Scott Crittenden
The pizza at Nardonne’s is consistently delicious, with tangy sauce and great crust; and the selection of regional beers always offers something excellent. The dining room is cozy, with big screen sports that you can enjoy or easily ignore. In the evening, the society around the bar is always lively.
… moreAthena Bell
Yummy pizza, two small things. We order out pizza with a crust Sicilian style, someone next to us ordered a thin crust. They look like the same crust. Also they don’t cut it in triangles. They cut it in squares, even though it’s around Pizza.
… moreAndreas Aristidou
Friendly staff but mediocre food and environment. I was very disappointed with this place because I went there craving good pizza. We got one of the salads which was not bad but the pizza was not better than a frozen microwaveable pizza from the supermarket, for a higher price and in not the greatest environment.
… moreChris Raj
Always stoked to get the family a pizza from Nardonne’s! Ben and his staff are always so inviting and super friendly. The bar has a great select of beer and wine. Can’t go wrong with the original or thin crust pizzas but we have started to mostly get thin crusts these days. Nice and crispy, super fresh ingredients and the sauce is insanely tasty and unique. You want to get the local experience, then get yourself a pizza, enjoy the indoor ambiance with a cold glass of beer and afterwards take a walk around Baywood and catch the sunset! Done ✔️
… moreSparky
I really wanted to like this place as I’ve heard so many good things about it, but it was ok, I would NOT say it was amazing.
I ordered a large pepperoni pizza on thin crust and one order of the six piece Buffalo wings. As the pizza tasted ok, the crust was difficult to chew. Appeared cooked and like it would be crispy but it was like chewing taffy. The wings were delicious. At first glance they looked like they were covered in a thick BBQ sauce but it was not sweet at all and the heat finally got to me on the second wing.
I recommend the wings but don’t expect the look ir flavor of traditional Buffalo wings.
I will try this place again as they have other dishes besides pizza.
… moreMando Man
Must try the pizza. Love the taste, fresh dough. Friendly staff. Fast service.
… moreHessian Hyena
This is my fav pizza on the central coast and really from anywhere. Hands down the best. I was sad the Atascadero location closed but the adventure to Los Osos is always nice. If you have a chance please stop in and try you won’t be disappointed!
My fav pizza there is sausage, pepperoni and anchovies with a side of ranch ♥️♥️
… moreJohn Fletcher
Cozy, lively and neighborhood style vibe. Best pizza in recent years! Enjoyed every moment!
… moreMatt Dowell
This is our go-to tuck in place for a good glass of wine and great pizza. Old school pizza place with wood panelling and dark lighting. Very comfy.
We get the 10″ thin crust pizza and share it. It’s perfect every time.
… moreThe Fluffy Show
Food was good. Server/Cashier needs a personality and don’t ask for anything she working and has no time for customers. I wouldn’t go out my way to eat here. Service isn’t the best.
… more