Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Clubby, old-school setup specializing in prime meats & seafood plus wine & martinis.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 951 Caroline St, Key West, FL 33040
Phone: (305) 296-4000
Website: http://www.primekeywest.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu – Prime Steakhouse, Key West, FL
All of our Steaks are Char-Broiled to your liking with Prime’s Signature Seasoning & Served with Fresh Oven Roasted Garlic, Red Wine Demi-glaze and Fresh …
Prime Steakhouse, Key West, FL – PRIME has quickly become the …
Since opening in 2005, PRIME has quickly become the premier steakhouse in the Florida Keys. Impeccably prepared prime beef is the star at PRIME, …
Make Reservations – Key West – Prime Steakhouse
Prime Steakhouse in Key West, FL is located in Old Town adjacent to the Conch Harbor Marina. We are upstairs from Dante’s Key West restaurant …
Reviews
Graff Kelly
Fantastic service and a great dinner. The dining room was a lot louder than usual but still a fantastic time. The crab cake is amazing as usual with lots of lump crab and oysters Rockefeller were juicy and perfect!
… moreTori Tesch
Loved this place! We sat outside and it was not too hot as they had fans blowing. The menu had a nice selection to choose from and our waiter was so attentive and friendly! When we come back we will be requesting him! My husband had the viel, I the surf and turf, and we all tried a little bit of everyone’s dishes. Everything was amazing!
I recommend ending dinner around sunset so you can catch a good picture on your way out of dinner!
… moreI recommend ending dinner around sunset so you can catch a good picture on your way out of dinner!
Jack Oneil
Mike was an excellent server. The meat was cooked perfectly just not a great cut. Both steaks very dry even though cooked rare and med rare. Hash browns undercooked minus the top shell and green beans with prosciutto had hardly any prosciutto. Can’t say enough good about Mike he hustled hard had all the tables and everyone sorted quickly.
… moreRichard Parmar
The food, ambience, and service is top class!! I took my wife and my son here to celebrate their birthday’s.
From the appetizers to the main course everything was great! Even the chicken tenders for was son was gourmet.
The surf n turf was excellent, the Veal (bone in) was even better. If our stay was longer we definitely would have gone again!!
… moreFrom the appetizers to the main course everything was great! Even the chicken tenders for was son was gourmet.
The surf n turf was excellent, the Veal (bone in) was even better. If our stay was longer we definitely would have gone again!!
EL
We ate here for a special occasion. It’s a little hard to find but with a little help we finally found it. It’s beautifully decorated & the food was great! I got the Red Snapper Oscar style. It wasn’t bad but it didn’t have enough flavor & wasn’t cooked enough for my taste. I wouldn’t get it again. My husband had the steak. It was delicious! Perfectly seasoned & cooked. I would definitely recommend the steak over the seafood. He’s a picky eater but rated it high on his list of steaks he’s eaten. The Mac & cheese was really good & the key lime was excellent! The service was great as well! I would eat here again.
*EDITED* We came back a 2nd time & I got the Delmonico Steak this time. No regrets! Their steak is definitely the way to go!
… more*EDITED* We came back a 2nd time & I got the Delmonico Steak this time. No regrets! Their steak is definitely the way to go!
Alexander Pierce
Prime Steakhouse is a standout in Key West and exactly what a great dining experience should feel like. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was refined but never stiff welcoming, attentive, and effortlessly professional.
The staff struck the perfect balance between polished and personable. Service was smooth, respectful, and genuinely attentive without being overbearing. You could tell they cared about the experience, not just the transaction.
The food absolutely lived up to the name expertly prepared, rich in flavor, and clearly handled with pride. It felt like a place that understands quality and consistency, while still making guests feel comfortable and at ease.
If you’re looking for a restaurant that delivers on excellence without losing warmth or humanity, Prime Steakhouse is well worth the visit. I’d happily return.
… moreThe staff struck the perfect balance between polished and personable. Service was smooth, respectful, and genuinely attentive without being overbearing. You could tell they cared about the experience, not just the transaction.
The food absolutely lived up to the name expertly prepared, rich in flavor, and clearly handled with pride. It felt like a place that understands quality and consistency, while still making guests feel comfortable and at ease.
If you’re looking for a restaurant that delivers on excellence without losing warmth or humanity, Prime Steakhouse is well worth the visit. I’d happily return.
Charles Wilson
Visited here for our 10 year anniversary. Reservations are highly recommended. The prices are very expensive. To be honest better and cheaper food could be purchased on Duvall Street but again Prime is a high quality place. We asked for our steak medium well came out on the rare side. Service by the bartender who was from the check Republic was awesome and he was funny with good service. Very romantic place to eat. Not bad but expensive.
… moreBen Munson
Great food and they will let you split a steak and don’t charge an extra plate fee.
… moreDustin Perone
Great date night spot, we grabbed an early dinner at 530, sat outside late May not too hot. Very nice breeze great atmosphere. Fantastic service.
Bone in filet and standard filet are very good well seasoned. Crab cakes are wonderful and the seared tuna is the best appetizer. Very good drinks. Will gladly come back
… moreBone in filet and standard filet are very good well seasoned. Crab cakes are wonderful and the seared tuna is the best appetizer. Very good drinks. Will gladly come back
Marla Davis
Our daughter and son in law got married in Key West and we dined here afterwards as a party of 22. Steaks are obviously their specialty and they know how to prepare them. They have a good selection of cuts to choose from. The appetizers and sides as well as the salads were very delicious. Our server was very attentive and did an excellent job for such a large party. We enjoyed celebrating the merging of two families here. They are tucked away and it wasn’t super easy to find them but follow the smells wafting through the air!
… more