Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 374 Mooney Pond Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738
Phone: (631) 736-0722
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria – Farmingville, NY – 374 Mooney Pond …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-9:00 PM; Shop address is 374 Mooney Pond Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738374 Mooney Pond Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738; (631) 223-7525.
Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Farmingville, NY! Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria | Farmingville NY – Facebook
Monday madness!! Get one Large plain pizza for only $10.99 or 2 or more plain large pizzas for $9.99 each 🙂
Reviews
Janelys Ojeda
I visited for the first time and it was also my first time having pizza in New York — and it did not disappoint. The cook was super patient and took the time to explain what each slice was, which I really appreciated. I chose the daily special (chicken, bacon, and mozzarella) and he also recommended the Thai chicken pizza.
The special was packed with chicken, and the Thai chili sauce was SO good. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and honestly looked too good — I started eating before I even remembered to take a picture Definitely can’t wait to come back and try more slices.
PS the slices were big, but he heard my boyfriend and I talking about taking bites from each others to try and he asked if we wanted them cut in half.
… moreThe special was packed with chicken, and the Thai chili sauce was SO good. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and honestly looked too good — I started eating before I even remembered to take a picture Definitely can’t wait to come back and try more slices.
PS the slices were big, but he heard my boyfriend and I talking about taking bites from each others to try and he asked if we wanted them cut in half.
Kathleen Maldoando
These guys are the best!! I couldn’t order on slice or door dash. They took my order & delivered it. I called back to complain my order was wrong & they literally sent someone the refund me in cash because it wasn’t a”app”. These guys are not only helpful & honest, their food is delicious! Sauce to die for. Good guys good values & honest! 10 stars!!!
… moreLinda Levick
Regular pizza looked amazing and those that ate it loved it. The gluten free pizza was absolutely awful. Threw in trash. Broke into pieces, dry and inedible.
… moreHarrison Nicastro
Ordered delivery and it took an hour and a half to get to our place that’s 15 minutes away. They either didn’t include sauce with their amazing garlic knots or didn’t include sauce with their calamari. The pizza looks like they just rushed it because it’s not evenly made and the crust is 4 inches wide in some spots. The knots were great 9.5/10, the pizza was 5/10, the chicken Parm was 3/10, and the calamari 6/10.
… moreLou Fourquet
I live right up the road from these guys, and have ordered food many times, but lately have been ordering there much less. The reason being no consistency in their cooking.
I’ve had burned sausage parm heroes, bland tasting chicken parm heroes (I used to order them many times a week), but not anymore. The first time I ordered a Sicilian pizza from them it was cooked well and tasted great. The next 2 times I ordered it I basically got a pizza’s with raw unrisen pizza dough. Now this is happening to my regular pizza orders…
I just got home with a regular pizza which is also undercooked. You can see the layer of uncooked dough under the cheese.. It’s like holding a floppy piece of fabric instead of a slice of pizza.
I don’t complain about bad food from places I eat, unless I am ready to never go there again. That is where I am. Good bye Goomba Johnny’s.
… moreI’ve had burned sausage parm heroes, bland tasting chicken parm heroes (I used to order them many times a week), but not anymore. The first time I ordered a Sicilian pizza from them it was cooked well and tasted great. The next 2 times I ordered it I basically got a pizza’s with raw unrisen pizza dough. Now this is happening to my regular pizza orders…
I just got home with a regular pizza which is also undercooked. You can see the layer of uncooked dough under the cheese.. It’s like holding a floppy piece of fabric instead of a slice of pizza.
I don’t complain about bad food from places I eat, unless I am ready to never go there again. That is where I am. Good bye Goomba Johnny’s.
Jose Ramirez
First time here working in the area would definitely come back again I got a free can of soda and the garlic knots are fresh and big
Very nice staff
… moreVery nice staff
Karyn Vaughan
We catered for an expected 30 people for my Mom’s wake. Called it in the day before. Delivered exactly at the time we asked for, food was piping hot, labeled and wrapped neatly. Delivery guy was awesome bringing it all in amongst all the dogs and people in my house. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed all the food, even the salad!! It was delicious! My family all wished they had a restaurant as good as this by them. Thank you for everything!!
… morefaith yunitis
First time eating pizza here. We had Sicilian and regular. Sauce crust cheese very good it even came with 2 sodas. Staff very nice. Will definitely go back.
… moreDANNY BOY
I am a pizza lover and today was first time trying their pizza! I got 2 slices with meatball and bacon.. pizza 10 out of 10! Hands down good pizza very tasty
… moreNate Tinsley
I dont do many reviews. This place deserves it. Firstly, the energy in the place? I like it!!! Always a warm greeting from the staff and even from other customers there. I normally order to pickup, but last weekend was the first time I ordered for delivery. Even the delivery guy brought good energy with him. The pizza is how I like it, the brooklyn pie is my fave, and going to try some entrees soon. Keep up the goodness Goombas.
… more