Alaa Awan
Great halal smash burgers. Great location. More of a stand and eat type of place. The stools suck. Staff is so nice. Love the fries. No pickles next time for me! Be back soon!
… moreLex
Food: I got a single patty smash burger. It’s greasier than I thought it would be but was cooked well with a nice flavor!
Heads Up: There’s very limited seating and instead of ordering with a person, you pre order at a machine by the entrance
Bonus: The kitchen ran with ease and was very efficient. Everyone was contributing in an assemble line type of structure. I was very impressed!
… moreBella Lu
Smash perfection!! I had their smash burgers, truffle fries, and a chocolate sundae, and everything was AMAZING. Watching the burgers being made was so satisfying, and the crispy, juicy result did not disappoint. The truffle fries were addictive, and that chocolate sundae? The sweetest way to end the meal. Highly recommend if you’re a burger lover or just craving something indulgent. Can’t wait to go back!
… moreCiara Tuyet Sheerin (Tuyet)
Best halal smash burgers we’ve ever had. The lady at the till was so accommodating to preferences and remembered us when we came back a second time. Spent 6 days in New York and ate here twice. Wish we came back a third time. Would recommend the double with the peach iced tea!
… moreM Leung
I recently came across this place on social media and decided to try it as I always love a good burger. Overall the place and good is decent but nothing really special. It’s not too expensive of a place but to be honest I think that 7th street a couple doors down blows this out of the water. The burger itself was very salty and dry and lacked any actual burger flavor. I will say though, they gave a hefty amount of pickles which really helped me finish the burger. The cheese fries were very good, well seasoned and well cooked. The place has a nice look to it but overall I would probably say this is a try once type of place.
… moreBeyza Uğur
So tasty. My go to when i crave a smash burger. I recommend it. Truffle fries are also good.
… moreTariq Shah
Absolutely blown away by Butter Smashburgers! Hands down one of the best halal burger joints in NYC. The patties are perfectly smashed — crispy edges, juicy center, and that signature buttery flavor in every bite. I had the Bombay Butter and it was next-level — spicy, tangy, and packed with bold desi flavor. The fries were perfectly seasoned, and their Burnt Butter Caramel Shake? Unreal.
The place has a cool vibe — casual, clean, and full of energy. Staff were super friendly and the service was quick. It’s rare to find a spot that nails flavor and quality and keeps it fully zabihah halal. Definitely coming back — this spot is a game changer!
… moreFauzee Nasir
Yo! We travelled from Kuala Lumpur to here just for the burgers. Burgers are to die for. Nuff said
… moreThuc Nhan Tran
So yummy!!! I normally don’t like pickles and specifically ask without, but I forgot this time. And the burger was still incredible! The pickles weren’t pungent and watery which was great for a pickle hater like me. The bun was so nice an fluffy which is often rare for burger establishments since they focus more on the meat. Everything about the simple cheeseburger just paired so well with each other and made to order. The soft serve really blew it out the park in my opinion. I expected a quick dessert but I got a really quality cup. The vanilla flavoring just felt rich and light, the creaminess was so so smooth, the caramel was not too artificially sweet, and the crumbs on top just added a extra texture that brought this entire meal to a satisfying stop.
… moreSkeeb Khan
If you’re near NYU’s campus and craving an unforgettable burger experience, Butter Smashburger is an absolute must-visit! The burgers here are simply outstanding—juicy, perfectly seasoned, and smashed to perfection with crispy edges that add a fantastic crunch. The flavor combinations are creative yet comforting, with fresh, quality ingredients that take every bite to the next level. The buns are soft and slightly toasted, holding everything together without overpowering the flavors.
The next time I go I’ll try their hot chicken sandwich.
The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, but super small and no place to sit. However making it a great spot to grab a bite with friends or enjoy a solo meal. The service is quick, and the staff is friendly, adding to the overall great vibe of the place. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Butter Smashburger has quickly become my go-to spot for a satisfying meal. Highly recommend it for anyone near the area—five stars all the way!
… more