3.5 – 91 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Crazy For Pizza is a locally owned pizzeria. We specialize in preparing delicious build-your-own 10, 14 , and 18 New York-style pizzas, calzones, salads, desserts, shakes, slushies, and soft drinks. Our walk-up window is open late every day till 2:30 AM for pickup and delivery. Crazy For Pizza is located in the RMAK Building at the corner of SE 18th and SE McLoughlin, just one mile south of the Ross Island Bridge.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
order.online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Claudia Flores
In this economy for 2 pizza’s???? It’s October & these prices are spooky. $2-3 for an extra topping?I have never paid this much for a pizza.. we were hopping the price was worth the pizza.. but my goodness, horrible. we will not cheat on dominos again . The man taking order was kind tho! Overall, horrible pizza. 1/10
… moreAlex Hansen
Decided to stop by on the way home (was craving pizza), and it seemed like a chill vibe. I REALLLY wanted to like this but after waiting over 30 minutes to get my pizza after I wasn’t given a buzzer, and then finally being sent away with only half my order and having to come back to the window to get the other half, I was not thrilled. The pizza was decent, I got a plain cheese, it was average, not really anything special, but you can do way better for the same price elsewhere. The calzone, however, was like a big floppy drippy nightmare that I had to use a pizza slicer just to get into manageable pieces. Grease was dripping like crazy (I hope that’s not what the name is about), and I felt icky after eating it. There was 0 crisp and my jaw was tired from the chewing. I’m afraid to test my luck to see if it was just a bad night.
… moreJill Bingham
This is our second time here this week! The crust is the star of the show! It is airy, chewy and just a little bit crispy. Delicious sauce and lots of cheese. The sauce they give you on the side (pesto ranch, maybe?) is really good, too. Service is friendly and they gave us plenty of grated cheese and crushed red peppers. The price may seem a little high, but they use good quality ingredients and they do not accept tips.
… morenathanael buzzini
I used to get this pizza every night on my way home from work. My go to was a pepperoni pizza, it was originally about $20 and would come with a crazy sauce. I stopped going here cause they raised their price to over $30 for the same size pizza. I saw they reduced their prices to more reasonable though still a bit pricy and got a pizza for $22. I order online and drove about 15 minutes to get the pizza, it said it would be ready by that time but when I got there they did not even start my order. At this point I’m abit annoyed and have people at home that are waiting and we’re all hungry. I had to wait another 15 minutes and when I got home to eat the pizza it was basically just bread cheese and pepperoni it had barely any sauce on it and it no longer included a crazy sauce that is the whole reason I order from this place. I hate to say that one of my favorite pizza places is now worse than dominos. Save yourself a disappointment of ordering from here and get a dominos pizza, I won’t order hear again.
… moreJohn
Almost 18 dollars for a medium is not necessarily overwhelming for a medium cheese pie, but is is whelming to some degree. Medium whelming. And that’s pretty much what you get. Mediocre. “Hey, its late night, whaddya want?” There was nobody else there..I grabbed the pizza as soon as the buzzer buzzed. Alas, it was lukewarm like a pizza made to be sold hy the slice but never re heated.
… moreJordan H
Plenty of toppings and they seemed high quality. Tasted very good but unfortunately the crust was a bit plain and reminiscent of the delivery chains, also not very crispy but that is a more personal preference. If they improved the crust recipe I would go all the time.
… moreLurk Darkly
I’ve ordered ordered here a number of times, although I think the prices are outrageous the pizza is good. Until tonight. 50$ for a medium 2 topping pizza and it was hardly even warm and the crust was PAPER thin. NEVER giving them by business again.
… moreJason
Stopped in around midnight on the way home from the arcade. Counter man either wasnt having a good night, or was sketched out by me maybe? (Black hat, black shirt, black hoodie, jeans, and all black AF1’S) Because he was a bit short with me. Again it was midnight lol. Ordered a small regular pepperoni, soda, and cookie for $25.(yeah that much) Pizza was wonderful though and i consider myself a pizza connoisseur, crust is the halfway chewy halfway crispy type, hand tossed. Decent amount of pepperoni, nothing that can be described as generous though. I would like to see a few more pieces if I’m honest. Soda was great, nice and bubbly. Cookie was the shizznit frfr They have all the topings you would expect from a joint like this. Solid 7.5-8 out of 10. Would recommend to friends and family. Will be returning to this convenient location that was once home to a strip joint. Lol
… moreCara Seeley
I’m not sure why there’s so many bad reviews! Maybe y’all went on a bad day. I got a pizza at 2 AM and it was really good! the cookie I got was even warm. Good stuff!
… morePhil Gordon
Bad pizza, extremely overpriced, horrible service, all served in a parking lot. Calling it NY style is an insult to NY pizza.
I really hate giving one star reviews. But unfortunately this place is such a far Miss on both of the food and the service.
I used a local flavor coupon and barely paid for the pizza but I still felt it was such a rip-off. Cost for a 14″ mushroom pizza with 2 cups tap water was over $32.
Review based on experience 4/12/25
… more … View more