Address and Contact Information
Address: 198 Winton Rd N, Rochester, NY 14610
Phone: (585) 270-8650
Website: https://baygoodman.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Bay & Goodman Pizza – Rochester | Best pizza near me in …
Looking for the best pizza near you? Visit Bay & Goodman Pizza – Rochester in Rochester for authentic pizza. Open Sunday – Wednesday 3 PM – 8 PM, …
Original Bay Goodman | Rochester NY – Facebook
Original Bay Goodman, Rochester. 2302 likes · 2 talking about this · 601 were here. Pizza place.
Bay Goodman Pizza Delivery Menu | 198 Winton Rd N Rochester
Order delivery or pickup from Bay Goodman Pizza in Rochester! View Bay Goodman Pizza’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …
Reviews
Dave “Doodles” Newman
Can’t do 5 stars just yet. Went neutral on atmosphere because I didn’t pick it up. As for the product completely satisfied. May be our new go to and hope not to be disappointed at some point after being a long time customer. We used to order from the original location back in the 70s. My aunt and uncle loved this place. I remember their pizza loaded with grease. I think this place invented the cup pepperoni filled with pepperonijuice… that’s what I’m calling it. very good. You’re welcome.i didn’t take pix. Next time
… morePeter H
Throughout the history of mankind, the great tablets of various cultures have furthered the remarkable journey of man. Moses came down from the mountain with the Ten Commandments. Hammurabi had his legal code written down in ancient Babylon. We have the Rosetta Stone that unlocked ancient secrets through language. One could even look to, much to the chagrin of child behaviorist, the modern IPad. Where can sociologists look to for the next great tablet of man?
The answer can be found at Bay Goodman Pizzeria. Their sheet pizza evokes all the savoir faire of generations of pizza knowledge while simultaneously creating a product that feels current and modern. The pizza is a 360 degree showcase of pizza perfection . From the bottom to the top, one is drawn to it. I found the cook on the pizza to be exemplar.
Like any great sheet pizza, it congeals in the most satisfying and gastronomically advanced way. If this pizza could play Super Smash Brothers, no quantity of button mashing could replicate it. Every move, every ingredient, every degree of the pizza oven was done with intent. Five Stars.
… moreThe answer can be found at Bay Goodman Pizzeria. Their sheet pizza evokes all the savoir faire of generations of pizza knowledge while simultaneously creating a product that feels current and modern. The pizza is a 360 degree showcase of pizza perfection . From the bottom to the top, one is drawn to it. I found the cook on the pizza to be exemplar.
Like any great sheet pizza, it congeals in the most satisfying and gastronomically advanced way. If this pizza could play Super Smash Brothers, no quantity of button mashing could replicate it. Every move, every ingredient, every degree of the pizza oven was done with intent. Five Stars.
devildogvet1775
Missed them when first Winton location closed. Not missing them anymore. I wanted to get pizza and wings somewhere else. Anywhere else. Family said let’s give them one last try. A while back daughter ordered pizza and wings. Pizza was ready for pick up but wings hadn’t even been dropped yet. She had to wait 20 minutes for wings as pizza got cold. No accommodations were made. No apology.
Tonight we ordered $63 (with tip) of food for delivery
1. we ordered pizza with Pepperoni only on half…..pizza came with pepperoni on entire pie.
2. They forgot our Caesar salad. Called and had to wait an hour for it to be delivered.
3. The wings were pitiful. No color of sauce. Looked like plain fried wings with a grease slick on it. Ordered hot. There was no heat at all.
So three strikes you are out. Sad as pizza is really good but execution, attention to detail and service is atrocious. To many issues , disappointments and frustrations to keep ordering from Bay Goodman on Winton.
… moreTonight we ordered $63 (with tip) of food for delivery
1. we ordered pizza with Pepperoni only on half…..pizza came with pepperoni on entire pie.
2. They forgot our Caesar salad. Called and had to wait an hour for it to be delivered.
3. The wings were pitiful. No color of sauce. Looked like plain fried wings with a grease slick on it. Ordered hot. There was no heat at all.
So three strikes you are out. Sad as pizza is really good but execution, attention to detail and service is atrocious. To many issues , disappointments and frustrations to keep ordering from Bay Goodman on Winton.
Brian Tucker
This is our go-to pizza spot. The food is always top notch and ready on time. The staff is super friendly. So glad to have them in our neighborhood.
… moreDavid Gaylord
So Glad they are back in one of the same locations previously occupied. Bay and Goodman Pizza has been around for decades. I recall going to the original location at Bay St. And N. Goodman in the Bar to Pick up our big orders for dinner at the RFD Fire Dispatch Office. Now, just since they opened here I had the Deluxe Pizza better than I remember! And, being just me I’m so glad they make small pies, hardly anyone does that anymore! Try them here on N. Winton and Blossom Rd. I promise you’ll be glad you did!!!
… moreRyan
My wife and I moved to Rochester 3 years ago from Buffalo and we have been on a never ending pizza search for our “go-to” spot. The majority of spots in this area charge very high prices for not so high quality food. This place has a really solid pizza and the prices remind of what we would have paid in the early 2000’s. Most place are charging upwards of $30 for a large pie. They have a deal on Wednesdays for $18. Non Wednesdays for $21. That’s dam good for this area in this economy. This is about to be the spot if you want good pizza and wings and don’t want to spend a 1/5 of your paycheck to get it.
… moreMarissa Cavenagh
Wow!! Ordered wings to go and I am IMPRESSED!! These wings are large, juicy, flavorful and cooked to perfection. I’ll be coming back for every flavor
… moreJackie White
Pizza and salad were both delicious. So happy to have them back on the neighborhood. Plus the food was delivered earlier than it was scheduled. Thanks!
… moreKathryn Jensen
I’ve been eating Bay & Goodman pizza for almost fifty years. Our pizza tonight was – as always – delicious!
… moreDan Zambito
A well oiled machine! Everything that comes out of Larry’s kitchen is perfection
… more