Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Broken Arrow, OK, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Broken Arrow pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Broken Arrow or stop by 24192 E HIGHWAY 51 for carryout to order the best pizza in Broken Arrow, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Hours
| Saturday | 10 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 10 AM–1 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 24192 E Hwy 51, Broken Arrow, OK 74014
Phone: (918) 505-1040
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
904 North Elm Place – Broken Arrow, OK – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Try our signature pizzas, savory sides, delicious desserts, and a variety of Pepsi 2-liter drinks. Trust Papa Johns pizza delivery for your next catered event.
Pizza in Broken Arrow, OK | Papa Johns S. Elm Place
Order from Papa Johns S. Elm Place for the best pizza in Broken Arrow. Order online, call or visit for a selection of pizza and more for delivery or …
papa johns stores in broken arrow, ok
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Last Updates
Reviews
Madison Shrum
We placed an order for a pizza and when we arrived to pick it up the order was wrong. We sat in their lobby and waited for the re-make without an apology offered and awkwardly hear the middle age female yelling at the employees that she didn’t know who made the pizza, but it was wrong. They give us the pizza and offer a 2-liter for our wait, which we decline. Once we get to the car we realize they forgot our dipping sauce and YET AGAIN made the pizza wrong. Rather than wait for a remake AGAIN we just got our dipping sauce and left. If you want pizza this isn’t the place, make the drive to a different Papa John’s or go somewhere else entirely.
… moreTanChanta Hopkins
The person who took my order was nice and the delivery lady was nice. But how do you mess a simple pizza up? I asked for one side with banana peppers and my pizza to be cut into squares. They barely put any cheese on the pizza as well. Good thing the bread gets you full or you and your family would still be hungry. Oan a ton of pizza sauce randomly placed on pizza. The pizza was not cut either. And I guess since I ordered banana peppers on half the pizza they decided that I deserved the tinys banana pepper on the side for the commentary. lmao what a joke
… moreNichole Cash
Set up for delivery at 7pm ordering at 5:30. It showed up at 7:40. It was just under warm and tasted like it had been cooked an hour or two before. Ordered a thin crust Alfredo chicken pizza and it had almost zero sauce. It was so dry! The only spots that had a tiny bit of Alfredo was a tiny bit at the ends. Like they put a spoonful in the center of the dough and called it good.
Garlic knots were good.
… moreGarlic knots were good.
Meghan Allison
Our family absolutely loves Papa John’s so we were excited to hear about them coming to the BA/Coweta area. Food was great even with being so busy with the new location! Staff was also friendly, and everything was cleaned. Food was also done at the time the tracker said it would be.
… moreMichael G
First time at this new location.. Ordered on the the app… Pizza was made to order, hot and fresh. The crew was friendly and the pizza tasted great. Highly Recommend!!
… moreMARIE ESPARZA
Asked for Cheese and Pepper and female associate told me there .15cents per packet now! I got an email saying my order was ready and she told me rudely that it wasn’t ready yet and still in the oven. I called another location and they said cheese and pepper is FREE!!
… moreNicole Turney
Shout out to Evan. My my coupon did not go through on my online order. He made sure everything was taken care of. Every time I order Papa John’s I’m always so pleased.
… moreCorey Whitney
Every time I’ve ordered from the store it’s on point, so today was no different. I arrived a little early and saw multiple people carrying many pizzas out (5-8), but what I didn’t expect was the one dude workhorse running the entire store by himself. I’ve seen some pretty crazy food service in my life, including working at a certain chaotic breakfast chain myself, but this one takes the cake. The fact that this dude got my order out on time as well as all these others with no help is honestly baffling. I didn’t catch his name, and I hope he gets credit for this, but the lone dude with the garlic butter pop socket needs a promotion to market trainer. Thank you my guy.
… moreSandra Anne
We were out of groceries for the night so I said, “Let’s get pizza.” I had a coupon for 30% off from doing my taxes at H&R Block. I didn’t even know how close they were but it was just down the road so very convenient. The thing is my son ordered the food from the app we had just downloaded and accidentally somehow ordered the wrong thing without even knowing it. I picked up the boxes of food not really thinking until I was walking to the front door of my house. I should have had four pizza boxes but instead I had two and two small strangely shaped boxes, something was amiss. After discovering our mishap which was surely our own negligence, I called to order what I was missing. I just wanted to know if I could get the 30% off since I was coming back a second time but would you believe it? They said they understood and that they’d just fulfill the order as I thought it was going to be, no extra charge. Wow, how often does that happen? Yeah, they didn’t even flinch about it, just exhibited a “Let’s make this right” attitude. I love that so much. I often wonder how much negativity our whole world might avoid if we all adopted this genuine attitude of helpfulness when it wasn’t even warranted. It’s so inspiring to come across in your daily life, but when it does, I think we should shout out about it since we learn from example and we’re all much more likely to be kind when we receive kindness in like from others first. So yeah, way to go, and good on you! Can we get these guys a raise?
… moreMomOf3
We recently ordered from this location for pickup and our pizzas weren’t made correctly however the manager Tyler is such a great guy that he was sure to remake them to perfection the way we wanted them. We will be sure to return back to this location, this location took responsibility and made things right for us and the pizza was tasty! Highly recommend this location!
… more