Felicia Bailey
This was my husband and I’s first time here and we can’t say enough about our experience! Welcomed warmly upon our arrival in to a homey friendly environment! The food was amazing!!!! Can’t recommend enough! The arancini, meatballs, Chicken Angelina and Chicken Parmigiana were old school Italian…reminders of my husband’s grandmothers cooking! Our waitress Tricia was lovely and accommodating! Celebrating our anniversary here was a pleasure and we look forward to our next visit! Go see Joey and his staff, you won’t regret it!
… moreBob and Dara Raffaele
We arrived for the early bird specials. Reasonably priced with good portion size. The service was excellent. Our waitress was very attentive. The ambience of the restaurant is pure Italian…from the music to the photos on the wall. As far as the food goes, the bread with oil was tasty and a nice appetizer. We had a party of eight and EVERYONE loved their meal. Personally, I had flounder it was the tastiest I ever experienced. We got to talk to the owner, Joey M. and he was gracious enough to take a photo with my daughter. She loves his Facebook page. Ample parking across the street from the restaurant and there is street parking as well. This was our second visit and we are looking forward our next one already.
… moreBob Goodyear
Hey Joe, a ship is only as good as it’s Captain,, and you are one fine Captain. The Bayville Long Island Senior group visited your restaurant on Monday December 1,2025. The Christmas decor was festive and put us all in the holiday spirit. The food was delicious and the wait service was courteous and very efficient. But the highlight of our visit was the entertainment you shared with us. Singing Christmas carols, old time favorites and of course the very funny jokes you told. All made for a memorable night of Christmas joy, good food and fabulous hospitality. I will be sharing our experience with all my friends. The next time we are in the vicinity, you can count on a visit. Sincerely Bob G, Vice President of the Bayville L.I. Senior Center ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreKimberly bartol
We had a party of 4 everything was fabulous except you don’t advertise that your a BYOB we had to pay 28$ for a SMALL bottle of sutter home. We were the only table that didn’t know it was also a a BYOB you should add that to your website. We will be back
… moreA-Line Development
This is one of my favorite places. I absolutely love Joey M. as a singer and he hires other classic singers for entertainment. This place is fun, engaging, romantic, delectable and delicious. I consider this one a tiny hidden gem!
… moreJohn M
Wife and I were there last night after the Italian Festival boy what a fantastic time.
The best Italian spot not in Italy.
The food, the service, the entertainment was top shelf all the way. Thank you very much Joey and staff for making g us feel like Family.
… moreJulian Ciccone
I was in Wildwood with family on a little vacation and wanted good traditional Italian food and let me tell you this is the place to go! The Chicken Marsala was incredible definitely will be coming back service was also great!
… moreKelly C
I love the staff here, the customers the atmosphere the place is like a family run business where everyone is friends. It’s an older crowd love music and good drinks, the food however is just average at best, the marinara sauce was way to watery and my meal was was just ok. From what they say the pasta is homemade and it was good but again the sauce needs to thicken up.
… moremichael barnes
Early bird….and all day Thursdays menu with sufficient options.
Delicious food…… Soup. Salad. Entree. Dessert. $22.
Soft Italian music in background.
Chicken dishes over pasta. Pork with peppers and potato.
Excellent and attentive service.
Web site was not updated…..5pm start for early bird in summer not 4pm.. Same menu…..as listed for the winter.
Parking…..On line zone parking.
Supposed to be free parking a block + away but its not obvious where to park or how to park? Call and ask for particulars…..
… moreLinda Gokbak
Just happened to stumble upon this restaurant while looking for a place to eat dinner. Everything about this place was excellent, Food, staff, music, dancing, laughter. We had the best time. Look forward to coming back when in town.
… more