Amanda Rajek
Amazing customer service! Placed an order this afternoon for one of my coworkers that was out in the area and was stranded for a bit. He was going to be waiting for a few hours and had nothing to eat. I called Overtime since it was super close and they went above and beyond for us. My coworker loved his Ruben sandwich and Diet Coke . Thanks so much for helping him out, we appreciate it! Everything was a 10/10!
… moreJannae Poole
Came here lastnight! Food was great! They have tater tot bowls that are awesome, bf got an orange chicken and rice bowl & he said it was great!
… moreGlen Davis
This place was a great stop before we go to the marina fishing. The bathroom was clean. Beer in a bottle $3.50. Tall mixers $5/7. The bartender Karley was great. Very good service, easy on the eyes, and very good at mixing drinks. Stop in and say Hello to her. Very nice and a good personality. Thanks for the Pizza.
… moreAlex Albrecht
Being in town for the NFL Draft, I wanted to explore places a bit off the main tourist path and get a feel for the local scene. That’s how I happily stumbled upon Overtime Sports Bar and Grill, and what a fantastic find it was!
From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was incredibly welcoming. The staff were super friendly and attentive, making me feel right at home even though I was clearly an out-of-towner. It genuinely felt like a positive, local neighborhood spot where everyone was just there to have a good time.
And the food! It was exactly what you hope for from a great sports bar – delicious, well-prepared comfort food. Everything I tried was tasty and satisfying.
The combination of the friendly vibe, great service, and really good food made my visit to Overtime a definite highlight of my trip. If you’re in the area and looking for a genuine, friendly spot with solid food away from the main tourist hubs, Overtime Sports Bar is an absolute must-visit.
Definitely earned its 5 stars! Highly recommend and would happily return.
… moreDevon Buechel
Rating would be higher but this place seems like its dying. Taking good stuff off the menu like brisket, and the food quality seems to have fallen off.
… moreJustin Liegl
Nice little lunch spot as I am 5 minutes down the road! With options limited, I gave this place a shot and wasn’t disappointed. The burger I had was average and the fries were good. Prices are pretty fair for what you get. Service was great and the place looks like it hosts quite a bit of events! Will be back!
… moreJulie Bustrak-Komorowski
We were promptly seated, after watching people at other tables who were seated after us get their orders taken for a half hour we left. Since this was the 2nd time this happened to us tonight. We are not too impressed with the Packer Inn nor this place. Who knew trying to patronize Manitowoc county restaurants could be so frustrating!
… moreJohn Weber
Try the tenderloin sliders as an appetizer or a meal. Service getting better everyday. Fun to be had at Tuesday night Trivia and Wednesday night Xtreme Bar Bingo. Delicious steak sandwich and tenderloin sliders. Elizabeth is the BEST waitress!!!
… moretony zim
Was super loud, waitress, kept walking around but not to the tables. Looked like she was maybe training but not being trained. Many tables were curious what was taking so long. Did apologizes and bring a treat
… moreJenn Shove
Terrific place and great management. This place has done some wonderful dishes, wow! So much flavor and service….A place to try for sure!
… more