Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1018 N Lake Park Blvd, Carolina Beach, NC 28428
Phone: (910) 458-7010
Website: https://fentonispizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fentoni’s Pizza
PIzza, Slices, Stromboli, Calzone, Food, Restaurant, Carolina Beach, NC, Take out, Delivery, Dine in, Pepsi, Pizzeria, Italian,
Fentoni’s Pizzeria – Home – Menu, prices, restaurant reviews
Fentoni’s Pizzeria, Carolina Beach, NC. 533 likes · 426 were here. Italian Restaurant.
Menu – Fentoni’s Pizza
Fentoni’s Pizza 910-458-7010 · Home · Specialty Pizza’s · Daily Specials · Menu · More. Home · Specialty Pizza’s · Daily Specials · Menu …
Reviews
Mike Mike
Their Philly steak subs are my favorite, the pizzas are excellent, and the service is always quick.
… moreChristina Groseclose
We eat here often and the food and service is always great! Normally we get the calzone and a regular pizza but tonight we got the Sicilian and I highly recommend giving it a try also! Everything is delicious!
… moreTaylor Ward
This is really like genuine NYC pizza – perfect crispy crust that has a great bite, good flavor on the sauce and toppings. Price is also very affordable, with slices less than $5. Don’t hesitate to stop here for a good bite!
Only feedback is that they should add margarita to the menu!
… moreOnly feedback is that they should add margarita to the menu!
Michael Quattlebaum
Went on a recommendation and glad I did. I can’t explain it exactly but this pizza made me feel nostalgic. Excellent all the way around. Generous with everything. The sauce slightly sweet and perfect. I had a pepperoni and sausage slice. Can’t wait to have a fresh pie. They are heavy handed with the cheese so let them know if you dont want a lot of cheese. Seems like their baseline is my vision of extra cheese. Still I’ll ne driving happily from downtown to scratch my pizza itch. Very good.
… moreJennifer
We decided on pizza and wings for dinner and wanted our order delivered. Fentoni’s does not disappoint. Everything was delicious and flavorful. Pizza had that cheese drip that I love and the wings were crispy with just the right amount of sauce. Mozzarella sticks were good too! Delivery was only 30-45 min on a Monday night. We will order here again on our next trip to Carolina Beach!
… moreMelanie Chrisman
I’m here on vacation and im glad I picked this place when I was craving a slice. The service is great and this really is super authentic NY pizza. I love the crust! Not too chewy, not too soft, not too thick, not to crispy. Just perfect.
… moreAngelo Sciortino
This pizza is amazing, and the Ravioli were as well. Delivery was spot on. Warm and delicious.Thank you for a fantastic first meal at Carolina Beach. We will definitely be back.
… moreAllie Pyles
Pizza was delicious! I love a good, floppy slice with lots of cheese and not too much sauce. We also had an order of garlic knots to share which were quite tasty. Service was excellent and our kids were amazed by the 80 lb batch of dough the team was dividing. The guy who took our order was super friendly and engaging telling us about the process.
A note to families on the atmosphere- could have been the time of year/day we stopped in. The boardwalk at Carolina Beach was a tad unsavory for us. We’re not uptight, stick in the butt kind but there were folks stumbling around during the middle of the day and glassy eyes. No danger, just not the place we choose to have our young kids if possible. Fentoni’s was a little haven after we’d accidentally strolled into a couple different bars with our kids in tow.
… moreA note to families on the atmosphere- could have been the time of year/day we stopped in. The boardwalk at Carolina Beach was a tad unsavory for us. We’re not uptight, stick in the butt kind but there were folks stumbling around during the middle of the day and glassy eyes. No danger, just not the place we choose to have our young kids if possible. Fentoni’s was a little haven after we’d accidentally strolled into a couple different bars with our kids in tow.
Andrew R
Exactly what I was looking for a classic New York style pie. No frills, no hype, just a really solid pie at a really appropriate price. It’s local, they do a great job. They were well staffed, place was buttoned up and clean. I was able slide in and slide out for a take-out order with ease.
… moreDanda Naveen
Nice place for a pizza after a tiring day at beach. Large plain pizza at $18 and then you can add toppings for $3 & $4.5 each. They give slices as well and they do have calzones. Place is good enough, don’t think its small byt look of front entrance with bar like sitting, they have some decent setup on the back. Fountain drinks and bottles too. Restrooms available for customers. Food is decent when its hot, service is too good.
… more