Amanda Heimberg
So glad we finally tried Renzo’s. All the hype was real! The food was delicious. We had a Caesar salad, fried calamari appetizer, spaghetti bolognese and garlic infused penne with broccoli and grilled chicken. We had two INCREDIBLE desserts too. The service was amazing – friendly and so super attentive. The restaurant was beautiful and spread out. Not loud and crammed like many of the local ones. Renzo came and introduced himself. Such a nice person, you just don’t get owners that care like that anymore. We have already recommended to many people, and will for sure be regulars! Thanks for a great meal.
… moreBahy Salama
Had dinner at Renzo yesterday with my family. Food was so tasty, price was reasonable to the portion & food quality, excellent service with smile faces. Their dessert platter was a top notch, the cream cheese cone was out of this world. Highly recommend!
… moreAj Mogavero
Phenomenal pizza cooked to perfection the hotness of the buffalo sauce is perfect just enough heat. And I love how they don’t put blue cheese or ranch on it you can put your own because a lot of people put blue cheese on it and me personally I don’t like that because I’m a ranch person.
… moreJohn Adly
Renzo’s food was excellent; fresh, tasty and good portions. The place is also clean and spacious, and the service is excellent.
… moreAlex Tsodikov
We dropped by Renzo’s with the intention of just grabbing a pizza, but the experience went far beyond our expectations. The pizza was fantastic—high-quality ingredients, a perfect crust, and packed with flavor. But what truly stood out was the service. Even though we only ordered pizza, we were treated like we were enjoying a full-blown 5-star dining experience.
The owner, Renzo, took the time to chat with us, making us feel right at home. And don’t forget to try their ice cream—it was absolutely delicious! Renzo’s is a gem in Marlboro, and we can’t wait to come back.
… morerhonda passmore
I must say that my experience at this dining in dinner was incredible! The food was over the top. The Chicken Marcela with mushrooms was beyond the best I have ever had. The Calamari was crispy on the outside and as tender as butter on the inside.
I normally never eat desert however of course I couldn’t resist. The sweets are made by a french baker in house. The owner is such a joy to be around as he made sure everything about our experience was perfect!!! Thank you and I can’t wait until next Saturday night. Btw I now have have a new pizzeria……….
… moreSearra Oliveira
First time here. Wish I was lying about the amount of dressing they gave me for my takeout salad 🙁
The chicken was also fatty & inedible.
… moreTess L
Ordered pizza and spaghetti and the meatballs came out cold and when I mentioned it to them they were nasty and took my plate away and rolled their eyes to go “heat” it up. What kind of service is that? The food wasn’t that good and the service was terrible. Definitely not coming back here. Probably a lot of fake reviews
… moreJennifer Arminio
Just had dinner at Renzo’s and it was SO good! I was pleasantly surprised they had wild caught salmon on the menu as I try to stay away from the farm raised fish; it was cooked perfectly. My husband had the veal portobello and he was very happy, he said he was able to cut it with a fork. The renovations look great and we will be adding it to our rotation of places to eat. Service was amazing and love the atmosphere. Thank you Renzo’s!
… moreMeryl Marshall
Food is always off the charts. Love the organic chicken dishes and the wild salmon is so tender and fresh. Just had the freshly made lasagna tonight and it was excellent. I recommend the margarita (crispy) pizza too. Bring a bottle of wine or two with you. Family owned restaurant with such friendly service.
… more