Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2006 Jefferson Hwy, Fishersville, VA 22939
Phone: (540) 949-8900
Website: http://www.newbrotherspizza.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New Brothers Pizza | Pizza in Waynesboro and Fishersville VA
New Brother’s Pizza, Pasta and Subs has proudly served Waynesboro and Fishersville for the last 16 years. Our locally-owned restaurant specializes in pizza, …
New Brother’s Pizza Waynesboro | Fishersville VA – Facebook
New Brother’s Pizza has moved! Stop by our beautiful new location, right down the road at 2006 Jefferson Highway in Fishersville (right across from Preston …
New Brothers Pizza: A Slice of Culinary Perfection in Fishersville
New Brother’s Pizza, located at 2006 Jefferson Hwy in Fishersville, VA, is a delightful culinary gem known for its exceptional food and welcoming atmosphere.
Reviews
Chrisy Bossie
This is the only place I will order Italian from locally. The white pizza is fantastic with the perfect amount of salt, and not an overly thick crust. The meatballs are huge and tasty. The wings I always order plain without sauce and they’re perfectly cooked and crispy. And the limoncello cake just tops everything off perfectly. I order enough (always delivered nice and hot) to last me a few days. The prices are excellent for the quality and quantity of food you get.
… moreJeff Organ
They accidentally forgot something from my order and before I had even noticed they were kind enough to call me to let me know that they would be delivering to my house. Which is not withing the normal delivery area. That is great customer service!!! The food is always great!!
… moreDavid C
I am new to the area and was told about this. I loved the food. It isn’t fake like fast food chains, everything eas fresh, and lacked the extreme amounts of salt most places use. This was safe for my wife that has high blood pressure. Definitely going back and trying more of their stuff.
… moreJustin Younes
Best Pizza within 100 miles! I’m a North East Pennsylvania Guy and the pizzeria food here can hang anywhere!! Get anything, but ask for your pizza “well done” it’s cooked perfect every time !
… moreIan Fitzgerald
Really cute little place that I nearly didn’t even see. Decided last second to stop in, and I’m so glad I did. This has been some of the best pizza I’ve had since leaving New York. The woman inside was so friendly as well, I was so super happy with it. Will definitely be back, I’ve heard the wings are also amazing.
… moreAaron Gray
I had forgotten how much i enjoy new brothers pizza since I haven’t worked in fishersville for almost 10 years. Stopped in this evening for a couple of subs and a pie and i tell you the quality and service hasn’t changed a bit. I’m definitely going to have to stop in more often
… moreLinda Jones
Perfect EVERY TIME! I’m originally from NY and this is spot on! Thanks to all the staff, especially NEW YEAR’S EVE, for your excellent service! Nice way to leave 2025! (And people, please tip! They work hard!)
… moreRebekah
My faaaavorite local pizza, its always amazing and staff are always very kind.
… moreSpike Weeks
In my opinion they have the absolute best pizza in the Waynesboro area. The pizza always arrives in a reasonable time, it’s hot, and it’s delicious. Never had a bad experience.
… moreBailey Short
I order a calzone yesterday and it had molded ham inside. Now that’s very nasty and can get someone very sick. I am pretty sure ham should never look like that. And to think I could have ate molded ham just nooo. No reason for this.
… more