Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
San Cristobal, Middletown NY
Order online from San Cristobal, Middletown NY 10940. You are ordering direct from our store. Not a third party platform.
Order San Cristobal – Middletown, NY Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from San Cristobal at 52 Cottage Street in Middletown. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Authentic Mexican Cuisine at San Cristobal – Middletown, NY
About San Cristobal. San Cristobal, located at 52 Cottage St, Middletown, NY, is a hidden gem that blends authentic flavors with a warm, inviting atmosphere …
Reviews
ava teoli
This place has the cutest decor and the waitress was very kind and helpful. The portions were very generous and the food was AMAZING. Everything was so flavourful and well seasoned. My mother got the El Toxico cocktail which was so large and delicious. If I am ever in this area again, this place is my first stop!!
… moreTom Osieski
Food and service is excellent! Had the Janeth Especial. Decorated very well inside
… morePerla R
Guys you must have the chicken quesadilla, me and my bfs fav! We came here for dinner and everything was so delicious i highly recommend, waitress was super sweet and attentive!
… morePeche “Peche” Peche
I’ve visited San Cristobal more than three times in the past month, and I can’t say enough good things about this place! The customer service is top-notch—they’re always welcoming, friendly, and make you feel like family. The food is absolutely delicious, every dish packed with authentic flavors that never disappoint. While the space is a bit small, I actually love it; these intimate spots are often the hidden gems for foodies.
The margaritas are fantastic, but be cautious if you’re ordering our bill got up there quickly. Seven margaritas later, though it was totally worth it for the quality and experience. Overall, this is by far the best Mexican restaurant I’ve been to in Middletown, and I can’t wait to come back for more. Highly recommend!
… moreThe margaritas are fantastic, but be cautious if you’re ordering our bill got up there quickly. Seven margaritas later, though it was totally worth it for the quality and experience. Overall, this is by far the best Mexican restaurant I’ve been to in Middletown, and I can’t wait to come back for more. Highly recommend!
Eugene
This is what you want when you go to a Mexican restaurant. Good food, very large portion sizes. If you are a normal sized portion eater, these size almost feed two.
… moreJennifer Nowinski
Great food, nice proportions. Only complaint, alcohol beverage prices not listed, $50 for 3 margaritas that I couldn’t taste the tequila in. Would definitely recommend for food, not drinks.
… moreJ
Small hole in the restaurant with the most delicious food. The staff is very nice and helpful. Definitely will be going back.
… morePaulo Trevisani
This cozy, unassuming Mexican restaurant was the nicest surprise.
We’re visiting town for the first time and decided to have lunch before hitting the road. San Cristobal was located in a downbeat industrial-like area. At first, we thought we’re going to regret trying it.
That fear increased briefly the moment we walked in and a customer drinking coffee at the counter turned to us with an ill-disposed look.
But just a moment later we’re sitting at this peculiar room, on chairs and tables decorated with rustic paintings of Mexican rural life, all very colorful and uplifting.
Thanks to Covid-19, I assume, the small eating room was nearly empty at noon on a Saturday.
We ordered the house stake with soft tortillas and a cactus salad. They served chips and salsa as we waited.
The whole atmosphere was homey, and so was the food.
The after-lunch coffee was disappointing, but the bill was about right.
Do stop by when you’re around.
… moreWe’re visiting town for the first time and decided to have lunch before hitting the road. San Cristobal was located in a downbeat industrial-like area. At first, we thought we’re going to regret trying it.
That fear increased briefly the moment we walked in and a customer drinking coffee at the counter turned to us with an ill-disposed look.
But just a moment later we’re sitting at this peculiar room, on chairs and tables decorated with rustic paintings of Mexican rural life, all very colorful and uplifting.
Thanks to Covid-19, I assume, the small eating room was nearly empty at noon on a Saturday.
We ordered the house stake with soft tortillas and a cactus salad. They served chips and salsa as we waited.
The whole atmosphere was homey, and so was the food.
The after-lunch coffee was disappointing, but the bill was about right.
Do stop by when you’re around.
Iris D
One of my favorite restaurants in Middletown, we order from San Cristobal at least 2x a week. Their food is amazingly delicious, always fresh & their staff is super accommodating. We love their Pozole which comes with 2 regular tostadas which are quiet delightful. The Pozole is fresh, the broth has a nice thickness to it & the seasoning is always on point. Their variety of tacos placeros is plentiful, one of our favorite is Papas con Chorizo & extra fried hot peppers.
We also enjoy their piña coladas & their flan
Give them a try! Delicious food always takes a hot minute & they do an outstanding job at getting everything done in a timely manner!
… moreWe also enjoy their piña coladas & their flan
Give them a try! Delicious food always takes a hot minute & they do an outstanding job at getting everything done in a timely manner!
Erica
The food was delicious and the atmosphere was very cozy. Our server was incredibly patient and friendly. This is definitely a place I would recommend.
… more