4.2 – 344 reviews • Italian restaurant
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
casamiany.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Casa Mia Ristorante
… Casa Mia, where enjoy some delicious food. Buy Gift Card. Casa Mia Ristorante Location and Hours. (914) 327-4155 · 132 Bronx River Rd, Yonkers, NY 10704. Open …
Casa Mia | Yonkers NY – Facebook
Casa Mia, Yonkers. 268 likes · 2 talking about this · 826 were here. Authentic Italian dishes and fantastic hand-tossed pizzas from our familia to yours!
Reviews
Adrian Onemana
Absolutely loved my dinner here. Great quality good for a great price. The hospitality from the workers made all the difference as well. Even close to closing time, we were never rushed, never pressured, and they took great care of us. Will come back.
… moreGMV_907
Stopped in real quick for a plain slice not too hot. As I entered the employee immediately greeted me, stopped what he was doing and asked what I would like. The cost was nearly $5, the slice wasn’t big. The crust was on the thinner side but soft and flavorful slice throughout. Stood out on its own when folded, crispy bottom but not burnt. Nice quality cheese and traditional sauce. Good slice over all. When I walk in, I thought it was just a pizza shop however in the back I noticed there was a dining area, dim lighting and quiet. It was lunch but I would definitely make this dinner date location in the future.
… moreVenice Turraine
This is a cute little gem! The drinks were delicious
The bread was warm & fresh!
Brownie points for that!!
The stuffed mushrooms were ok. Not my favorite. However, the shrimp fra diavolo with pasta was fantastic.
And don’t leave without trying the limoncello cake or take it to go. It’s that good
The service & staff were also great
… moreOrion Pax
Casa Mia Restaurant has quickly become one of my favorite places to order from, and I’m always impressed with the quality of their food. I really appreciate the personal size pizza pie, which is perfectly portioned, flavorful, and great when you’re craving pizza without overdoing it. Ordering through DoorDash is super convenient, and the food always arrives hot and fresh. The chicken parmesan sandwich is another standout—crispy, cheesy, and absolutely delicious. Everything I’ve tried has been consistently satisfying. Casa Mia offers great food, easy ordering, and reliable quality, making it a spot I’m happy to recommend and return to.
… moreChrissy Hernandez
Found this place on Open Table desperately searching for a place to eat for Mother’s Day. Was nervous bc there was a pizza place in front, but it was blown away once we stepped in!! Everyone was great from the guys in front to servers/waiter. The food was amazing, we each got something different and each dish delsih. We will definitely come back. This was the hidden spot we didn’t know we needed the little photo opp in front was great too!!
… moreSAL
As of today, February 5, 2026, I will no longer order from Casa Mia. In the past delivery and orders were messed up and I tried to overlook it but today was the tip of the iceberg. The $40 dollar order wasn’t even worth it. My bruschetta was soggy and tasteless. The chicken wings were cold and had no flavor or taste. Not even salt or pepper. It’s like they just cook and fry it bland. Order it and you’ll see. I had to add ketchup to make it appetizing. They have to do better. I’ll no longer order. They lost a good customer.
… moreAnna Foster
Server gets 4 stars for doing his best.
Perhaps I expected too much.
$135 for one appetizer, 2 martinis, two lower-priced entrees, one dessert, one coffee, tip and tax. Seemed over priced for a place that was drafty and at one point smelled of the dry cleaning chemicals wafting in from next door.
Finally, the red pepper flakes (?) used for spicing up the shrimp fra diavolo, overwhelmed the flavor of the entree.
I wasn’t going to review negatively but I would want to know these criticisms if I were planning to eat here.
I DO wish the owners luck. I hope they do well.
… moreAmanda Gomez
This is one of my favorite restaurants to eat in. It’s cozy and the food/service are always great. They have different specials throughout the week which helps keep the menu fresh. They recently started serving slices (they only did pies and personals previously) and that’s been a nice addition. Highly recommend!
… moreDylan D
We just ordered the meat lasagna and shrimp scampi as a to-go order. Waited about 40 minutes for the food to come out and when we got it home it was horrible. The shrimp was hard and over-cooked and the lasagna tasted like it came out of a can. Would not recommend this place…especially for $50
… moreErica Gonzalez
Depending on who answers the phone depends on if you can ask to modify your order due to allergy reasons. The pizza here is also terrible. Taste like cardboard.
… more … View more