Thomas Lynch
une 23 eat in, June 24 take out. – 2 in and four at the house.
My wife and I stopped in for a late evening cheesteak hoagie and I got a ‘vegan cheesteak’ . Hers was pretty good although at 9 pm maybe the rolls were a little aged/stale. My vegan cheesteak was interesting with a faux steak and the grated parmesan cheese was a bit dry and powdery. I would have liked a more ‘sliced’ or melted cashew cheese or some other melted product.
The buffalo pizza and the white pizza we got for take out the next night were both AWESOME!!!!!! bravo. nice job.
… moreRobert Vezirian
The menu said something about their old world pizza quite possibly being the best pizza in earth? Sorry, but not even close and I had to post a quick review for other that might be fooled by that as my family was.
I went with my son daughter and wife and all of us were very disappointed with the pizza and the atmosphere. The mozzarella sticks were very good actually. And our server was excellent. But the pizza not so much.
I have to say the pizza “looks” great in photos but the crust on the old world pizza was nonexistent and the crust on the deep dish was weird. We assume they don’t have a real pizza oven. The deep dish had a crust, but it had the appearance of a fried crust. Pretty sure it was put in a deep dish baking pan with a lot of oil.
I won’t be going back and can’t recommend it.
… moreDanny Ferraro
Absolute mayhem upon entry of the establishment, me and 3 friends got 2 slices each and they got every single one wrong. Watched a Worker basically accuse 2 10 year old kids of trying to steal French fries. French fries. After 15 minutes of standing there a worker asked if we were waiting for slices to which we replied yes and they stare at us and say we have none of those in the oven yet. Not sure what happened in the time we ordered to then but we had to wait another 15 minutes after that. Our slices finally come out and the worker screams my name 3 times in the fastest 1-2-3 sequence possible didn’t even give me a second to get up and come grab it. When I get to the counter she goes I called ur name 3 times already. At this point I’m in absolute awe of this experience I’m having and instead of getting snappy with her I just take my slices and go.
Ordering 2 slices of pizza should not have been this stress induced nightmare but this place made that so. I’ll tell you this, I will not be crossing the threshold of that places doors ever in my life again. Food was pretty good tho.
… moreRick Shirk
Place was quite busy. The host was super nice as was our server.
The vegan wings I CANNOT recommend whatsoever. They looked like Gardein chicken strips overly cooked and lightly tossed in BBQ sauce. Huge letdown honestly.
The vegan cheesesteaks barely had any cheese and came out warm, not hot. Flavor was so so, but definitely not bad
The reason for the higher score was the Sante Fe pizza I got. It was a vegan pizza with “chicken,” “bacon,” and ranch. It was incredibly tasty.
So, if you’re there for vegan food, maybe stay away from the wings and sandwiches? The pizza was great. I’d been here before and had a vegan stromboli that was great too.
… moreAndrew
Pretty awesome pizza. I have eaten here a few times when visiting family in Sea Isle. Traditional N.J. style pizza. Hot and fresh made to order. Good service from friendly employee’s.
… moreK T
Decent food, but very long wait. We were there on a Saturday during lunch. It took almost an hour from the time we sat til the time we got our food. The staff were friendly though.
… moreSharon Byrne
As an islander we have ordered here for beach delivery many times. NO MORE. Today the order was wrong. A Chicken steak works with gluten free roll had minimal meat and no world. The pizza cheese and crust overdone such that the children it was covered for would not eat it. Called and was switched to 3 different people. Told the roll of sandwich is huge so what’s inside looks small amount. Also that only chicken steak was on order. Since an adult ate a few slices of the pizza they would not replace
Worst service and food ever received from them. Time to switch to one of the other businesses on island for future.
… moreJoe Klepchick
Dried out and burnt pizza order of 2 medium pie. Ordered 2 slices of margerita pizza also dried out burned and must have the last one of the day. Never order again from Ogies again. Manager would not even come to counter to hear my complaint. Did refund my credit card charge. Only thing done right.
… moreColleen Anthony
Just may be the worst cheesesteak I’ve ever had in my life. Bread was awful, meat worse, whiz was tasteless and it was covered in a shiny, unidentifiable substance, which if it was grease might have given it more flavor. To top it off, one small sandwich and one bag of chips was $20. not including a tip.
… moreB K
Was a good place to get pizza, wasn’t too crowded on a Thursday night. Pizza was good and loked it had a slight crunch to the crust. Pinapple/bacon pizza was solid, was more a subtle pineapples taste. Kids enjoyed the upside-down pizza. The buffalo chicken boli rolls were really good. Barnyard steak sandwich was solid.
… more