Pizzeria New York

Pizza is not the answer. It’s the question, and yes is the answer. ORDER ONLINE Pizzeria New York Pickerington . (614)862-4743 https://order.toasttab.com/ …

Pizzeria New York – Pickerington 833 Hill Rd N – Order Online

Order online from 833 Hill Rd N, including Pizza, Appetizers, Wings & Tenders. Get the best prices and service by ordering direct!

Reviews

Bria Henderson

The cheese breadsticks were everything the pizza was amazing they are nice people and great at the job they have

… more

Andrea Rudin

Do not sleep on this place! My family and I visited on a weeknight, and the place was completely empty. Considering how good the pizza is, we were shocked. Although, I imagine the vast majority of their business is pickup orders. The cheese and crust were absolutely perfect, and I believe they could hold their heads high anywhere in New York. The only drawback in my mind is that the didn’t have a waitstaff (considering how large and open a space it is!). You have to do all your ordering at the counter, and you get paper plates, plastic cups, and no ice. That all could be a lot better, but it’s still amazing pizza.

… more

Juanita Powell

This place was recommended by a friend however I found it to be disappointing. I was born and raised in New York and I know authentic New York style when I taste it and this isn’t it. Pizza was ok, bread knots were bland. The best tasting thing was the onion rings. Place looked very dirty and dusty when I went in to order and looked like they were moving and not open for business. Staff were cordial but you can tell over worked and not as responsive as they should be. Sadly I don’t recommend this place and I will not be returning.

… more

Steven Hague

Really good yet Hidden Pizza place in the strip mall of Drug Mart in Pickerington Ohio, the inside is a little dark & old fashion vibe you which I like, the only thing is I call in and ask for the pepperoni pizza to have the pepperoni be well done crispy and I just get it normal pepperoni style the pass 3 visits. I highly recommend everyone to give this place a try if you haven’t already & for price ranges a Large Peperoni is around $19 Large Cheese $16 Garlic Knots five pieces which 1 of my favorites is $5

… more

Jack Berry

Pizza was delicious!! We had 2 different pepperoni old world and orginal!! Small salad was a nice size. The garlic bread was great too.

… more

Coretta

Whenever I’m craving a classic New York slice, this is my go-to spot. I always order my pizza with triple cheese, and it hits the mark every time—crispy, cheesy, and delicious. On our latest visit, we decided to branch out and try the boneless wings, but unfortunately, they were a big miss. They were overly sauced, the breading was falling apart, and the chicken itself just didn’t taste fresh. Going forward, we’ll be sticking to the pizza, and I’d definitely recommend skipping the boneless wings.

… more

Asiyih Rajabian

Pizza is one of our favorites! mozzarella sticks, on the other hand, have severely declined. They used to be one of our favs but they’re not good at all anymore.

… more

John and Lara Y

Impressed! Tastes and looks like the famous Bleecker St Pizza in NYC. Great cheese and crust, sauce is good but don’t expect sweet like Romeos/Papa Johns etc. Kind service. Took us a while to try this place because they don’t seem to advertise to the degree other local pizza shops do, but word of mouth brought us here. Will be back!

… more

Robert Kline

This place has the best pizza! I love their style of pizza, the pepperoni pinwheels and their cannolis.
I’d give them 5 stars, but the cook on my pizza has been overdone a handful of times. Beyond that though, I’m a huge fan of place

… more

Jim Weaver

Had an excellent NY style pizza as you would expect! Delicious! Great salad as well!

… more

… View more

Pizzeria New York

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results