Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY 14086
Phone: (716) 681-1111
Website: http://thepizzaheist.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best Pizza in Lancaster, NY – The Pizza Heist
We serve a delicious mix of Italian and American favorites, with daily specials available Monday through Friday. From pizzas, subs, and wings to tacos, wraps, …
The Pizza Heist – Lancaster, NY 14086 (Menu & Order Online)
Online ordering menu for The Pizza Heist. The Pizza Heist is the restaurant to get a meal for a steal in Lancaster, NY. Since 2012, we’ve been creating …
The Pizza Heist | Lancaster NY – Facebook
Somethin about a char bbq wing Get your orders in for the Bills game today 716-681-1111 // orderthepizzaheist.com #GoBills · No photo description …
Reviews
M. Klein
Pizza Heist is hands-down our local go-to! Whether you’re craving wings, subs, wraps, or salads, they’ve got it all—but the pizza is the real star. They use premium ingredients and are incredibly generous with the toppings. We personally love their “old school” style: thin crust with plenty of cheese and those perfect cup-and-char pepperonis.
The staff is always friendly, and while the parking lot can get tight during the rush, the food is well worth the hustle. Don’t miss their Monday $13 special! It’s a bit indulgent (we keep the napkins handy for blotting the grease!), but that’s just a sign of the high-quality toppings. If you haven’t been yet, what are you waiting for? You won’t be disappointed!
… moreThe staff is always friendly, and while the parking lot can get tight during the rush, the food is well worth the hustle. Don’t miss their Monday $13 special! It’s a bit indulgent (we keep the napkins handy for blotting the grease!), but that’s just a sign of the high-quality toppings. If you haven’t been yet, what are you waiting for? You won’t be disappointed!
steve c
I was really impressed with the pizza at Pizza heist. just got a couple of slices to give it a try, sweet sauce, worked very well with charcup pepperoni, crust was thick and golden, but not doughy: really good. but really I was there for the wings. The wings were cooked perfection nice crisp skin, and juicy inside. Mediums were more of a mild honey Mustard was solid. but the pizza was substantially better than the wings.
… moreGlen Cogswell
I normally dont write reviews but this place i had to. I ordered pizza and boneless wings was my first time ordering from the pizza heist all I have to say is wow the pizza is by far the best I ever had. The boneless wings are delicious char bbq. I will be a regular customer here. Absolutely fantastic pizza
… moreChris Thornes
Pizza is Good but I didn’t expect to have boneless wings with feathers see pics
… moreNoah Safraniec
Stopped in for the Monday large 1 topping deal and got a Large cheese with banana peppers and onion for about $16. Very good pizza with generous topping portions. The toppings were very fresh and the crust had a delicious oven taste. They appear to use cheese slices, which I like and the sauce is very light and subtle. This is a great deal!
… moreJoseph Andrews
After seeing a pizza review online I thought I’d give it a run. Pizza had a nice soft dough, crispy crust and a slightly sweet sauce. Employee at counter was very good at taking my order when I wasn’t sure what I wanted. Haha. I did notice that they get a lot of people that come in for the 2 slice special. That tells me this is a consistently good food spot. I will go again.
… moreadam sanders
I used to like pizza heist, the last few times we’ve gone there it’s gotten worse and worse. Not sure what’s going on but our favorite pizza place has gotten really terrible.
6 out of 20 wings were massively deformed, and inedible. Supposed to be 10 mild, 10 medium. They were all tossed in the same sauce with the same amount of sauce. All medium. I have young kids that don’t eat medium.
They also won’t let you use a gift card if you’re getting one of the specials? So a 42 dollar large pizza and 20 wings special is rang up separately and your gift card is charged 47 dollars. Crazy to have disregard like that when people are showing loyalty to your business and purchasing gift cards.
Pizza was burnt, but this isnt the first time that’s happened, they usually burn half of it and the other half is “ok”, kind of awful to pay for a full pizza and only half is edible.
I called to see what they could do, they put me on hold for 10 minutes then said they are calling the owner to see what they can do. I was on hold for 10 more minutes and then they said they are waiting to hear back from the owner. I verified my name and number with them and they did not call me back.
It’s ok if food gets messed up or whatever, it happens, that’s fine. But to take my info, not call me back and blow me off is just not right.
Sadly, we won’t be eating at pizza heist anymore.
… more6 out of 20 wings were massively deformed, and inedible. Supposed to be 10 mild, 10 medium. They were all tossed in the same sauce with the same amount of sauce. All medium. I have young kids that don’t eat medium.
They also won’t let you use a gift card if you’re getting one of the specials? So a 42 dollar large pizza and 20 wings special is rang up separately and your gift card is charged 47 dollars. Crazy to have disregard like that when people are showing loyalty to your business and purchasing gift cards.
Pizza was burnt, but this isnt the first time that’s happened, they usually burn half of it and the other half is “ok”, kind of awful to pay for a full pizza and only half is edible.
I called to see what they could do, they put me on hold for 10 minutes then said they are calling the owner to see what they can do. I was on hold for 10 more minutes and then they said they are waiting to hear back from the owner. I verified my name and number with them and they did not call me back.
It’s ok if food gets messed up or whatever, it happens, that’s fine. But to take my info, not call me back and blow me off is just not right.
Sadly, we won’t be eating at pizza heist anymore.
Vinnie Pellegrino
The go to joint for pizza and wings in Lancaster. My family has been ordering from here almost weekly for a decade. Good food, good people, good prices, and fast service.
… moreJessica Carbone
Apparently these are boneless wings. Ordered a small pizza and boneless wings. Got bone in wings. Never got my 2 liter of soda. Called the place to inform them of their mistake and basically get told well we can’t do anything because you ordered online and once it leaves the store it’s out of our hands. Like you didn’t give the delivery driver our soda and you gave us the wrong food. A real business would make it right and just send us the correct stuff instead just get told try and get a refund I don’t care about the money I care about getting what I paid for originally. I haven’t ordered here in a long time and now I remember why. So annoying.
… moreBevy S
I enjoy a well done pizza, however the pizza I was given tonight was so burnt it was inedible. They aren’t consistent. I don’t know why the person who made this would think it was ok to serve this. I would have had no problem waiting if they had to remake. This should have never been sent out the door. The fact that they thought it was acceptable to serve this is enough for me to not come back.
… more