Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Strip-mall counter serve dishing out Jamaican specialties like curries, fish stew & beef patties.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 12–8 PM |
| Sunday | 12–5 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 13175 Jefferson Ave #3, Newport News, VA 23608
Phone: (757) 847-6333
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menus for Mystic Jamaica Restaurant – Newport News – SinglePlatform
Back-Ah-Yard Served with white rice or rice & peas & choice of 2 sides. Cabbage, macaroni & cheese, potato salad, plantain, yellow yam, boiled dumpling, …
Mystic Jamaica Caribbean Restaurant | Newport News VA – Facebook
Mystic Jamaica Caribbean Restaurant, Newport News. 2172 likes · 1 talking about this · 1711 were here. Family Style Restaurant.
Mystic Jamaica Caribbean Restaurant | Newport News, VA
Mystic Jamaica Caribbean Restaurant · 13175 Jefferson Ave Ste 3 Newport News, VA 23608 · [email protected] · 757.847.6333. About. It’s a natural mystic …
Reviews
Iyanna O
So my choice in going here was solely based off of previous reviews. I am nit from this state so I had to go by what the people was saying and out of all the other jamaican restaurants; this one has the highest and better reviews.
I ordered the rasta pasta with oxtail originally wanting it with shrimp but I was advised it was be a 20min wait. ( I understood and appreciated them being upfront). Let me just say the pasta was cooked to perfection and it tasted amazing. The oxtail’s gravy on the other hand was very oily/greasy instead of the type of oxtail gravy I was looking for as a jamaican. I do have to say that other than that issue the oxtail meat fell off the bone , it was delicious and nice size pieces with no alot of fat, so I truly appreciate that!
My husband had the Jerk bbq pork ribs, rice and peas, plantain and cabbage. Again the meat FELL OFF THE BONE! -hands down the chef is killing the meat!!! My husband did not like the rice and felt like it tasted fake; now someone being born and raised inna jamaica knows dem rice n peas. So he probably wont return based off of that.
The portion sizes are nice , very big and I can say that the prices are worth it. Lastly spending $8.20 on 2 tropical rhythms is a bit much where I come from but I again understand.
Thank you for service us!
… moreI ordered the rasta pasta with oxtail originally wanting it with shrimp but I was advised it was be a 20min wait. ( I understood and appreciated them being upfront). Let me just say the pasta was cooked to perfection and it tasted amazing. The oxtail’s gravy on the other hand was very oily/greasy instead of the type of oxtail gravy I was looking for as a jamaican. I do have to say that other than that issue the oxtail meat fell off the bone , it was delicious and nice size pieces with no alot of fat, so I truly appreciate that!
My husband had the Jerk bbq pork ribs, rice and peas, plantain and cabbage. Again the meat FELL OFF THE BONE! -hands down the chef is killing the meat!!! My husband did not like the rice and felt like it tasted fake; now someone being born and raised inna jamaica knows dem rice n peas. So he probably wont return based off of that.
The portion sizes are nice , very big and I can say that the prices are worth it. Lastly spending $8.20 on 2 tropical rhythms is a bit much where I come from but I again understand.
Thank you for service us!
Kiki G
Been a while since ate here. Was in the area so decided to stop in for lunch. Got the Stew chicken w/ Mac & cabbage. Mac & cabbage good; Mac a lil salty. Rice & peas & chicken was dry & chicken was sweet tastes like BBQ chicken. Didn’t even finish food. Never had dry stew chicken before. Food & service went from great to poor. Won’t be back.
… moreSelam Ambachew
After a long day at work, I decided to treat myself to some jerk chicken, a dish I hadn’t had in a while. Eagerly, I placed my order and couldn’t resist digging in while driving home. However, just two bites in, I had to pause. The jerk chicken I remember is not only spicy but also has a hint of sweetness. This particular dish, though, was just hot without that familiar flavor profile. Thinking back, we had a Jamaican neighbor who would cook and sell us various dishes, and his jerk chicken was always my favorite. I hoped to find something that came close to his incredible cooking. I’ve also tried jerk chicken from other restaurants, but for some reason, Mystic’s version didn’t hit the mark for me.
… moreS J
I ordered the red snapper, it was burnt and over cooked. The rice and peas were dry as well. The best items I had were the oxtails and the rum cake…oh, and cabbage was pretty ok. I love Jamaican cuisine, and this was not it – AT ALL!! The customer service wasn’t bad, but it certainly could have been better. I was very disappointed and should’ve chosen another establishment to eat at.
… moreRaven Christian
Second visit: The customer service here was amazing the cashier was very nice! The food wasn’t too good to be honest and I was a little disappointed. The Jamaican beef patty was flakey, well seasoned and fresh 10/10. The macaroni was great and fresh as well. Now the chicken have a very peculiar taste not a traditional taste for some reason. I cannot put my finger on it. The curry piece was not enough for a large and the prices. Also was a little too salty. I wouldn’t try it again. The restaurant was so clean and a nice place to sit and eat if you do. Food came fast.
First visit:You are a professional business, update your hours on visible platforms you advertise. Came an hour away and closed.
… moreFirst visit:You are a professional business, update your hours on visible platforms you advertise. Came an hour away and closed.
Ashanti Tomlinson
Husband and I stop by here because we were craving some Jamaican Food and we heard some good reviews about this. Let me tell you it did not disappoint. When I tell you this was the best Jamaican food my husband and I have tried in the 757 it really is ! Food was seasoned to perfection it came out hot everything had flavored and the Mac and Cheese hit the spot. We will definitely be returning don’t mind driving far out for some good food !
… moreLuther Cotton
I enjoyed my food. Cheesecake was delicious. I’ve only done takeout. Staff was nice. The only thing is I don’t remember hearing any music!
… morepeople view
Great recipes and great people ,shout out to father Piley and the crew Tyler , shout out the owner Wayne
… morejay bee
I had the Oxtail w/rice & peas, Mac & Cheese, plantains.
Very thin / small Oxtail pieces . Never seen it prepared this way. A bit overpriced for what you get. Food was hot and fresh but the Taste was lacking overall.
Unfortunately I’ve had much better food at other Jamaican establishments.
Service was great and the restaurant was clean.
… moreVery thin / small Oxtail pieces . Never seen it prepared this way. A bit overpriced for what you get. Food was hot and fresh but the Taste was lacking overall.
Unfortunately I’ve had much better food at other Jamaican establishments.
Service was great and the restaurant was clean.
Carole Graff
Small place , but great food!! I had the shrimp w/cabbage and corn bread!!! Huge shrimp and great cabbage and cornbread!! My hubs ordered the jerk chicken salad (no pic cause he was wolfing it down) and an order of onion rings (after having ate 6 rings)!! Definitely a place to stop!!
… more