Carol O.
Best Hawaiian and specialty pizzas in WNY! They use better and fresher real ingredients like pizzerias did long ago. Most pizza is now overly greasy and too salty because they use cheap low quality ingredients! I drive past another closer Just Pizza to get to this one! It is worth the drive!
… moreMike Cirocco
There are a lot of great pizza places in Western New York and just pizza in Elma is certainly one of them. All of their food from their extensive menu is great. What really sets them apart is their staff. I believe Bella is the manager and her professionalism and willingness to go above and beyond is so impressive and it is shared by everyone else at the restaurant. Just Pizza and Elma is my go-to Pizza & Wing place in the southtowns
… moreStacie brennan
I just called to use a coupon I received via text from their text club. The online ordering was not working and I only had 60 minutes to use the coupon. The person on the phone had no idea what I was talking about. I even had my friend use her link for the code and told him everything on the text club offer. They refused to honor it. I don’t know why I am part of a just pizza text club if I go to use the coupons I get and they don’t get honored. I told them I’d call elsewhere and all I got was a sorry.
… morerandy soby
Best pizza in the area by far. Garlic sesame crust is the way to go. Up there with Bocce, Picasso’s etc. Not a sweet sauce thankfully (for me). This one was a tad bit well done and purely magical. Finally an elite level pizza in Elma. If you can keep your pizza consistent at this level you will kill it.
… moreRosalie Hicks
The “everything” sub had no lettuce, onions or tomato and a very thin slice of meat plus a thin slice of cheese. The rolls are small. It was like a sandwich you make at home. Very skimpy, $15, there are so many other options in the area, I cannot imagine ever going back.
… moremarie ann
Absolutely amazing pizza!! Staff is always friendly and welcoming. Just pizza is now my go to spot for pizza and wings!
… moreCathy Dzierzanowski
A few weeks ago I ordered pizza and wings. Med wings, and lge pizza onion sausage extra sauce lite cheese. Pizza had regular sauce and cheese. Mistakes happen. Wings were definitely more hot then med. This week I ordered same thing except mild wings. Pizza again didn’t have extra sauce which I pointed out to the cashier, she agreed, also reg cheese. She was very polite. When I got home these wings were as hot as the last time. Definitely more like hot. I called to ask if perhaps there was a mistake. The person in charge came on the phone and told me they were mild and blamed corporate for sending them the sauce and there was nothing wrong with them. She then instructed me how to eat them. Dip in blue cheese and if that didn’t work add melted butter. Needless to say we’re done with them. All she had to say was I’m sorry what can I do to better the situation better.
Instead she had a terrible attitude. I hope corporate sees this review
… moreMark Kent
Staff always friendly, food is quick. Love the pizza.
… moreKIMBERLY STREER
So many great choices. Old Italian white pizza is the best. Friendly staff!
… moreDebra Kester
Update – since the change in ownership took place. Just pizza of Elma has been great. The food is good, the employees are very friendly. The owner is very nice and easy to speak with. This is my new go to. Thank you for taking over this location.
11/2024 update
We order a lot from just pizza. Food is great. But the rewards program needs a little work
2/2025 update
Had a few hiccups in the past couple months. But they do try to make it right. Food is still good.
… more