Ordered onion rings as an app with a pepperoni pizza. Both our sodas were off tasting. I had a root beer that tasted of mainly of the carbonation. Asked for a sprite instead and still tasted of carbonation. That usually means the syrup is running out and should be changed.Didn’t bother to ask for another drink, just stook with it. The onion rings didn’t taste of even onion. Just breading. Two pieces burnt. Served with ketchup. Would be better with honey mustard or a Chipotle sauce. Pizza came out pretty quick. It was obviously very oily. I know that is a preference for some people. It was an ok pizza to me, my wife thought it was better than pizza Joe’s. The pizza was the saving grace for this review. Would I go again? A very loose maybe.
… moreDoug
Always good and consistent. Chicken Parm is great here. 5 star pizza for Lehigh Valley but no comparison to some good NYC or Jersey spots. If they cooked the pizza longer it would definitely be better but it’s still good. Dough is just floppy and doughy, no crisp at all.
… moreRose Hahn
Food was absolutely excellent!! We got a large chicken broccoli alfredo pie, cheesy garlic bread, and an italian hoagie. It’s been a long time since we found a go to place for pizza. Glad we finally found one after moving to PA!
… moreKalli Fraser (Kalleh)
Food is fine but $32 for a large, half-bacon pizza and fries. Guy told my husband the fries were “like $8,” on Google it says $5.50 and the pizza was $23 plus topping when a regular plain on Google is $17. When my husband questioned the price, the guy said “are you gonna pay for it, or not?” Probably will not go here again due to prices and customer service, it’s a shame. And $32 is not worth this amount of bacon on half the pizza!
… moreJohn Mikovits
Just writing this to say that the tomato & basil Sicilian pie that I just ate here is the best pizza that I have had in a very long time. Delicious
… moreJeffis myname
Got a large cheesesteak and order of fries. Portions were good but sadly the meat was bland and the fries were undercooked. Highly disappointed.
… moreChristopher Corrado, DVM
This started as a doordash tale… which ended with doordash not having a driver. The nice pizzaoli at Sicily Pizza called me, stayed there almost an hour after closing, and kept my kids pizza warm. 5 stars and a couple hearts to these guys. They are genuinely good humans, a rarity in today’s world. Pizza is largely a commodity – these guys differentiate themselves with service and compassion. So. Support these nice folks.
… moreLorin Williamson
Excellent pizza. I had the Grandma which is what they said they were known for. The sauce is the star here. Love work trips to the East Coast!
… moreKatelyn Lahr
My FAVORITE restaurant in the entire world. They have the best pizza and entrees EVER!!!! The staff is very nice and friendly. I have food intolerances and they work with me and they prepare my food accordingly. You can’t go wrong with this place! 🙂
… moreCourtney
I door dashed and the food was hot, beautiful and delicious!!
… more