Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY 11738
Phone: (631) 846-1828
Website: http://hilltopbagelcafe.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Hilltop Bagel Café | Restaurant | Farmingville, NY
631-846-1828 – Buy a dozen bagels and get three FREE. Combo offers are available. Delicious food. Breakfast. Lunch.
Hilltop Bagel Cafe (@hilltop_bagel_cafe) – Instagram
Full Breakfast/Lunch/Catering, BEST egg sandwiches around. ACAI BOWLS, specialty cream cheeses. Located next to Ralphs Italian Ices. Come and get em!
Hilltop Bagel Cafe – Facebook
Hilltop Bagel Cafe. 931 likes. Breakfast, Lunch, Catering 623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY 11738.
Reviews
Alisha B
Why did I come here? Guys this place is Highway robbery. Nothing special about this place. Flavor was so bland. I got a croissant with egg and cheese. And honestly tasted like a Burger King croissant egg and cheese and I’m not even kidding. I should’ve just got Burger King Croissant was not fresh at all. Not sure how this place was labeled as the best. This sandwich cost me $9 like wth?
… moreBrittany Brogan
Love this place! Come here often for lunch during my lunch break and order breakfast for my family on DoorDash a lot. The staff are wonderful and food is always amazing and made/delivered quickly! I always recommend them to anyone looking for great breakfast/bagels/and or lunch who are local!
… moreAmanda P
We ordered from Hilltop Bagels for the morning of our wedding, and it was absolutely perfect! Rich and his crew provided incredible service from start to finish – everything was on time, organized, and stress free. The tray of bacon was a huge hit (perfectly cooked!), the bagels were fresh and delicious, and the variety of spreads that came with the continental breakfast impressed everyone.
They truly went above and beyond, and we couldn’t have asked for a better start to our big day! Highly Recommend Hilltop Bagels!
… moreThey truly went above and beyond, and we couldn’t have asked for a better start to our big day! Highly Recommend Hilltop Bagels!
Kyron
Food wasn’t all that great I’m sorry to say. The coffee was terrible as well; extremely light, more coffee grounds needed when brewing. Service was great. The cashiers and cooks were very nice.
… morePaul Cutler
The owner and staff were welcoming and the food was great. I had bagel and cream cheese flavors I’ve never tasted and they were amazing! Great place I recommend visiting if you’re in the area!
… moreLISA TRIPODI
Very very upset I sent my son to get two egg sandwiches $27 later. He comes home with two egg sandwiches. Where do they get the nerve to charge that kind of money for two sandwiches eggs no less, food was good but not worth $27
… moreMichael Scaringe
I wasn’t going to write a bad review, but after reading all the other ones, I feel it’s well deserved. I ordered a large acai bowl for $10 and this is what they gave me.. the poor kid behind the counter saw my face and said “they had me do it like this, I would’ve filled it up, I’m sorry” so I gave HIM a tip and 3 stars for being realistic. I don’t see ANY honey, a tiny sprinkle of coconut, a couple berries cut up, and a half empty container? Come on now.. that’s silly.. He’s not the one running the show, it’s not his fault. I’ve been there. He didn’t ring me up for the coffee I made but I don’t think he noticed because he didn’t look up after that. He was embarrassed for his employers, who don’t seem to care. I felt bad. As I was leaving to go to Poppyseeds Bagels, where I recommend you go, I saw the bagels being delivered. What kind of bagel place doesn’t make their own bagels? Drive the extra 7 minutes to Poppyseeds Bagels, every time.
… moreVinny Zingone
The review is based strictly on prices. An egg sandwich is a 6 or a dollar item not a penny more . An egg sandwich here is 12+ i will never return! Fix your prices
… moreA B
My breakfast wrap barely had any eggs, peppers onions it was so thin, it was more wrap than anything. They didn’t press the other egg wrap on the grill like I asked and they forgot a side of hot sauce. The $37 on breakfast that I spent was not worth it.
… moreEvan Nangle
I’ve been looking for a great bagel spot around this area, and this one definitely fits the bill.
The bagels were made to perfection, nice and crispy on the outside, with a light and fluffy texture inside. The eggs were perfect as well, very flavorful.
The service and atmosphere was definitely something that would make a trip back worth it. There are plenty of options for whatever your flavor profile is. For sure earned my business.
… moreThe bagels were made to perfection, nice and crispy on the outside, with a light and fluffy texture inside. The eggs were perfect as well, very flavorful.
The service and atmosphere was definitely something that would make a trip back worth it. There are plenty of options for whatever your flavor profile is. For sure earned my business.