Haley Jones
High quality ice cream with a great texture and lots of flavor options. Butterfield’s was delicious! I tried the daak chocolate, banana cream pie, and black raspberry. The chocolate was nice and chocolate-y. The banana cream pie had real banana and cookie pieces and didn’t taste like fake banana. None of the ice cream was overly sweet and it all tasted like it was made with high quality dairy.
… moremickey Ghirra
The wait staff at the window weren’t in the best mood, maybe because we went on a hot day but their working in a/c. Ordered the vanilla peanut butter ice cream, which had no taste of peanut butter and no indication of being anything other then unflavored. Waffle cone was stale. Strawberry shake was alright but specifically ordered a banana split with no chocolate, got chocolate. Good thing we weren’t allergic. We will stick to Gifford’s for ice cream.
… moreMiss Mariss
The best ice cream that we have ever had! SO GOOD!! The only problem is it’s 4+ hours away from where we live & I crave it all the time!! The flavors are all so good, and I haven’t had ice cream like this anywhere else!!
… moreAlex de la Torre
Delicious homemade ice cream! Stopped here in August 2025 before heading back to North Carolina. Had their wonderful “Dover-Foxcroft” sundae. Vanilla, chocolate, and mint chip ice cream topped with hot fudge, caramel, whipped cream, and of course a cherry. Eight bucks for more than I could finish. Cannot complain. The best food of any type in all Piscataquis County! Will be certain to return on my next trip to Maine. Highly recommended!
… moreJulie Woolfolk
They make all of the ice cream themselves. I have tried several of their flavors and they all are delicious!
… moreBentley Boyd
Stopped by this homemade ice cream shop today and was delicious lots of flavors to choose from and lovely staff. Great remodel. I recommend the fudge mocha brownie and the chocolate peanut butter
… moreMaris Stella Gil
I always order maple walnut ice cream and tastes great all the time.
… moreCarly Gurel
Yummy!!
We did a flight of 4 kids scoops and they were all really good. And my dog loved their pup- ice cream bowl.
… moreMarcia Leighton
We loved it here!! Our ice cream was super creamy and full of flavor and the kids couldn’t get enough of their treats! Loved how they incorporated area attractions into their flavors. Ranks in my top 5 of ice cream shops.
… moreKassandra Sokol
Great pricing and awesome portions! Mocha fudge brownie and Cupcake pictured in a waffle cone. Tasted great.
… more