Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Counter-service Italian cafe offering pizza, heroes, pastas & entrees, plus delivery & take-out.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 673 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040
Phone: (516) 326-7879
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gigi’s Pizza – New Hyde Park, NY – 673 Hillside Ave – Hours, Menu …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-10:00 PM; Shop address is 673 Hillside Ave, New Hyde Park, NY 11040673 Hillside Ave, New Hyde Park, NY 11040; (516) 326-7879.
Gigi’s Pizza – New Hyde Park | View our menu, reviews & Order food …
View our menu and reviews for Gigi’s Pizza located at 673 Hillside Ave – New Hyde Park. We serve Pizza, Sandwiches, American. Order delivery & Takeout.
Gigi’s Pizza – 673 Hillside Ave, New Hyde Park, NY 11040 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in New Hyde Park, NY! Gigi’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Last Updates
Reviews
Kitty Kat
12/9/25 **“I absolutely love Gigi’s Pizza—hands down one of the best pizza places I’ve been going to for years. From the moment you walk in, they treat you so well and make you feel welcome. The customer service is always great, and the staff is friendly, attentive, and consistent every visit.
The atmosphere is amazing—great music playing, a clean space, and I really love the updates they’ve made to the dining area. It feels modern, comfortable, and inviting, which makes you actually want to sit and enjoy your meal. Overall, Gigi’s Pizza never disappoints. Great food, great service, and a great vibe. Highly recommend!”**
… moreThe atmosphere is amazing—great music playing, a clean space, and I really love the updates they’ve made to the dining area. It feels modern, comfortable, and inviting, which makes you actually want to sit and enjoy your meal. Overall, Gigi’s Pizza never disappoints. Great food, great service, and a great vibe. Highly recommend!”**
HUSSAIN BAJWA
GiGi’s Pizza truly impressed me. I tried both the classic cheese pizza and the spinach Alfredo pizza, and honestly, they were fantastic in every way.
The cheese pizza was exactly how a great slice should be—perfectly balanced sauce, rich and gooey cheese, and a crust that was crisp on the outside yet soft and airy inside. Simple, classic, and done right.
The spinach Alfredo pizza completely stole the show. The Alfredo sauce was creamy and flavorful without being heavy, the spinach was fresh, and every bite felt indulgent but well-balanced. It’s one of those pizzas you keep thinking about after you’ve finished eating.
You can tell quality ingredients are used and that real care goes into their pizzas. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or something a little more unique, GiGi’s Pizza delivers. I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending this place to others.
… moreThe cheese pizza was exactly how a great slice should be—perfectly balanced sauce, rich and gooey cheese, and a crust that was crisp on the outside yet soft and airy inside. Simple, classic, and done right.
The spinach Alfredo pizza completely stole the show. The Alfredo sauce was creamy and flavorful without being heavy, the spinach was fresh, and every bite felt indulgent but well-balanced. It’s one of those pizzas you keep thinking about after you’ve finished eating.
You can tell quality ingredients are used and that real care goes into their pizzas. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or something a little more unique, GiGi’s Pizza delivers. I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending this place to others.
T Hom
Great local pizza shop. The pesto alavodka square and plain slices are good. Good no flop pizza.
… morevasilios katehis
We have been ordering from here for years and love Gigi’s food and pizza! We recently moved to the area and have been ordering from here every Friday and very impressed every time we have their pizza and so are our friends and family! They say they haven’t had pizza like this for years and we could not agree more! Their regular slice is truly the epitome a New York style pizza. Every time I go in there, I am greeted and served very quickly. Always busy but runs like a well oiled machine! Thank you to Gigi’s for making our pizza experience unforgettable and exceptional!
… moreGlenda Moran
My husband and I stopped here to have lunch. The food is AMAZING! So fresh, flavorable and DELICIOUS! The service is 100/10. Family owned business, very clean, great environment. The owners Rudy and his wife are very attentive to their customers. Great variety of food choice. Reasonable pricing as well!
Definitely will be coming back for more!!
… moreDefinitely will be coming back for more!!
Dina Musso
2nd time eating here and it was the most unpleasant dining experience for me and my family. Pizza is alright nothing to brag about. Everyone that worked there (except for the gentleman who took our order in the front) made it seem as if it was a problem that we had our kids with us. Whoever the owner is should re-evaluate who they hire to represent their name. You’re in a hospitality business – you need to like people and that includes children of all ages. Safe to say not a kid friendly pizzeria and definitely won’t be returning.
… more1ssaa
Prosaic & popular, falls short of epicurian. Looks like a family enterprise. At any time 6-7 persons, nattily attired in ‘Gigi’ uniform, are busy behind display countertop, in collision-free Brownian motion. Affine memorabilia adorns cash register.
Business driven by locational convenience. Patrons appear to be mostly those wanting to fill-up, rolling off the busy stores in the vicinity.
Backroom has snug seating for ~20.
Their app sucks. I reached 5 minutes past store pickup time by app. They seemed surprised an order was even placed but hurried to add pizza will be ready in 5-6 minutes. The half-n-half pizza came after 24 minutes waiting time, far from the char requested via app. They did not skimp on veggie toppings, though. Accompanying fries soggy and garlic knots batch processed {never let an irate patron stand and observe}.
However, 5 minutes in the home-oven and flavors came through, big time.
Overall, family opinion was divided. Willing to give them another try and then scale up, or down…..
… moreBusiness driven by locational convenience. Patrons appear to be mostly those wanting to fill-up, rolling off the busy stores in the vicinity.
Backroom has snug seating for ~20.
Their app sucks. I reached 5 minutes past store pickup time by app. They seemed surprised an order was even placed but hurried to add pizza will be ready in 5-6 minutes. The half-n-half pizza came after 24 minutes waiting time, far from the char requested via app. They did not skimp on veggie toppings, though. Accompanying fries soggy and garlic knots batch processed {never let an irate patron stand and observe}.
However, 5 minutes in the home-oven and flavors came through, big time.
Overall, family opinion was divided. Willing to give them another try and then scale up, or down…..
Kiera Kearney
Gigi’s pizza is very underrated. Me and my family have been ordering pizza here for a long time. the crust is very flavorful, classic new york slice, perfect sauce, and it’s never mushy or doughy. It’s better than other pizzerias in the area!
… moreDarlene Lopipero
I wish I could rate higher then 5 stars
I absolutely love GiGi’s! I’ve been going there for years, and they never disappoint. The friendly family who runs it always greets you with big, welcoming smiles, making every visit feel special.
I also use them for all of my office party catering—the food is always amazing and incredibly fresh. Their penne alla vodka and chicken Francese are truly the BEST I’ve ever had. Shh… don’t tell my Nona!
GiGi’s is consistently outstanding in both quality and service. Highly recommended!
… moreI absolutely love GiGi’s! I’ve been going there for years, and they never disappoint. The friendly family who runs it always greets you with big, welcoming smiles, making every visit feel special.
I also use them for all of my office party catering—the food is always amazing and incredibly fresh. Their penne alla vodka and chicken Francese are truly the BEST I’ve ever had. Shh… don’t tell my Nona!
GiGi’s is consistently outstanding in both quality and service. Highly recommended!
Aniysa Myrille
I really wanted to like this place. I’ve been craving a good chicken bruschetta slice ever since my old neighborhood pizzeria closed down, so when I saw Gigi’s Pizza had it, I decided to stop by after the gym. I walked in hungry and excited, but the experience was disappointing from the start.
There were two men ahead of me who had already ordered, so I stood behind them and waited. No one acknowledged me at all. No “I’ll be with you in a moment,” no eye contact, nothing. I even asked the guy in front of me if we order at the counter or register because I genuinely didn’t know, and he said to order at the counter. So I continued waiting… and still nothing.
I stood there for about ten minutes watching the staff move around without saying a single word to me or the other customers waiting. Someone even walked in after me, waited a bit, and left. Honestly, he had the right idea because I eventually left too.
As someone with years of customer service experience, I understand being busy. But it takes two seconds to acknowledge a customer. That alone can change the whole experience. Unfortunately, after how unseen and ignored I felt, I won’t be going back.
… moreThere were two men ahead of me who had already ordered, so I stood behind them and waited. No one acknowledged me at all. No “I’ll be with you in a moment,” no eye contact, nothing. I even asked the guy in front of me if we order at the counter or register because I genuinely didn’t know, and he said to order at the counter. So I continued waiting… and still nothing.
I stood there for about ten minutes watching the staff move around without saying a single word to me or the other customers waiting. Someone even walked in after me, waited a bit, and left. Honestly, he had the right idea because I eventually left too.
As someone with years of customer service experience, I understand being busy. But it takes two seconds to acknowledge a customer. That alone can change the whole experience. Unfortunately, after how unseen and ignored I felt, I won’t be going back.