Bobby Lewullis
Absolutely love this place. Great atmosphere, friendly staff, and drinks that are consistently on point. The bartenders know what they’re doing and make you feel welcome from the moment you walk in. Perfect spot to hang out with friends, unwind after a long day, or start a great night out. Music, vibes, and service are all top-notch. Highly recommend — I’ll definitely be back.
… moreShugufa Ramin
College Hill Tavern consistently delivers wings that hit the spot every single time. While many may flock to the bar for drinks, I find myself stopping by just for their amazing wings. The perfect blend of flavor and crispiness makes it a go-to treat, making this tavern a wing lover’s paradise.
UPDATE: When we first entered, we sat in the corner and when given the menus they were filthy and stained. My friend ordered buffalo tenders for $13 but the tenders were both dry and small. In total there was 3 tenders and he only ate half of the one and the manager said he either had to pay and get nothing or get the order remade. He also tried to clear our table when we were still eating. When the tenders were remade we saw a drastic difference in how fresh it was compared to the old food they served. The waitress also made another table of guests give us our food and it was very lazy. We never saw her again until it was time to pay the tab.
… moreKendyll Hedgepath
Worst bar ever… limited seats at the bar. We ordered double titos with seller no titos on the drink. The pinot tasted like poop. Dj was fire but couldn’t stay. How do you lock the front door and have no seat? Came for my bday never again.
… moreMegan Schwartzinger
The manager was really nice to me, I think it was because I’m a redhead. Lol, but anyway, food was great, really clean atmosphere, genuine, wholehearted individuals. The owners have a wonderful mindset and are only looking to make the most out of their family on business. Love this place. Emiliana 10/10 bartender
… moreLela Strysky
Consistently great food and drinks . One of my favorites is the awesome Peanut Butter Burger. It’s juicy, yummy and has tons of flavor. The Jersey Burger with the fried egg and pork roll is another great choice. A great home town Tavern that never disappoints!
… moreJordan Vargo
I stopped by for Plant Bingo. While that was fun to play and it wasn’t too crowded, the service was extremely slow. I was in visible view of my server and they started taking care of another table that was seated after I ordered a drink. They brought their drinks out before they brought me a canned drink. Took about 10 minutes before they realized. After that, they checked on me only one more time. I closed out my tab with another server/bar tender by the time I wanted to leave.
… moremaurice gray
Buffalo chicken cheesesteak and fries are delicious!
Update: Ate there today the burgers are delicious and the service was great!
… moreJacob Maurer
The service is horrible. Just bad people who work here the food is okay but the workers make it insufferable.
… moreRicardo Ramirez
Best wings in town hands down. Fast service and its always a vibe.
… morerichie conolly
Some of if not the best service I have ever had. We were there with 4 kids for lunch. One of our kids dropped a chicken tender and the staff fired another chicken tender to bing out for her. If I could give 10 stars I would.
… more