Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 837 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
Phone: (631) 775-9888
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Athens Diner
Menu Contact Us Specials About Us.
Athens Diner | New York NY – Facebook
837 Middle Country Road, New York, NY, United States, 11953. Links. . athensdinergreekrestaurant.com. Contact info. . (631) 775-9888. . athensdiner@outlook.
Order Athens Diner – Menu & Prices – Middle Island Delivery
Use your Uber account to order delivery from Athens Diner in Middle Island. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your order.
Reviews
Marlene is Key
I LOVE ATHENS DINER
I was once driving by and craving a good Greek salad and decided to stop here as I was in the area. The space is truly lovely, well kept, clean and feels like home.
I now work in the area and finally was able to order the delicious salad with chicken and a chocolate milkshake as a treat!
The chicken was so fresh and tasty, the salad itself was huge and I have leftovers, the milkshake was gone in seconds AND I got yummy pita bread with tzatziki sauce!!!! What a marvelous treat!
I really think this place is a gem and I love dinning in or being able to take out, the parking lot is a bit tiny and wacky access but once you’re there you will love it!!! ♥️
… moreI was once driving by and craving a good Greek salad and decided to stop here as I was in the area. The space is truly lovely, well kept, clean and feels like home.
I now work in the area and finally was able to order the delicious salad with chicken and a chocolate milkshake as a treat!
The chicken was so fresh and tasty, the salad itself was huge and I have leftovers, the milkshake was gone in seconds AND I got yummy pita bread with tzatziki sauce!!!! What a marvelous treat!
I really think this place is a gem and I love dinning in or being able to take out, the parking lot is a bit tiny and wacky access but once you’re there you will love it!!! ♥️
Dawn DiBartolo
We went there New Year’s Day. Service was excellent. Coffee was AMAZING! We were delighted that it was sooo good. I had eggs Benny with avocado! Eggs were delicious – priced right. All the Benedict’s were the same price – which I liked. Iykuk. Friends and skillet and French toast. They enjoyed their normal size portions at a reasonable price. Definitely a go to !!!
… moreRoberto Blanco
Tatiana was incredible! She is outstanding. The food was amazing. I had a gyro with French fries. The gyro was delicious, the fries were fresh and hot. My friend had the Greek salad with gyro meat and he loved it too. The white sauce is excellent. Just the right amount of garlic, the pita bread was warm and tasty. I’m definitely going back. Great food and fantastic experience! Thank you Tatiana!
… morePeter Hill
Quick warm service from staff. Food was good and plentiful. Worth visiting.
… moreGoran O
In the past I’ve ordered Greek burger with feta cheese and today I got sauted liver with bacon and onions. If you like liver, this meal is excellent. Tasty, not dry, cooked really nice. Loved the sauce too. Mine came with french fries, corn and fresh Greek salad but you can choose any addons, soup, etc.
And as a result, all dishes are empty 🙂 Loved it!
Nice family restaurant, friendly and fast service, plenty of parking space.
… moreAnd as a result, all dishes are empty 🙂 Loved it!
Nice family restaurant, friendly and fast service, plenty of parking space.
T C
Food is good, however, if you order take out make sure you have the right food. It has happened to us on 2 separate occasions that the wrong order was given to us. When we bring the wrong food back, they tell us “we took the wrong bag”. First off, they should not be allowing people to just pick up bags from the counter. They don’t identify the bags with any names, or telephone numbers so how can anyone just pick up a bag from the counter. They’ve handed us the wrong bag both times and when they finally realize it’s their mistake they don’t care about the inconvenience they caused you. Yes, the food is good but I don’t like their service.
… moreTony 2 Times
Best Bacon I have ever tasted Very very good breakfast. Awesome beautiful older l waitress we love. Like a grandma making me breakfast The chef is so nice❤️ Great mom and pop Diner.
Go here! ❤️❤️❤️ We miss you guys!
… moreGo here! ❤️❤️❤️ We miss you guys!
Vanessa Elizabeth
It’s very nice and the food is good; not bad, not great. The diner isn’t it’s own building, it’s in a complex, that’s easy to pass and had only one way in and one way out. The parking lot needs work as well.
… moreJoseph Payton
I’ve visited The Athens Diner for several years and also brought family and friends to take in the professionalism, excellent food and family atmosphere. Give them a try, you’ll be satisfied! JP
… morePriya Chesnutt
Great unexpected find! We stopped by Athens Diner on our way back from Wildwood State Park and it was great. We brought our toddler and we all enjoyed a good Greek diner meal with kind staff. The Moussaka was specifically delicious.
… more