Jenifer Deisinger
We grabbed a pizza to go after 14 hrs on the road. It was very, very good! The only little downside was they put foil over top & all the cheese stuck. But really great pizza! Tasted like homemade sauce too!
… moreSteve Gallagher
I had high hopes. I was looking for a tavern style where the crust was homemade and the toppings were fresh.
I balked at the price. Over $14 for a small 6 inch pizza. Roughly two slices by comparison.
This is a 6.2 on the One Bite scale.
Mushrooms tasted weird. Cheese very greasy. Crust and sauce were just ok. Priced way too high.
… moreJason Struve
I was in town for work, I got to my hotel on a cold rainy night. I didn’t feel like leaving but was hungry, so I ordered a pizza from here. My theory on pizza is that if it is on a pizza circle in a bag, the chances are it’s . This didn’t disappoint the perfect bar pie on a cold night. Crispy crust cheesy and gooey. This pie reminded me of the pie I was raised on. Wish the boneless wings would have been tossed in the BBQ sauce, but I dunked them in the sauce. Got a couple of cans of soda that were ice cold, too… I will be back when I’m in town.
… moreJoshua Gaffney
I paid 38 dollars for a one-topping small pizza. I ordered TWO Wisconsin cheese curds. Hostess says “I didn’t understand what you wanted-click!!! I pur in two orders-*CLICK*
… moreStaci Gates
Highly disappointing. I am visiting for work, so I am unfamiliar with the area and restaurants. I called to order for delivery and the person who answered the phone was rude and acted like she didn’t want to take the call to begin with. I felt uncomfortable asking any questions even though it was hard to find an up to date menu online. I ordered “pizza sticks” thinking it would be breadsticks with cheese and pepperoni on top. Apparently it was just mozzarella sticks, which I do not like. I also got breaded cauliflower but would have gotten something different had I known I was ordering mozzarella sticks. I spent $25 for a meal I’m barely going to eat and that I felt was far from worth the price paid. I will be going elsewhere to find dinner for the night.
… moreedward linden
From the moment that you step through the door, you get that Time Warp feeling. It’s exactly how you remember it from decades ago! The red booth seating and classic decor have somehow remained unchanged. Quick service, short wait and really great pizza. It’s a one of a kind taste that keeps you coming back time after time!!❤️
… moreTammy Ketchum
Was looking for a place to eat,found this place online,read the reviews. It sounded like a good place to eat. It is a must if you like pizza. A little diner with AWESOME pizza,great service.
… moreRandy Ernst
Juke box, pleasant throw back atmosphere and great thin crust pizza. Prompt service!
… morebick dasket
Easily the best pizza I have eaten in my life.
… moreWayne Fields
My family just loves the pizza from Mueller’s. They have a lot of choices in what goes on your pizza. Walking in is like stepping in to 1970 and they are open late. One thing that throws me off is this place has been here a long time, but those red curtains in the front window have been there since the place opened! Time for a change there, maybe I will ask them if they would like a new set but similar color.
… more