Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 215 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: (607) 272-7600
Website: http://www.ithacapudgies.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pudgies Ithaca | Often Imitated, Never Duplicated
Pudgies Pizza Menu. Order Online · Home · Menu · Daily Specials · Contact Us. Hours of … NY 14850 | P: 607-272-7600 | Accepted Credit Cards. Website Developed …
Pudgie’s Pizza & Sub Shops | Ithaca NY – Facebook
Stop by today we have lots of options for our Thursday special! Buy a slice and a drink you get a free slice. Most specials are between $6-7! Cant beat that for …
Order Pudgie’s Pizza & Sub Shops – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Pudgie’s Pizza & Sub Shops at 215 Elmira Road in Ithaca. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
Chris M
Finding something that everyone agrees on, a place that isn’t insanely busy and something that isn’t going to break the bank. We found a winner.
Fridays are always a challenge for dinner for my family. Pudgies has always been that hidden gem that alot forget about. The website makes ordering and paying for it so easy. We ordered the party pack. For the amount of food you get, it was worth the price. It was delivered in short time and the food was still hot. The delivery guy(George) was great. He greeted me with a smile, he was courteous and very professional. After grabbing some of the food from him, he seen that I was struggling a little bit and he told me to take my time. I appreciated the fact that he wasn’t trying to throw everything at me and rush out. He waited for me to put some things down, wish me a good day and even close my door for me. The food was delicious. Thank you for a great experience.
… moreFridays are always a challenge for dinner for my family. Pudgies has always been that hidden gem that alot forget about. The website makes ordering and paying for it so easy. We ordered the party pack. For the amount of food you get, it was worth the price. It was delivered in short time and the food was still hot. The delivery guy(George) was great. He greeted me with a smile, he was courteous and very professional. After grabbing some of the food from him, he seen that I was struggling a little bit and he told me to take my time. I appreciated the fact that he wasn’t trying to throw everything at me and rush out. He waited for me to put some things down, wish me a good day and even close my door for me. The food was delicious. Thank you for a great experience.
Interesting
I’ve enjoyed Pudgie’s in Ithaca for years ever since I was a college student fresh out of high school! The food’s always been delicious , costs reasonable, and service kind and courteous. And now with the easy online ordering it’s one more way of getting great tasting pizza, salad, and more!
… moreWilliam Carroll
Great service pizza came fast nice and fresh thank you guys so much will do business with you soon
… moreLexie Brotz-Nisbett
Nothing wrong with the staff that works there, but they don’t sell pudgies pizza. Flat, Tony’s Tostitos lookin pizza but worse. Not worth the money whatsoever. The staff did give us a whole new pizza, which we appreciated, but it was no better. Just not like normal pudgies pizza at all.
… moreDiane Koi-Thompson
Driver arrived with a pleasant smile and good food.The tracking app said he was going to Toronto, but it didn’t take over 4 hours!
… moreJustin Perkins
Pudgies Ithaca always does a fantastic job for us. We often call and they deliver right to our job site taking care of several hungry DPW workers. You are appreciated, all of you!
-CSEA City of Ithaca DPW
… more-CSEA City of Ithaca DPW
Roy Loomis
Pudgies has one of my two favorite pizzas in Ithaca. However, this week with home projects and an overnight shift, I decided to call for delivery before work. BIG MISTAKE! Phoned at 7:35pm Family pack with a two topping pizza told it would be about 45 minutes. Delivery completed at 8:25pm. Get the food inside to find pizza was cheese only and wings were pathetic! (See photo) Being in customer service I was disappointed with the response of Vinny on the other end of the phone. “Nothing I can do about the wings. I can have the driver bring the correct pizza or can offer 1 free topping for your next order.” I had TWO toppings which he was unable to refund to my card. So I told him to bring the correct pizza in which he said the driver would be back to ‘exchange’ pizzas. How about, “go ahead and keep the incorrect pizza and I’ll have the correct pizza to you as soon as possible? After all I was hungry 45 minutes prior!! I waited, waited, and had to call back just before closing time, told it was on the way the driver had ‘other’ deliveries before bringing making my delivery right. Finally received my pizza at 9:11pm an hour and 46 minutes after ordering, 20 minutes before leaving for work. Needless to say, dinner was rushed and not enjoyed at this point. $45 for a pizza and 10 wings is pricey! Too much to ask for order to be correct and timely? Sadly, I’ll never order from Pudgies Ithaca again there are plenty of competitors in town.
… moreholly masih
Made saladnwith rotten lettuce that needed about 75% of it removed. Soggy breadsticks. I tried to call them to talk to them about it, and they refused to answer their phone. I won’t be ordering from there any more.
… moreKristy Brame
Great pizza=Great people – Thank You for the delicious pizza, wings, subs, and fresh cut salads.
… moreDavid Gardner
Got a sheet pizza and some pizza fries. More than enough pizza ans was good.
… more