Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2093 Broadway, Buffalo, NY 14212
Phone: (716) 783-9880
Website: https://www.toasttab.com/wally-s-cafe-pizzeria-2093-broadway-st
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Buffalo Pizza Beast | Sloan NY – Facebook
The Buffalo Pizza Beast, Sloan. 5623 likes · 102 talking about this · 365 were here. High quality food at reasonable prices!
Wally’s Cafe & Pizzeria – Order Online
The Buffalo Pizza Beast The Buffalo Pizza Beast. 2093 Broadway St, Buffalo, NY. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 2093 Broadway St, Buffalo, NY. Schedule your order …
The Buffalo Pizza Beast | Pizza Takeaway in Buffalo, NY
Discover The Buffalo Pizza Beast at 2093 Broadway, Buffalo, NY. Enjoy deep dish, specialty pizzas, and unique sides for quick takeaway.
Reviews
Jeremy Lang
Pizza was slightly well done so it was nice and crispy, these medium wings were fantastic! Homemade bleu was also very good.
… moreRich Pembrock
Food was just ok it didn’t blow my socks off the way Other reviews made it seem. my pizza looked better in photos than in person… .it was not bad it had an orange color to it .the wings, however, tasted great decent sauce, and I’m not a fan of crunchy wings that shred my gums .. These I liked no super crunchy it also cost me 83 bucks with a personal pan ..16 inch thin crust ..20 wings and a sub ..not too far off but still a touch high
… moreMrs.Jamie Huthmacher
Ordered got a steak hoagie with extras and a personal pizza with the hot honey sauce amazing. By bar best hoagie around creamy loaded good meat extra cheese! Tried lovejoy carbones all them not good & dry i love wallys and that they are family owed great service and pricing the to go to for sure thank you!
… moreBambi Deer
Disgusting rude man cooking food in his pajamas while on the phone. Came in and told him my order name. He told me 10 more minutes. Waited in my car 15 minutes and came back in and rang the bell over and over again waiting for someone to come out. When he finally did he told me there WAS no order with my name with a nasty attitude and walked off. Complete waste of time.
… moreFina “Aquafina”
My first time trying Wally’s and they didn’t disappoint!!! We ordered a sheet pizza and 50 wings(half Chivetta’s & half honey mustard), along with a deep dish cheese & pepperoni pizza. If you’re looking for a deep dish…(My husband says no need to go to Chicago, go to WALLY’s ) our 2 teenage boys also give 2 thumbs up!!! Everything was delicious I love finding hidden gems #NewCustomers4Life!!!!
… moreD Eckert
Still making my rounds to try all pizza places in this area. Wally’s was next on my list.
I wasn’t expecting much as the name “Wally’s on Broadway” just doesn’t seem to scream “Try my pizza”
I ordered my typical cheese and pepperoni pizza and single order of wings.
For starters, ordering online was a breeze. It puts places like Macy’s to shame as their pickup time and order ready notification was pretty close to perfect.
As far as the pizza is concerned, I was wowed! Quality ingredients were used. The 1/2 sheet crust was perfect! So many places make I oversized to cut back on ingredients. The whole pie was cooked to perfection! A bit doughy (which I really like) and a nice golden brown on the bottom all the way around! Definitely in my top 10.
The wings were another story. Sauce was good. Blue cheese was interesting. Not your typical blue cheese. Seemed like homemade blue cheese/ranch type of dressing. However, the wings were severely undercooked. Just cooked enough so they weren’t raw. However was skin soggy and meat was like rubber. Easily in my bottom 5 wings of all time.
… moreI wasn’t expecting much as the name “Wally’s on Broadway” just doesn’t seem to scream “Try my pizza”
I ordered my typical cheese and pepperoni pizza and single order of wings.
For starters, ordering online was a breeze. It puts places like Macy’s to shame as their pickup time and order ready notification was pretty close to perfect.
As far as the pizza is concerned, I was wowed! Quality ingredients were used. The 1/2 sheet crust was perfect! So many places make I oversized to cut back on ingredients. The whole pie was cooked to perfection! A bit doughy (which I really like) and a nice golden brown on the bottom all the way around! Definitely in my top 10.
The wings were another story. Sauce was good. Blue cheese was interesting. Not your typical blue cheese. Seemed like homemade blue cheese/ranch type of dressing. However, the wings were severely undercooked. Just cooked enough so they weren’t raw. However was skin soggy and meat was like rubber. Easily in my bottom 5 wings of all time.
Yassmine Mccarter
I ordered the pictured items and let me say I am very satisfied with my order. I’ve never been here before until today and cant wait to try the rest of the menu. I’ll start with the pizza- I love love love the crust, it was filled with soo much flavor and the thickness was perfect. The cheese melted in my mouth and the blends of the toppings made it so much better. The boneless wings were very tender and not too hot and lastly the cannoli hit the spot. It was just enough chocolate chips and the filling was fulfilling. I will highly recommend.
… moreLorne Catalano
Quite simply it’s a damn good pizza!!! Not a fancy location or ideal hours but a very good sauce, a crispy not greasy crust, very good service and price and one of the few places that’s uses enough cheese.
… moreYenna
Tried to make an order when they were open and available for orders online, and I had a man yell at me through the window that he was choosing to be done for the night. What a joke, don’t even care to try the food when the service is rude and hours are inaccurate.
Edit: Sir, you shouted at us “No, no, no! I’m done!” while pointing us out the door, after I politely asked to make an order at the window. No where does it say that you are online only and your OPEN sign stayed on long after as well as your online ordering system. If you had explained “hey I’m so sorry but I’ve ran out of stock from the holiday!” then I would’ve wished you a happy new year and never thought of the interaction again. We all work holidays, my man, I had just gotten off a busy shift as well, but I didn’t scream at you. This is why I explained that if that’s your level of customer service then there is no need to even try the food because you spoke for the business and it is clearly an unprofessional one at that. I appreciate everything I have in life and I’m glad that it doesn’t include your subpar services!
… moreEdit: Sir, you shouted at us “No, no, no! I’m done!” while pointing us out the door, after I politely asked to make an order at the window. No where does it say that you are online only and your OPEN sign stayed on long after as well as your online ordering system. If you had explained “hey I’m so sorry but I’ve ran out of stock from the holiday!” then I would’ve wished you a happy new year and never thought of the interaction again. We all work holidays, my man, I had just gotten off a busy shift as well, but I didn’t scream at you. This is why I explained that if that’s your level of customer service then there is no need to even try the food because you spoke for the business and it is clearly an unprofessional one at that. I appreciate everything I have in life and I’m glad that it doesn’t include your subpar services!
Savanah Smiles
Love me some wallys. Food is always fresh and good. Large portions flavorful and worth the money. I got stuffed shells n sausage, fried dough with extra butter and garlic bread. Everything was so good. Give it a try!
… more