Louis and Elaine
We only had the ice cream at Ami Pizza? but I watched as they made and cooked a pizza. Our ice cream was excellent and the pizza looked and smelled great. The atmosphere is nice, very casual and sort of like a small neighborhood pizzeria. The seating is ample and comfortable.
… moreFire and Ice Turnkey Unlimited Inc
1/23/26 5:30pm. I asked the girl not once, twice but 3xs!!!! To make sure the pizza is well done!!!!!!!! Got the pizza to go!!!!! Decided to sit at beach for a moment of peace. This pizza was so.soggy my fingers went through it!!! The grease saturated my arm rest!!!!! This thing was $30!!!!!! I will NEVER, EVER order anything for us again!!!!!! Like the casino but you can keep the slop!!!!. So disappointed!!! $30 freaking dollars for absolutely nothing as it went in the trash!!! You are gonna kill someone with all that grease!!!!
… moreMelissa
There’s nothing like freshly made, still steaming hot pizza! My husband and I shared the Butcher Pizza and it was delicious! The small was plenty for the two of us, making our meal around $15. Everyone was friendly as well. We will be back. We ate here twice on our last stay!
… moreAl kb
We had this pizza before and it was good, two years later this place is awful our crust on our pizza was soggy very thin so it would not cook because it looked wet! waited 45 minutes and no one was there. will never be back, the girl working the counter Katlin was not friendly at all and this place was expensive. Won’t be back
… moreAnthony Terry
I have getting pizza here for years and I considered it at one time the best on the coast. Currently I consider it the worst on the coast. I got a pizza last night and it was not good. The crust was over cooked, paid for double cheese and you could see the crust with no cheese on it. Shake my head! You had a good thing for a while Scarlet Pearl, looking at the reviews, looks like you got work to do.
… moreAnnette kortman
Been eating here since they opened. Food was good but they improved to perfect !the last three years they have been struggling. I feel each time I eat here there is always an issue !!! Today I ordered a meatball sub and this is what I got!!!!nadty bread and three meatballs! Maybe 4 !!!
… moreJennifer G
I ordered the chicken salad on croissant. It was the only thing that sounded good..if you’re a woman you probably understand what I mean anyway, I get my sandwich (my son went and got them for us) and opened it up to see what it looked like. I saw there were dried cranberries or raisins in it (like the cranberries, not so much the raisins) and I was wondering how to would taste. I took a bite and I couldn’t believe what I was tasting! It was sweet! I am NOT a fan. I have never had sweet chicken salad before. I do not recommend the sandwich. My son got the Italian one and he wasn’t much into it either, but I’ll let him write his own review. The worst part is I was starving and hadn’t eaten for hours. I didn’t end up being able to eat until many more hours. This was a disappointment and waste of money. Wish I had something nicer to say.
… moreTina M.
My husband late night pizza, two nights in a row, from AMI located in the scarlet pearl lobby. We ate it all both nights. Really good pizza!
Prices reasonable.
Popular with hotel guests.
… moreLynard Kedzierski
This place really has gone down hill. Service is good. Food is not good. Terrible would be an understatement . I only have eaten here because of casino comps and it’s a quick grab and go. I would NOT recommend spending money here. The fig vinegar they use
is gross, weird ingredient combinations are unappetizing, the pizzas are always soggy in the middle, they have resorted to using the pizza dough in place of the sandwich bread and it’s super tough and oily and doesn’t taste good. I have tried various things on the menu only to eat a bite and throw it away .
… moreJames Bernard
The pizza here is excellent..and you can watch them make it. It’s always been good. I haven’t had the gelato
… more