BrownEyes !
Let’s go straight to the question that is always at the end of any review… Will I go back?? Unfortunately no. Sauce good. Pizza good. But the cost compared to what I received was not worth it. Pizza was $20… that’s fine. 3 meatballs for $14. Uhhh Ok. But the SPICY RIGATONI was $19, and even though the sauce was good, the amount we received vs the cost was not worth it. Also… The pasta was very al dente. Same thing with the Penne allá Vodka …. Cost $17 + chicken brought it to over 20. What we received not worth it. Just look at the pictures (why Chinese containers??) Was it worth the cost???
… moreCourtney Straw
Huge fans of this spot. We were visiting the area and stopped by late at night. So many slice options and unique flavors. Got the perfect NY crust that holds no matter the toppings!
… morebrad joyce
Loved this place! We’re movers and we’re moving someone from Montclair to Virginia and wanted to get some authentic Italian Pizza and Lucci’s 100% delivered!! Salad was fresh and delicious, pizza was SO good, so fresh and can taste the quality ingredients! the owner Sebastian and his crew were so nice and accommodating they make you feel like you’re royalty! they sell Boylan’s black cherry soda and reminded how much I love it, started buying at my local grocery store… wonderful experience!
… moreTHE POET NYC
My nephew came over around midnight with a box of pizza just randomly. No one in my house was really hungry but when pizza walks in there is no questions asked. Man oh man this pizza was amazing. Pie was half regular and half buffalo chicken. The crust was thin and crunchy. Sauce was saucing and the flavors were on point. Definitely try this place!
… moreJessica Barile
Great pizza & great friendly service everyone behind the counter was so nice. The food came out fresh and hot. The garlic knots here are huge and delicious full of flavor. The classic margarita slice was amazing the fresh tomatoes on top and the flavor of the sauce was a great pair. There Sicilian slices were crispy and fluffy the sauce and cheese were just right. Definitely recommend.
… moreVirgil Fitzpatrick
There’s absolutely no question on who dominates the restaurant scene here, and you’re looking at it!!! Portions so huge, CAUTION should be exercised when ordering!!! Tim’s team has got this down like a well oiled machine. If you have any second thoughts on this place, THROW THEM AWAY AND ORDER!!!
… moreSunny Desai
Solid spot. Came with the family and the place smelled incredible the moment we walked in. We ordered a bunch of slices, wings and the spicy rigatoni (WOW).
The staff was awesome – when a fresh penne alla vodka Sicilian came out and I mentioned how good it looked they cut me a big square and handed it over on the house. Just genuinely nice people serving very tasty food that I haven’t had this solid in the area.
Also heard the Caesar salad is excellent while walking out. We’ll definitely be back very soon.
… moreJacob Barreto
4 stars does not mean anything bad. The pizza was great. I just understand that delivery quality can be a little different from eating it fresh in person, and that’s totally normal.
I ordered for delivery in Montclair and it arrived right on the estimated time. They followed my notes exactly and cooked the pizza well-done just how I like it. The pepperoni pie was delicious and they really nailed it.
We’ll definitely be ordering again.
… moreSoumava Bera
Ordered pizza for Super Bowl night and it was a disaster. They didn’t honor pre orders and were totally not equipped to handle any volume of orders and were extremely disorganized. The pizzas I got were poorly made, unevenly thick crust, disproportionate ratio of marinara and mozzarella. It was an utter disappointment. They broke customer trust. To top it off I was seeing the pizza maker at work sweating and huffing and puffing and all that sweat from bare hands and the forehead dripping into your dough. It was unhygienic, chaotic and extremely unprofessional. If this is how the owner runs business, you can never scale up.
Edit: The owner called to apologize. I appreciate that gesture. Only For that I will increase the rating . But they still have to win back customer trust
… moreDiana M
“Grandmas” pizza was really a Sicilian pizza. Crust was too thick. Meatballs were good. Good news the pizza taste better the second day. Maybe we ordered the wrong pizza. We won’t go back to try again
… more