Roger Brown
Never been here and decided to stop and try. Im glad I did. Seriously one of the freshest delicious pizzas I’ve ever had! A little pricey but totally worth the money! We will be coming back soon.
… morePam Buss
Skip the chains and eat here! Todd was super friendly. Homemade crust and sauce not from concentrate! Yummy
… moreBrittney Baker
This is a fantastic pizza place! ❤️ First time going there with my boyfriend and it was a great experience! Service was awesome! Todd was such a nice guy! You can tell he takes pride and is passionate about what he does. We got the prairie dog pizza. Wish it had a little more cheese, but it was still tasty! Loved the crispy crust and flavorful sauce! We will definitely be back when we stay in the area again
… moreBrad Ruehle
Stopped in on Thursday evening at about 6 pm and it was not busy at all. Todd took my order and made my pizza right away, and it only took 10-15 minutes to get my order. My pizza was very good, I really liked the crust, not too thin and not too thick.
… moreTodd Koch
Pizza! .
Our experience was amazing at Muddy Waters Pizza Pub. We were greeted by Todd the co-owner and his service was awesome. He has a passion for the business that’s for sure. Home made crust was probably the best I’ve had and just the right amount of toppings. Top notch!! If you’re in the area and are craving pizza I cannot recommend it enough.
… moreScott Solyntjes
Love this place!
The beer is very cold, the pizza is awesome . Homemade crust and cooked right. We had tried a few of their other pizzas before, but jumped in for the muddy water this time. It has everything in it they offer. We were a bit worried about the crust being soggy, but it was perfect and all of the toppings worked well together. This is a place will be glad to come back to!
… moreBrianna Kenowski
Such a great pizza place! Server was very busy with a large order this past weekend when we there and he was running the place alone for a bit being a server/pizza chef/bartender all in one! He was still super friendly while being on the move! Would definitely come back and recommend!
… moreTammy Bass-Bishell
Fantastic Amazing Pizza Homemade dough crust cooked just right homemade pizza sauce AND local ingredients. Best pizza hands down, this pizza beats any in the Madison area. Staff are VERY attentive Owner came out personally to see how our food was. The cheese bread was loaded with fresh cheese. Definitely could tell cheese bread sauce was homemade tasted very healthy organic. LOVE the atmosphere
… moreToni Sumpter
This was the only place I could find a gluten-free pizza that wasn’t a national chain. Wow! It was amazing. They prepare their dough from scratch (even g-f) and get locally-sourced sausage that they cook onsite. We added spicy jalapeños and loved every bite.
… moreCassandra Pickering
We found ourselves wanting pizza and staying at a hotel near here so walked over to enjoy some AMAZING thin crust, tavern style pizza. The crust is both chewy and crispy…and the cheese pull .
Our 11 and 13 year old boys each got a Creek Chub size that they couldn’t finish. my husband and I got a Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza that was either new or a special (not on the menu but posted by the door) and it was mouth watering delicious.
We didn’t order an appetizer, but saw several of the cheese sticks go by and I don’t think they would disappoint anyone.
Beverage choices were cqns of Soda, bottles/cans of beers and seltzers. We stuck with the housemade lemonade and tea.
Do yourself a favor and swing by and get something for yourself…you won’t be sorry.
… more