Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New York Eats & Treats Group | Facebook
A place to share and discuss goings on and specials involving New York Eats & Treats Restaurant. . Heber, Arizona. Travis Branam. 30w · Public …
New York Eats And Treats – CLOSED, 1945 Arizona Highway 260 …
New York Eats & Treats is a charming eatery located in Heber AZ offering a delightful blend of classic New York-style cuisine and comforting treats.
Italian Food at New York Eats and Treats in Heber-Overgaard
Santa Always Meets the Best People at Chef Pappa Joe Riccardi New York Eats and Treats in Heber- Overgaard! Say Hello to Kim and Dean …
Reviews
Mary Montgomery
Both are dishes were delicious we will be back for sure!
… moreHannah Conner
We stopped by intending to have dinner, but when we saw the menu pricing we just grabbed a slice of cheesecake. I don’t know what a place serving food on plastic plates with napkin dispensers and plastic cups is doing charging $22 to $24 per entree. Those are fine-dining prices. The cheesecake tasted good but the coffee was below average.
… moreThoughts 4u
Loved the entire experience at this restaurant. I had the best, most flavorful Italian food I have ever eaten. Our server was delightful, we had such friendly interaction with her and she took good care of us. Great atmosphere! Highly recommend.
… moreThomas Lott
New York Eats & Treats is hands down one of the best Italian restaurants I’ve visited in a long time. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warm hospitality and a cozy, inviting atmosphere that feels both authentic and modern.
The menu is a dream for anyone who loves Italian cuisine — each dish is clearly made with care, fresh ingredients, and a passion for flavor. The pasta is perfectly cooked, the sauces are rich and well-balanced, and the portions are generous without being overwhelming. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic like meatballs or a more unique house special, you won’t be disappointed.
The service is just as excellent as the food. The staff are friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu, offering great recommendations and ensuring every detail of your experience is perfect.
Don’t skip dessert — the tiramisu and cannoli are absolutely divine! But the cheesecake is a must!
If you’re looking for a place that delivers consistently delicious Italian food in a welcoming setting, New York Eats & Treats should be at the top of your list. A must-visit for locals and tourists alike!
… moreThe menu is a dream for anyone who loves Italian cuisine — each dish is clearly made with care, fresh ingredients, and a passion for flavor. The pasta is perfectly cooked, the sauces are rich and well-balanced, and the portions are generous without being overwhelming. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic like meatballs or a more unique house special, you won’t be disappointed.
The service is just as excellent as the food. The staff are friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu, offering great recommendations and ensuring every detail of your experience is perfect.
Don’t skip dessert — the tiramisu and cannoli are absolutely divine! But the cheesecake is a must!
If you’re looking for a place that delivers consistently delicious Italian food in a welcoming setting, New York Eats & Treats should be at the top of your list. A must-visit for locals and tourists alike!
Dave Owens
Had lunch here today for the first time. The spaghetti and meatballs was fantastic! Possibly the best sauce I have ever had! My wife had the meatball Parmesan sub, and she said it was great as well. Looked at the dinner menu, and we will be trying it very soon. Service was great, and the food was up quick. Great place!
… moreCaleb Butler
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I loved my meal at New York Eats and Treats in Heber, AZ! The spaghetti and meatballs were fantastic—perfectly cooked pasta, rich marinara, and huge, juicy meatballs. The staff was friendly, and the atmosphere was cozy. If you’re nearby, don’t miss it! I can’t wait to return!
… moreI loved my meal at New York Eats and Treats in Heber, AZ! The spaghetti and meatballs were fantastic—perfectly cooked pasta, rich marinara, and huge, juicy meatballs. The staff was friendly, and the atmosphere was cozy. If you’re nearby, don’t miss it! I can’t wait to return!
D&T Miles
We ordered shrimp fettuccini, lasagne, chicken Parmesan and Piccata for take-out. Very generous portions and very fast. Food was delicious, hot, and definitely fresh. Highly recommended and can’t wait to try the lunch menu!
… moreKirk Affolder
Nice quiet place to enjoy a delicious dinner. We had shrimp scampi and chicken parm. No alcohol at this time. Work in progress. Small venue, but nicely kept. I’ll visit again.
… moreSherry Sessa
Their food is the best Italian food I have ate in years. So happy they are in our beautiful town. Everyone must try! You will go back!
… moreAmber t
Papa Joe says “I love to feed people and make them happy.” This is the absolute truth. Love is the main ingredient, and you can taste it. Everything I have tried has been excellent, and I am always greeted with smiles by Papa Joe and the staff.
The food is fresh, and I always get at least 2 meals out of the good-sized portions each time. It is the best Italian food I have found; it is like a home-cooked meal at your extended Italian family member’s home. And what a cute little building.
It is so hard to choose a favorite, and it depends on lunch or dinner menu (and availability), but…just a few are the Chicken Piccata, Turkey Provolone, The New Yorker, Chicken Parmesan, lasagna soup (any soup)…and don’t forget the cannoli!
… moreThe food is fresh, and I always get at least 2 meals out of the good-sized portions each time. It is the best Italian food I have found; it is like a home-cooked meal at your extended Italian family member’s home. And what a cute little building.
It is so hard to choose a favorite, and it depends on lunch or dinner menu (and availability), but…just a few are the Chicken Piccata, Turkey Provolone, The New Yorker, Chicken Parmesan, lasagna soup (any soup)…and don’t forget the cannoli!