Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Casual spot offering pizza, heros, pasta & other Italian standards for dine-in, takeout & delivery.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 624 Broadway, Massapequa, NY 11758
Phone: (516) 797-1122
Website: https://www.mariospizzeriarestaurant.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Mario’s Pizzeria & Restaurant – Massapequa, NY – 624 Broadway …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-8:15 PM; Shop address is 624 Broadway, Massapequa, NY 11758624 Broadway, Massapequa, NY 11758; (516) 797-1122.
Mario’s Pizzeria | Italian Food | 624 Broadway, Massapequa, NY, USA
Mario’s Pizza in Massapequa, NY, serves fresh, hand-tossed pizzas, classic Italian dishes, and hearty pastas. Known for authentic flavors and friendly …
Marios Pizzeria (@mariosmassapequa) · Massapequa, NY – Instagram
️ open daily from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm · from dough to delicious watch the magic happen ✨ · to all of our incredible customers inquiring about Mario’s …
Reviews
EK
So I ordered the chicken parm with spaghetti and figured I’d grab a slice of pizza too —-> you know, can’t go wrong with that combo, right? Yeah… wrong.
The chicken parm looked like it had been fried sometime last week and left sitting around ever since. It came in one of those round metal tins like I was at a food court in a mall. They dumped this super-sweet tomato sauce on top and also drowned it in sauce , then melted some cheese that never even saw the inside of an oven — not a single browned spot. The chicken was tough around the edges, and the spaghetti? 100% precooked and reheated. You could tell.
And the pizza — wow. Same sauce, same sad story. Honestly, it might’ve been the worst slice I’ve ever had in my life. Sweet pizza! I’ve had better slices at gas stations.
If you’re craving real Italian food, keep driving. This place missed the mark big time.
Take note: + 4% extra for using a credit card.
… moreThe chicken parm looked like it had been fried sometime last week and left sitting around ever since. It came in one of those round metal tins like I was at a food court in a mall. They dumped this super-sweet tomato sauce on top and also drowned it in sauce , then melted some cheese that never even saw the inside of an oven — not a single browned spot. The chicken was tough around the edges, and the spaghetti? 100% precooked and reheated. You could tell.
And the pizza — wow. Same sauce, same sad story. Honestly, it might’ve been the worst slice I’ve ever had in my life. Sweet pizza! I’ve had better slices at gas stations.
If you’re craving real Italian food, keep driving. This place missed the mark big time.
Take note: + 4% extra for using a credit card.
Frank Deets
The pizza and food are good. But lately there’s been a very fragrant smell in there that’s keeping me away from this place. The smell is absolutely disgusting smells like a sweet sixteen party. I honestly don’t know what’s going on in there but I’ve been there two times in the last month or so and it absolutely reeks of perfume, body spray or something else. I can’t even breathe when I walk in there.
… moreJohn Christoulakis
Deanna & Skyler are always on top of their game. They make you feel welcomed and comforted before you even order. They are truly the best duo since Batman & Robin.
… moreKirstie Albury
My husband and I came in for dinner tonight to celebrate some good news since we were in the area. Lisa was our server and was so nice with us and helped us out perfectly where my husband has a special diet. I had the stuffed mushrooms, the shrimp francese and rigatoni with a red sauce. All of the food was impeccable, very fresh and probably the best food I’ve had in quite some time. We’re already planning to hopefully come back very soon. 10/10 cant wait till the next time.
… moreTim Dog
Used to be much better at old location. Sauce is now hit or miss , they don’t look happy and or communicate well. Used to be a place I liked very much but the last two experiences were completely off. Maybe I will give another try but right now I’m giving it a long break
… morePaul Akap
The Delivery driver Demetri was very professional, kind and careful with our food. Everything came out amazing and service was great. Definitely returning.
… moreBrenna Cicciari
In the midst of a very difficult weekend after our bridal salon experienced a fire, the incredible team at Mario’s in Massapequa went above and beyond to support us. They generously delivered pizza, pasta, salad, heros, and more to help keep our staff fueled as we navigated the chaos. As a fellow family-owned business, their kindness and generosity truly touched our hearts. It’s moments like these that remind us how special our community is. We are so grateful for Mario’s and will absolutely continue to support and order from them moving forward. Thank you for showing up when it mattered most — your food was amazing and your hearts even bigger.
– Roselynn, Anthony, Cristina, and our team at Bridal Reflections
… more– Roselynn, Anthony, Cristina, and our team at Bridal Reflections
A M
Amazing pizza and people! I’m a fellow business owner in Massapequa and we had a recent fire in our space. Mario’s was kind enough to send our staff pizzas, salads, and garlic knots! Generous people and great food. Thank you Mario’s!
… moreJohn Coleman
No offense to the GREAT food we have in this neighborhood-but this Mario’s on Broadway in Massapequa has the BEST meatballs in town, great price always consistent. Great salads also. All around an awesome pizzeria. Customer service always on point, take out, dine-in or delivery-TERRIFIC job there. Very good at what that do 🙂 This location 5 stars from me all day!
… moreAnne Howell
Tonight I ordered pasta, eggplant, calamari and pizza and all were absolutely delicious! I have to admit I was awful on the phone trying to place my order and the girl was extremely patient and even tho I kept changing my mind, she was so patient and kind to me. In addition, she got my entire order right in spite of my constant changing of my mind (order). Food and service is definitely 5 stars!
… more