Jonas Ofori
Great Pizza. Surf City Pizza got some of the best pizza I’ve had in ocean county. Seriously. I had the same reaction I had first time trying their pizza for second time… and it’s the some. “ wow this some awesome pizza”…
… moreChris N
Been a while since ive been to Surf City Pizza. After years I was happy to see the owner was still greeting customers. Tony is worth the price if admission and the pizza was just as good as I remembered. Went in for 1 slice ended up eating 3 slices.
… moreSean Hyde
Pizza: great crust, generous toppings, sauce and toppings were a little bland. I only had the special slice so I can’t speak to more than that though as far as flavor goes. The chicken and bacon on top didn’t give off much flavor besides salt.
Atmosphere: classic jersey pizzeria with sparse decor, pizza display counter and those same pizzeria booths everyone has.
Service. Fast and friendly and probably the best part of the experience. Definitely what made me choose 4 stars instead of 3 when I was inbetween.
Convenience: good location with easy street parking and access and nice that it’s open year round.
… moreKaren Thomas
I never been here. I take care of somebody in area. The pizza was excellent.
… moreSusan Popik
Absolutely the best pizza on the island! The ingredients are fresh, the crust is tasty and crisp (but not overcooked) and the price is right! Definitely a place to go when your visiting (or living) on the island! A+++
Update 4/26/25. Still the best pizza on the island!
… more360SiteVisit 6317427742
Stopped in with my business partner to grab lunch, we both had the Garden salad and garlic bread. It was a nice size salad and super fresh.
Garlic bread was really good as well. We will stop in next time we are in the area!
… moreAlex Delfino
I’ve been going to Surf City Pizza for literally years now and they never disappoint. Have a great variety of slices, that always taste great, good prices for the island. 100% recommend for a quick and tasty bite to eat!
… moreReza Senejani
Stopped by for a quick visit at LBI and looking for a good fast food place. People are nice and burgers OK! I would recommend steak cheese burger (beef not the chicken) they make it fast and fresh!
… moreLinda H
Two extra large slices! I so enjoyed. Living in Florida has its disadvantages. I miss good pizza.
… moreMichele Turner
I love Surf City Pizza, We drive 2 hours from Pennsylvania just to get the pizza. It’s sooo good. My friend and I have bought a pizza just for the ride home and then for leftovers. I can’t wait to get some more… See you soon and keep doing what you do best ❤️
… more