Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5913 Hoover Rd, Grove City, OH 43123
Phone: (614) 875-8525
Website: https://www.tammyspizza.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Tammy’s Pizza – Grove City, OH
Welcome to Tammy’s Pizza – The Locally Owned & Operated Pizzeria in Grove City – where we proudly blend tradition with quality. As a locally-owned, …
Locations – Tammy’s Pizza
View 3984 Broadway, Grove City, OH 43123 on Google maps – opens in a View 5913 Hoover Rd, Grove City, OH 43123 on Google maps – opens in. +−. Leaflet …
Tammy’s Pizza in Grove City Reviews and Favorites – Facebook
Oh wow thankyou Chickpizz Food Stop the pizza, chips and garlic sauce is amazing lovely little treat, get yourselves there and order your food …
Reviews
Brian Switzer
This was our first time at Tammy’s on Hoover. We were there at lunch time and the lone worker, Mitchell, was busy but still very friendly and helpful. We had The Works pizza and really liked it. I enjoyed the crispness of the shell. We ordered at the counter and were served at our table. Bottled soft drinks are available out of a cooler.
… moreKarl Maki
One of the best pizzas in Columbus. Great crust, delicious sauce, loads of tasty cheese and spicy well cooked pepperoni. I couldn’t ask for anything more. I first tried Tammy’s years ago and it is just as good today as it was then.
The strip mall location doesn’t do justice to this hidden gem. You will not regret trying this pizza and if you like flavor, it will be your go to pizza going forward.
… moreThe strip mall location doesn’t do justice to this hidden gem. You will not regret trying this pizza and if you like flavor, it will be your go to pizza going forward.
Nicholas Cohagen
Update-
They forgot half our order. I simply asked for them to replace the order. I paid $8 delivery fee plus $8 driver tip. Owners said middle finger. You eat the charges and we will credit you $18 on an $88 order. They must be hurting. Though we love their food, I won’t let my family eat here anymore because of the service. Sad someone can have the product but not the customer service. And we complain that small businesses can’t make it.
I want to start this post by saying- my family loves Tammy’s Pizza. The food is great. We have multiple gluten free people in the household and they have a ton of options.
Unfortunately we had a not so great experience on Christmas Eve. We decided to order Tammy’s instead of cook. We usually do pick up but due to other engagements we decided to order delivery.
2 of the 5 items we ordered were not handed out to the delivery driver by the staff. When I called I was told it was “someone new” working the front. Totally fine- people make mistakes and we understand that. However, I asked them to repeat the order at no charge- they were closing for Christmas Eve and I didn’t want to ask anyone to stay late just to get me some wings and salad. So I fed my wife cereal and waited for a call from management the day after Christmas when they reopened.
I had to follow up with them and then they were only willing to credit back the missing items. I let them know I was a bit disappointed with this as I felt when you place an $80+ order and it’s missing half the items the whole order should be redone. But they felt different.
Food is good but I will say they OFTEN forget items. This one just happens to be the worst of them.
… moreThey forgot half our order. I simply asked for them to replace the order. I paid $8 delivery fee plus $8 driver tip. Owners said middle finger. You eat the charges and we will credit you $18 on an $88 order. They must be hurting. Though we love their food, I won’t let my family eat here anymore because of the service. Sad someone can have the product but not the customer service. And we complain that small businesses can’t make it.
I want to start this post by saying- my family loves Tammy’s Pizza. The food is great. We have multiple gluten free people in the household and they have a ton of options.
Unfortunately we had a not so great experience on Christmas Eve. We decided to order Tammy’s instead of cook. We usually do pick up but due to other engagements we decided to order delivery.
2 of the 5 items we ordered were not handed out to the delivery driver by the staff. When I called I was told it was “someone new” working the front. Totally fine- people make mistakes and we understand that. However, I asked them to repeat the order at no charge- they were closing for Christmas Eve and I didn’t want to ask anyone to stay late just to get me some wings and salad. So I fed my wife cereal and waited for a call from management the day after Christmas when they reopened.
I had to follow up with them and then they were only willing to credit back the missing items. I let them know I was a bit disappointed with this as I felt when you place an $80+ order and it’s missing half the items the whole order should be redone. But they felt different.
Food is good but I will say they OFTEN forget items. This one just happens to be the worst of them.
Rob Parsley
Tammy’s Pizza is located in the strip mall on Hoover Rd. The pizza is outstanding, as well as the garlic cheese bread. My wife enjoyed her baked ravioli, and we also ordered the fries. The fries were slightly undercooked. However, everything else was on par for a good pizza place. I also enjoyed the trivia board that scrolls interesting facts. We will definitely be back to try other options.
… moreMegan Real
Great crust – slightly sweet and on the fluffier side of Columbus style. I’m generally not a fan of tomato based pizza sauce, so really appreciated that garlic butter is offered as an alternative. Nice old world pepperoni as well. Others in my party had pasta with meatballs (a win), twisty potatoes with cheese and bacon (very good and cheesy), mozzarella sticks (a bit undercooked), and pizza with traditional sauce (the garlic butter was better, even for those who like tomato sauce). Appreciated that there was a dine in area as well.
… moreJared Henkle
My favorite pizza in all of Ohio! They have the best pizzas, and load them up with toppings; cheese & pepperoni. And they have the old school pepperoni! Their cheese is so fresh! The best of the best!
… moreAbsolutely amazing Person
Walked in for the first time on a recommendation of our neighbor.
No one was up front and the place waa empty and then 4 minutes later a very tall gentleman came up. My wife realized we left the coupons at home and she told him and he said “there’s nothing he can do without it”.
We left and did not order anything.
So much for customer service or a first impression.
… moreNo one was up front and the place waa empty and then 4 minutes later a very tall gentleman came up. My wife realized we left the coupons at home and she told him and he said “there’s nothing he can do without it”.
We left and did not order anything.
So much for customer service or a first impression.
Herb Butson
1st time ordering from Tammy’s. We used the b1 10″ get 1 free. Everyone is friendly, even when ordering on the phone! The place was very clean. Nice atmosphere & you can eat in at this location. If you love your toppings, then this is the place for you. There was not 1″ of cheese showing. It was covered edge to edge in toppings. Cheese was good. Stringy when you bite into slice. Sauce wasn’t overly powerful… which I like! Crust had this flavor that makes you want to keep eating it. Prices are very reasonable. Pizza is great, service was 100% personable & its CLEAN. I mean clean! We live near Obetz and this lil joint is worth the drive over to G.C. We will be repeat customers. Trying new stuff everytime we order food. Thanks for a great 1st impression. Many pizza joints can learn from you!!
… moreSherry palmer-lubonski
I ordered take out. When I got home the sub I ordered was wrong, chicken sub has small cuts of chicken breast instead of a fried chicken breast . All I received was the bread and chicken no lettuce , tomato, mayo. Disappointed and will not be back.
… moreMatthew Groves
Love Tammy’s pizza, my favorite pizza in all of Central Ohio, but decided to check out the subs today. Fantastic, thank you! There’s something for everyone at Tammy’s. I highly recommend it.
… more