Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Welcome to Mim’s Mighty Meaty Hoagies, a family-owned business offering delicious hoagies, sandwiches, pizza, dinners, and home-baked soup. Our menu is filled with a variety of options to satisfy your cravings. Pair your meal with a refreshing soda or cool down with one of our tasty ice cream treats. Visit us today for a mouthwatering meal that will have you coming back for more.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 423 W Main St, Fayetteville, PA 17222
Phone: (717) 352-3935
Website: https://ordermims.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mim’s Mighty Meaty Hoagies : Powered by TakeOut7
Mim’s Mighty Meaty Hoagies. 423 West Main Street. Fayetteville, PA 17222. (717) 352-3935. Go Back. Login. Login. Our Menu. Order Pickup Order Delivery.
Famous Mim’s Mighty Meaty Hoagies
We offer Take-Out / Dine-In/ Delivery. Order Online Take-Out or Delivery · Call · 423 W Main Street, Fayetteville, PA. Hours: Monday – Thursday 11 am – 7:30 pm …
Mim’s Mighty Meaty Hoagies | Fayetteville PA – Facebook
Mim’s Mighty Meaty Hoagies features freshly made hoagies, soups, sandwiches, salads, and much more. For a hot delicious meal, come by, call in, or ask for a …
Reviews
Peter Parker
Mighty Hoagie is a great place with an awesome atmosphere and amazing food. Everything tastes fresh, the portions are big, and the staff is friendly. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to.
… moreMatthew Bockhouse
Make no mistake! I really want to give a 5 out of five for the food… I moved to Fayetteville in 1984 and for 7 years this was our go-to for absolutely the best quick food. I had business out east today and stopped here for the first time in 30 years & ordered sandwiches. I then proceeded to drive back home to Pittsburgh, My only request when the sandwiches were made was that all the condiments be put on the side; As I had told the girl that took my order the sandwiches were coming the whole way back to Pittsburgh before they would be eaten… After five hours in the car with all the condiments on the sandwiches they’re just soggy slimy messes… And I’ve no earthly idea when I will get back there again, Like I said it took 30 years the first time.
At least I got a bag of gibbles potato chips to celebrate my childhood in Chambersburg, And I did get a large meatball which was quite amazing I ate that on the way… I think I took the last bite as I was driving through downtown Chambersburg, so it was not long for this world I know these sandwiches would have tasted amazing too but I bought them at 7:30 at night It’s 1:00 in the morning and I just walked in my kitchen with them ♂️
#devestated
Takeaways, absolutely go here, This place is the best sandwich shop I’ve ever eaten at my whole life and I’ve lived in Chicago and I’ve lived in New York City… Eat the sandwiches within a couple minutes of ordering them. I will still eat these solely because I have been so poor that I had nothing in my freezer or refrigerator except a 5 lb bag of rice. Not even a condiment to put on the rice. So I do not throw food away if it is not spoiled I will eat it. It sure would have been nice to have it the way it’s supposed to be had though.
I will go back and I will take my wife with me and we will eat the sandwiches there next time! My opinion of the establishment has not changed from the time I was a little kid. It is still the place to be… I think I just did it wrong. ♂️
Please also keep in mind, my review is not meant to impeding the good folks at the sandwich shop in any way but merely to serve to make sure that someone else doesn’t make the mistake that I made…
… moreAt least I got a bag of gibbles potato chips to celebrate my childhood in Chambersburg, And I did get a large meatball which was quite amazing I ate that on the way… I think I took the last bite as I was driving through downtown Chambersburg, so it was not long for this world I know these sandwiches would have tasted amazing too but I bought them at 7:30 at night It’s 1:00 in the morning and I just walked in my kitchen with them ♂️
#devestated
Takeaways, absolutely go here, This place is the best sandwich shop I’ve ever eaten at my whole life and I’ve lived in Chicago and I’ve lived in New York City… Eat the sandwiches within a couple minutes of ordering them. I will still eat these solely because I have been so poor that I had nothing in my freezer or refrigerator except a 5 lb bag of rice. Not even a condiment to put on the rice. So I do not throw food away if it is not spoiled I will eat it. It sure would have been nice to have it the way it’s supposed to be had though.
I will go back and I will take my wife with me and we will eat the sandwiches there next time! My opinion of the establishment has not changed from the time I was a little kid. It is still the place to be… I think I just did it wrong. ♂️
Please also keep in mind, my review is not meant to impeding the good folks at the sandwich shop in any way but merely to serve to make sure that someone else doesn’t make the mistake that I made…
Teena Wiser
I am 72 years old. Lived here since I was born. No stranger to mim’s. I knew the orginal… The last time I was in there.. i had 2 large hogies they each had 2 tomatoes slices
I could barley see any lettuce..and not much more onions.. we took home too.. NOTHING LIKE I REMEMBERED..I haven’t been back. GOT COUPONS im the mail So I may give it a whirl.. cause I paid quite a bit with I don’t mind if it’s good..I should have brought back but my husband had a hemogentic stroke so was not a good time.. but ill try again cause of coupons.. im not upset anymore. Was then..sorry had to let you know..but it was really bad..Oh I even had to put mayo on it myself at home.
… moreI could barley see any lettuce..and not much more onions.. we took home too.. NOTHING LIKE I REMEMBERED..I haven’t been back. GOT COUPONS im the mail So I may give it a whirl.. cause I paid quite a bit with I don’t mind if it’s good..I should have brought back but my husband had a hemogentic stroke so was not a good time.. but ill try again cause of coupons.. im not upset anymore. Was then..sorry had to let you know..but it was really bad..Oh I even had to put mayo on it myself at home.
Jamie Kauffman
Horrible! Rude! They do not take cards(credit or debit)and then when we only had $55 cash for a $58 total they allowed us to cancel the whole order and walk out over $3 rather then offer a solution. Personally I think I would have let the 3 bucks slide rather than potentially lose future business since their prices are steep and they don’t let you know ahead of time, online that they only take cash. They did not once even apologize for the inconvenience, nothing. Just seemed glad that they didnt have to serve us .That’s pretty much why we walked instead of just taking something off the order.
… moreCharisma W
I love going here! Staff is always kind, and the food is freaking amazing. My personal favourite would probably be the taco sub. Definitely recommend!
… moreKaylee Cook
Placed my order 30 minutes before arriving here and was greeted by the owner who was very nice and apologized for the inconvenience. The very young girl that’s in there working had a very poor attitude with me and kept cutting me off. I then went back inside for my food and she tossed the bag at me rolled her eyes and walked away. Food is great but not young workers who don’t know how to treat customers!!
… moreSean Freeman
I just ordered 8 in trk with ham which is $7.50. I literally got a slice of ham a slice of roast beef a slice of turkey and they forgot my lettuce. Not really a 7.50 sandwich in my opinion.
… moreTara Hufman
My husband and I ordered lunch online here while at a softball tournament. Italian cold cut subs and fresh cut french fries were delicious! We will definitely return when we are in the area again.
… moreMarlene Wilkinson
I have lived here since 1998 and we would get mims, food was good but last night I ordered 4 16 inch subs and 2 orders if shoe string fries I got fries for my 4 year old grandson because he always wants fries needless to say nobody ate fries not even my grandson they were the size of tiny burnt hash browns. Two bags looked like food meant for waste loss deduction tiny little shreds not even a inch long wish I could share my photos but it wouldn’t let me. I’m disappointed I even gave a 5.25 tip before I even saw the fries. Needless to say my 4 year old grandson was disappointed and I don’t think I will be back.
… moreMichele Holden
I came to eat there for the first time last Sat 8/10/24. Never been there before and got a coupon so wanted to try it out. Brought my mom with me. Food was pretty good ,but there were 2 men cooking in the kitchen who were so rude and argumentative with the lady taking our order. Who was there that day to help out she said because of a callout. She mentioned she hadn’t been in there for months due to a couple of surgeries. She made a small mistake on my order (not a big deal at all) but when she took it to one of the men preparing food he said” why did you put bacon on this order if she didn’t ask for bacon. Heavy sigh and walked away. I felt sorry for her because she was in there helping them out and he was very RUDE. I asked for a box to take left overs and when she went to get me a box the other man preparing food snapped at her and said we don’t use those anymore” put his kitchen tool down and grumbled when he walked away. They treated her like she was an idiot and getting scolded in front of customers was UNCALLED FOR!! i was please with my sub but don’t think I will be returning because if that’s how they treat their employees its no place I want to eat. And i love supporting our local Mom and Pop shopes.
Sounds like they have been in business for years and been successful but treatment of employees needs to change.
… moreSounds like they have been in business for years and been successful but treatment of employees needs to change.