Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Old-fashioned locale known for hearty American & Amish cuisine, including homemade pies.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239
Phone: (941) 955-7771
Website: https://www.yodersrestaurant.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Yoder’s Amish Village
Yoder’s Logo Footer. Amish Village. 3434 Bahia Vista St. | Sarasota, FL 34239. Yoder’s Facebook; Yoder’s Trip Advisor; Yoder’s Instagram. Restaurant Hours. ( …
Yoder’s Amish Restaurant
Yoder’s Logo Footer. Amish Village. 3434 Bahia Vista St. | Sarasota, FL 34239. Yoder’s Facebook; Yoder’s Trip Advisor; Yoder’s Instagram. Restaurant Hours. ( …
Breakfast Menu – Yoder’s
Yoder’s Amish Restaurant has been known for. … | Sarasota, FL 34239. Yoder’s Facebook · Yoder’s Trip Advisor · Yoder’s Instagram …
Last Updates
Reviews
Nelson Montero
This was our first time here and I would definitely stop by again. We stopped for breakfast on our way to Blue Springs State Park. We started off with the pecan pie because as adults no one can tell us what to eat and when. The coffee was so good I didn’t even add creamer. I normally add creamer to any coffee I drink. Next time I’m trying a different pie. The cream cheese blue berry muffin, yummy!
… moreD.K. Robertson
The roast beef is simply amazing. It tastes more like a high end beef short rib. The famous fried chicken is delicious. Get the 4 piece chicken. It is a great value. I will come back, although it seems wise to come before 5 or after 7 for dinner to avoid a long wait.
Sara, our server, was outstanding!
… moreSara, our server, was outstanding!
Eva G
Such excellent soul food. Best fried chicken and corn muffins and oh my their pies. The place is so popular. If there’s a line don’t worry. They seat people quickly. The staff is so nice and so friendly. It’s our tradition to stop by here when we are on road trips. (I also recommend their pulled pork )
… moreT-REX
If you’re in Sarasota and want an honest home cooked meal this is the place. Fried Chicken, fantastic! Pot roast, so good. Best apple butter I’ve tried.Pie, need to try at least one. There is a reason this place is always on wait. And don’t forget the gift shop
… moreSignature Sara
Marcia was amazing!! 5 Stars for her service for sure!
We got so many different things between the 7 of us in our party tonight and every single thing was beyond expectations phenomenal.
Meatloaf, turkey, chicken The beef veggie soup of the day was incredible. Mashed taters and gravy were out of this world. Even the green beans were amazing.
Our kids loved the grilled cheese, Mac n cheese and fries too.
The pies were perfect. We got the cream pie trio. Peanut butter, chocolate and banana. They were insanely sweet and SO good.
Also. Their apple butter is the best I’ll EVER had in my life. Do it.
… moreWe got so many different things between the 7 of us in our party tonight and every single thing was beyond expectations phenomenal.
Meatloaf, turkey, chicken The beef veggie soup of the day was incredible. Mashed taters and gravy were out of this world. Even the green beans were amazing.
Our kids loved the grilled cheese, Mac n cheese and fries too.
The pies were perfect. We got the cream pie trio. Peanut butter, chocolate and banana. They were insanely sweet and SO good.
Also. Their apple butter is the best I’ll EVER had in my life. Do it.
The Roving Ballards
Delicious food, and great service. The front parking lot is a bit tight for larger vehicles but the back lot (technically it to the side of the building) has plenty of space.
I had small meatloaf with mashed potatoes and J had a pot pie with mashed potatoes. We were both so full we had to get our pecan pie to go.
… moreI had small meatloaf with mashed potatoes and J had a pot pie with mashed potatoes. We were both so full we had to get our pecan pie to go.
Gayle Mercado
Yoder’s restaurant is such a cozy place with great staff and excellent home cooked food. Their food is amazing, great pies and cake. Always a must stop when we go to Sarasota. Their fried chicken, BBQ pork, stuffing and mac n cheese are excellent. Their desserts are amazing. They have a restaurant, gift shop and market as well. Will definitely return here when we are back in the area! Lovely people here as well.
… moreKayla Conover
We arrived around noon on a Saturday. The line to dine in was wrapped around the building & we were told the wait would be about an hour. Instead of waiting, we ordered from the carry out window. Our food was ready in about 15 minutes, and we ate it in their seating area out front. The roast beef sandwich with au jus is something I will dream of having again – it’s pretty basic but delicious nonetheless. We went to the gift shop and farmer’s stand as well. Bought oatmeal whoopie pies, a piece of chocolate cake, and apple butter. All were good, but the chocolate cake was surprisingly dry.
… moreBa Bo
I wanted to love Yoders but I got the famous fried chicken for $23.95 it wasn’t hot, no flavor and extremely dry, ate 2 bites. The noodles fell apart while trying to eat them and the corn was like eating rubber. Waste of my hard earned $. I did bring the chicken home to feed to my animals. Sorry I can’t recommend. But by the line waiting to get in losing a customer is no big deal.
… moreLittle Skittles
Very popular restaurant, so don’t be surprised if there is a wait. Also seems a popular place for takeaway. Service is friendly.
Food is hearty and plentiful. While tempted by the desserts, we simply didn’t have room in our tummies to give them a try. We did, however, purchase some cookies which were greatly enjoyed later that day.
On site, there is a gift shop/bldg, and a separate coffee shop with baked offerings.
Worth the short drive (~15 mins) for from the interstate for a nice meal.
… moreFood is hearty and plentiful. While tempted by the desserts, we simply didn’t have room in our tummies to give them a try. We did, however, purchase some cookies which were greatly enjoyed later that day.
On site, there is a gift shop/bldg, and a separate coffee shop with baked offerings.
Worth the short drive (~15 mins) for from the interstate for a nice meal.