Samantha Cummins
We celebrated our anniversary with family and friends and it was perfect! We dinned outdoors, and it was lovely! The musician was talented, server so attentive. We ordered several different wines, they offer a great selection to satisfy all wine lovers. We multiple appetizers, and entrees, portions were very generous. Everything was incredible! Can’t wait for our next visit!
… morejt rich
As a husband of a south philly italian we were stunned we finally found incredible italian food in fl. We lived here 4 years and sad we just found this spot. Service was incredible. Had one person clearing the table and bringing water and drinks prompt. You have to get the bada bing! Not on the menu. Great presentation and fantastic. I had the filet with truffle mash and an amazing white chocolate raspberry martini. Wife had the gorgonzola cream scalops tourt and pears sacchettini milani. Our main server was loyal and wrote nothing down a sign of a pure og server. Finished off with creme brulee and Tiramisu. Parking is hard to find so we parked near the court house street . Will be back again
… moreRick Bowald
The food was excellent. We both had the Tile Fish special. Our server Vincent and Gabriel took great care of us. Will definitely be back.
… moreChristina King
The food is amazing & our waiter Beau was exceptional! Thank you for the wonderful experience. We come every year now & Can’t wait to be back.
-Your friends from Richmond VA
… moreMichael Kuhn
Once again we found ourselves at Carmelo’s Italian Ristorante celebrating another wedding anniversary. The cuisine is an absolute out of this world palette pleaser! So delicious! The service was attentive and exceptional, with their talented staff making sure we had a delightful dining experience. This is one of our favorite places to eat in Punta Gorda. Thank you Travis for making celebration so memorable.
… moreCarolyn Shinn
Carmelo‘s Italian Ristorante is exceptional. The atmosphere is so inviting. The staff are friendly, welcoming, and knowledgeable. I like to order one of the evening specials. I’ve never been disappointed. Our family ranges from three years old to 80 and we all enjoy the food and dining experience at Carmelo‘s.
… moreAllison S.
This place is an absolute vibe! High quality food/drinks. Service is phenomenal. The place offers indoor and outdoor seating, including on the front porch and courtyard where you can really enjoy the atmosphere.
I’ve been here a handful of times and have enjoyed everything I’ve ordered.
Highly recommend this place and to make reservations beforehand (preferably days before!)
… moreMad B
Dinner was beyond delicious. Come expecting superior service. Beau was our server and was delightful. Portions are generous. They even have gluten free pasta as an option. Soup or salad with each meal, and the salad was just so yummy as well. Authentic Italian with a great setting. Go a little earlier than sunset so you can walk across to catch it set.
… moreMandy Mattson
This was our first visit to Carmelo’s. Nathan was an attentive server. He made excellent suggestions and helped pace our dinner out perfectly. The food was divine. We started with Bada Bing with sausage. Entrees were Chicken Valentina and Lasagna. Dessert was a cannoli and crème brûlée. Everything was so good and I cannot recommend this restaurant enough.
… moreJohn Tooley
Best dining experience I have ever had. Atmosphere was comfortable and inviting. Service was amazing. And the food was worth every penny. Made our anniversary dinner one we won’t forget.
… more