Leila
We’ve been getting food from here for years and it’s always been exceptional. We regularly order the ziti pizza pie along with cheese pies. The ziti pizza pies are always prepared exceptionally so we didn’t open the box to check before we left, as we expected what we usually get. Not only was the food terribly prepared, but when I called to order, a staff member picked up and was yelling something at me and I was unable to understand what he was saying. He then hung up on me. I was informed shortly afterward that it was the OWNER speaking to me like that and that he was “drunk.” Lol. Very unprofessional and disappointing. Won’t be ordering from here anymore. Will spread the word too !!!!!!
… moreElias Chelala (Chewy)
The pizza is fantastic—crispy crust, just the right amount of char, and quality ingredients that actually taste fresh. I went with the classic Margherita and a white pie with prosciutto, and both were perfectly balanced and flavorful. The sauce has that rich, tangy depth that shows they take pride in the basics.
Atmosphere is casual but cozy, with a laid-back staff that makes you feel right at home. It’s the kind of place where you can relax with friends over a cold beer and a hot pie without feeling rushed.
Whether you’re in for a quick slice or a full sit-down meal, Il Mattone delivers. Definitely one of the better pizza joints in the area.
… moreManhattanNYC
Tried pizza pepperoni and was good looking and tasty, but the crust wasn’t crispy, which was a bit disappointing. Overall, it’s a decent pizza spot in the city.
… moredannymartin80
I don’t ever leave a review, but I had to for this place. Working construction late on a Friday night. Found this pizza place. Omg, im a picky person. So it takes a lot to make me happy. the buffalo chicken slice and regular slice were unbelievable. One of the best buffalo slices I have had. You definitely got to try this place. And the staff were very friendly as well.
… moreEmanuel Ramirez
Ya have to do better quality is poor and the fact I was picking up before closing usually people are generous and give something out since you want to avoid food waste but nope not even in there mind they gave me 4 slices and nothing with protein plus and unfriendly personality.Definitely never coming back !
… moreMr. Galway
Been in Tribeca for the last year…tried all the spots…this one is the CLEAR winner. The plain cheese aka the great equalizer of all pizza is the best I have found in the city which is a big statement. Cheers to Il Mattone – thank you for being a neighborhood icon.
… morePatrick Krass
Amazing pizza. Old school vibe with friendly staff. The cheese is so creamy and the pie is just the right crispiness. Fantastic slice. A+
… moreCarlos Herrera
Pretty decent, pretty decent
Called to order a Chicken Alfredo here..(be warned! you need two people to eat the whole thing considering it’s size) it’s very pricey but worth it.
… moreNeri Manni
Great and friendly staff! Great pizza!
Price per person: …
… moreIsaac Karner
Man! I’m so glad to see that Il Mattone made it through 2020 and the last four years! A photo of our family with the owner in front of the restaurant popped up in my memories feed, and I had to see if he was still going.
He is a gem of a person. Was so friendly and helpful to our family, and the pizza was amazing. If we ever get back to NYC, Il Mattone is at the top of the list.
… more