Chris Pantani
Indian Neck Pizza is a true gem! Family-owned and operated, they serve up traditional Italian dishes alongside incredible New Haven-style pizza. Be sure to try the eggplant and spinach pizza—it’s a standout. Whether you’re dining in, enjoying the patio on a warm day, or grabbing takeout or delivery, every meal feels fresh and made with care. Bonus: bring your own wine or beer to make the experience even better! A must-visit for anyone who loves authentic Italian flavors.
… moreGabriel B
Absolutely fantastic pizza! We tried half Bianco (fresh broccoli and ricotta) and half Mozzarella Basil Tomato, and both were outstanding. The crust was perfectly thin and crisp (not burned!), with fresh, high-quality toppings that made each bite delicious!!!
Beyond the great food, the experience was made even better by Vicenzo, one of the owners, who took the time to come over and chat with us, such a friendly and welcoming touch! The espresso was also amazing, authentically Italian, rich, and smooth, without the bitterness you find elsewhere.
Plus, the prices are very reasonable for the quality you get. Highly recommend this place if you’re looking for amazing pizza and a great dining experience in Branford. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreDelilah Royka
Words can only describe how TERRIBLE of an experience I’ve had here. I called in to order a pizza for delivery, a medium pepperoni. Seems simple enough, I was told pizza would arrive in 45 minutes. Mind you it’s 5 PM on a Sunday. My sister had just moved back in town from Boston, so I was hoping this would be a nice meal to share about our time away from each other. About 50-55 minutes later I call back and ask about the status of my delivery, was given straight up attitude and not even an estimate of how much longer it would take, the guy was EXTREMELY rude. Over an hour 10 minutes I’d say has gone by in total and we start to give up hope on our pizza when we hear a knock at our door. The delivery guy was nice, but our pizza didn’t even look like pizza, I’ll let the photo explain itself. The taste could not make up for the looks or the service we received, crust and pepperoni were overcooked, and very greasy. Needless to say I will NOT be ordering again.
… moreLidia LoPresto
Such great pizza, could not even get a picture fast enough! We love the firehouse pizza, but all of their pizza options, subs and dinners are amazing. Our favorite place!
… moreTheresa Dobson
it has been years since I have had a calzone and was recently dissapoonted when i got one ELSEWHERE
If you want a calzone this is THE ONLY PLACE TO GO !! they are delicious perfectly made ! huge and oozimg with fresh ricotta! (a little pricey if you add in items , I recommend spinach and eggplant , but 100% worth every penny! )
… moreTywana Hamilton
WARNING!!! Do not use SLICE to have your order delivered. I placed an order here last night and the driver stole my food. The driver intentionally waited until the restaurant was closed to mark the order as complete, so that they wouldn’t get a call from the restaurant.
… moreSofia
The best pizza i have ever eaten in my entire life. The workers are so nice. I had such great service.
… moreClaire Crisp
Really good pizza!! We placed a larger to-go order and they had it ready right on time. Not sure if they turn their phones off or don’t accept out of state numbers but they’ll serve you if you go in person.
… moreFrancine Jensen
When I’m near Branford, this is my go-to place. Excellent pizza and worth the trip. Margarita all the way! Lots of choices.
… morePresto
Ordered a small onion and sausage pizza here and it was delicious. The sausage was ground up so it spread across the crust and the onion used was red onion, a very nice addition.
The pizza took less than 15minutes and I was sure glad I gave this small coastal pizza joint a try!
… more