Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 148 Middle Ave, Elyria, OH 44035
Phone: (440) 412-4060
Website: https://www.erieislandcoffee.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Erie Island Coffee Co. | The Art of Coffee
Find a Location Shop Coffee. chevron. Locations. Grab a cup of coffee at one of our many locations across Northeast Ohio. Rocky River. Learn More. Elyria. Learn …
Erie Island Coffee Co. Elyria, Ohio – Facebook
WE ARE NOW OPEN ON SATURDAYS starting 07/11/2020 (this saturday!!) 7:30am-12pm. Enjoy all day coffee, breakfast, and lunch. See you there!
Erie Island Coffee Co. – Order Online
Banner image. Erie Island Coffee Co. 148 Middle Ave, Elyria, OH. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 148 Middle Ave, Elyria, OH. Schedule your order for later.
Reviews
Brennen Pribula
Stopped by here for the first time today and it was amazing. The Iced mocha, bacon egg and cheese bagel, and blueberry muffin all tasted beyond phenomenal, and I am upset I haven’t tried this sooner. Will absolutely be coming back.
… moreAllan Robison
The coffee is good. The food is all supplied by US Food Distributors. For the quality of the coffee, you would think they could find some local bakeries to partner with. However, with that said, the cheese pastry and the muffin were good and flavorful.
I continue to go to this coffee shop. It is the best in Elyria.
… moreI continue to go to this coffee shop. It is the best in Elyria.
Jake Goodman
Grace, Kat, and Autumn are the best! Everyone here is always so friendly and kind every time I stop in. It’s become my favorite spot for a quick lunch in Elyria. I love the Cuban and the baked potato soup.
… moreAmari Allgood
My chai latte was good but as a first time guest I didn’t feel welcomed. Felt like the barista was irritated she had customers. Like I said the drink was good but would I go back? Ehh. No warm welcome, not that I need a royal greeting or anything but maybe a little better customer service!
… morePrincess of Yahweh
This place is a gem!! So glad we waited the extra 1/2 hour, until the place opened at 730 am, to continue our road trip in the morning. The barista was friendly and fast, and the locals knew her The cook was friendly and is fantastic at what he does! The design of the place was super cute and original as well ♡
Onto the flavors:
We both ordered a SOB (South of the Border) wrap, but on gluten free bread, which was toasted to perfection… It. Was. Delish!!!! Highly recommend! Did not have much kick, but could definitely taste the jalapeños in it. Since it isnt a premix that they cook with, it could be customized to dietary needs, which is AMAZING!
Had a black coffee, house blend. So good!
Also, a sugar free, brown sugar cinnamon iced latte with almond milk. It had a reminiscent taste of a cinnamon roll.
… moreOnto the flavors:
We both ordered a SOB (South of the Border) wrap, but on gluten free bread, which was toasted to perfection… It. Was. Delish!!!! Highly recommend! Did not have much kick, but could definitely taste the jalapeños in it. Since it isnt a premix that they cook with, it could be customized to dietary needs, which is AMAZING!
Had a black coffee, house blend. So good!
Also, a sugar free, brown sugar cinnamon iced latte with almond milk. It had a reminiscent taste of a cinnamon roll.
Christel
This is the best coffee spot around. I drive from Amherst because the coffee and food is that good. They have a ton of flavors to choose from. The food is fresh, flavorful and always perfect. The service is always incredible and everyone is always nice. The avocado toast is my favorite thing to eat and my favorite coffee is the pistachio ice cream latte. You really can’t go wrong with anything though.
… moreTara Quinn
One of the most rude employees I’ve ever encountered. It’s Saturday morning – it’s going to be busy- people will be upset when you don’t have items on the menu – you’re in customer service darling. You made everyone so uncomfortable and like we were the problem for the shops problem. Poor attitude, poor social skills from a grown woman.
… moreDr. S. R. Wright
When I visit my son and his family in Elyria, I always get my coffee and breakfast from this location. This local coffee shop is a hidden gem and easily one of the best spots in town. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warmth, professionalism, and genuine hospitality. The staff go above and beyond to make every visit feel personal, and their attention to detail is unmatched.
The food is exceptional—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick breakfast or settling in for lunch, everything on the menu is consistently well-prepared and delicious.
The atmosphere is equally impressive: clean, cozy, and thoughtfully designed. It’s the kind of place where you can catch up with friends, knock out some work, or just relax with a good cup of coffee. It’s clear the owners take pride in creating a welcoming space for the community.
I highly recommend supporting this business—you won’t be disappointed.
… moreThe food is exceptional—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick breakfast or settling in for lunch, everything on the menu is consistently well-prepared and delicious.
The atmosphere is equally impressive: clean, cozy, and thoughtfully designed. It’s the kind of place where you can catch up with friends, knock out some work, or just relax with a good cup of coffee. It’s clear the owners take pride in creating a welcoming space for the community.
I highly recommend supporting this business—you won’t be disappointed.
Mariana Hren
This little cafe is so cute, the cook is amazing and makes the E.I.C’s to die for, everything is made fresh, the bagels are perfect and not hard to eat. The staff is sweet, sometimes there is only one worker and the wait can be long but it’s worth it. The lattes are very good!!
… moreckSage
Your team is always working their butt off. We appreciate your friendliness and wish that downtown could be populated with more places like this one. Thanks for the great foods and sips!
… more